The Collected Poems of Rupert Brooke

Rupert Brooke was both fair to see and winning in his ways. There was at the first contact both bloom and charm; and most of all there was life. To use the word his friends describe him by, he was vivid . This vitality, though manifold in expression, is felt primarily in his sensations — surprise mingled with delight —
One after one, like tasting a sweet food.
This is life's first fine rapture . It makes him patient to name over those myriad things (each of which seems like a fresh discovery) curious but potent, and above all common, that he loved , — he the Great Lover . Lover of what, then? Why, of
White plates and cups clean-gleaming, Ringed with blue lines, —
and the like, through thirty lines of exquisite words; and he is captivated by the multiple brevity of these vignettes of sense, keen, momentary, ecstatic with the morning dip of youth in the wonderful stream. The poem is a catalogue of vital sensations and dear names as well. All these have been my loves.
The spring of these emotions is the natural body, but it sends pulsations far into the spirit. The feeling rises in direct observation, but it is soon aware of the outlets of the sky . He sees objects practically unrelated, and links them in strings; or he sees them pictorially; or, he sees pictures immersed as it were in an atmosphere of thought. When the process is complete, the thought suggests the picture and is its origin. Then the Great Lover revisits the bottom of the monstrous world, and imaginatively and thoughtfully recreates that strange under-sea, whose glooms and gleams and muds are well known to him as a strong and delighted swimmer; or, at the last, drifts through the dream of a South Sea lagoon, still with a philosophical question in his mouth. Yet one can hardly speak of completion . These are real first flights. What we have in this volume is not so much a work of art as an artist in his birth trying the wings of genius.
The poet loves his new-found element. He clings to mortality; to life, not thought; or, as he puts it, to the concrete, — let the abstract go pack! There's little comfort in the wise, he ends. But in the unfolding of his precocious spirit, the literary control comes uppermost; his boat, finding its keel, swings to the helm of mind. How should it be otherwise for a youth well-born, well-bred, in college air? Intellectual primacy showed itself to him in many wandering loves , fine lover that he was; but in the end he was an intellectual lover, and the magnet seems to have been especially powerful in the ghosts of the men of wit , Donne, Marvell — erudite lords of language, poets in another world than ours, a less ample ether , a less divine air , our fathers thought, but poets of eternity . A quintessential drop of intellect is apt to be in poetic blood. How Platonism fascinates the poets, like a shining bait! Rupert Brooke will have none of it; but at a turn of the verse he is back at it, examining, tasting, refusing. In those alternate drives of the thought in his South Sea idyl (clever as tennis play) how he slips from phenomenon to idea and reverses, happy with either, it seems, were t'other dear charmer away . How bravely he tries to free himself from the cling of earth, at the close of the Great Lover ! How little he succeeds! His muse knew only earthly tongues, — so far as he understood.