A. R. McALLISTER
The Pioneer Leader of School Bands
The High School principal, hurrying out to lunch stopped at the foot of the stairs and listened in astonishment.
“Horns and drums,” he muttered, “I’ll have to see what is going on down here!”
He followed the sounds easily and through the rear door of the manual training room saw a group of boys, seated on nail kegs and boxes, playing various instruments. A stocky young man was busily directing them.
The principal smiled and quickly turned away. “Mac has certainly started something this time!” he said to himself. But not until years later did he realize that he had seen in its very beginning, Joliet’s famous School Band under its leader, who became the Dean of the School Band movement. This was the commencement of the greatest wave of music ever to sweep the country.
A. R. McAllister was born on a farm near Joliet, Illinois. As a very small boy he was fond of making music. Seldom was he seen without a cornstalk fiddle or an elder flute.
To the dismay of his thrifty Scotch father, Archie sold his pet pig for eight dollars and immediately sent a request to a mail order house for a cornet costing that exact sum. However, the elder McAllister was pleased that his son sent a C.O.D. order. Evidently he was going to be sure to get the worth of his money.
The boy tooted away faithfully and was soon able to play tunes. His next thought was to teach other boys in the neighborhood and organize a band. The group made good progress and had fun besides, although some of the neighbors declared “That McAllister boy does nothing but fool around with music and will never amount to anything.” But the first year of its existence this new band entered a contest and won the first prize—a music rack. The second year they again won first prize—this time a five-dollar bill.
Then Arch grew restless. He wondered which to follow—business or music? He loved music but he wanted to make money quickly, so he took a course in business school and got a job as auditor of the street car company. That failed to satisfy him. He sold his cornet and went “out west” to a fruit ranch in Montana. There he worked into a different line, woodworking, building and making things with his hands. He felt he had a real talent for this sort of work and soon went back to Chicago to teach manual training in a Jewish training school.
A few years later McAllister accepted a position as Manual Training teacher in the High School in Joliet, Illinois. Here he seized upon an opportunity to get back into music work. He rounded up twelve boys who liked music but knew nothing at all about it. They gathered up a dozen used instruments, and McAllister began to teach and train the High School Band, which at first was looked upon solely as an aid to the football team. Their lessons were given outside of school hours and for some time McAllister received no extra salary.
The boys worked faithfully, their membership increased and their ability improved, but no one knew much about them. In 1920 the Joliet Rotary Club took McAllister and his band to Atlantic City to their convention. There they attracted much attention.
When the first national school band contest was held in Chicago, twenty-five bands took part in the affair sponsored by the Music Instrument Manufacturers. The Joliet, Illinois Township Band (Grade School) directed by A. R. McAllister, easily won first prize.
The Joliet Band continued to win first place in contests in 1925, 26, 27, and 1928. Then they were barred from entering to give other bands a chance. But when they re-entered they came out first in each contest.
The Joliet High School Band after having won many state and national contests was finally given an honor no other organization will ever have: the first national school band trophy ever awarded in the world.
Bandmaster McAllister took his band on many pleasurable concert trips, but the outstanding, unforgettable jaunt was a whole week’s engagement playing in Radio City Music Hall in New York in March, 1936. The Joliet Band also played at the Metropolitan Opera House, in Philadelphia and in Washington, D. C. on the steps of the East front of Capitol Building where they were cheered by Congressmen and Senators.
Many honors came to McAllister also. He was elected the first President of the National School Band Association, organized in 1926, and served for eight years. He was president of the American Bandmasters’ Association, and prominent in every organization connected with school music.
A. R. McAllister died September 30, 1944, loved and honored by many thousands of people, young and old. He was an extremely modest man, yet he had one of the most brilliant careers in the history of instrumental music education in America’s public schools.
McAllister was not a University man; he never graduated from a music school, never had a doctor’s nor a master’s degree. Yet he created one of the greatest high school bands in the world and was known and loved by millions of young Americans.
As We Go Marching On
And so they have all marched—the military bands, Sousa, Gilmore, Pryor, Conway, the town and community bands, and the college and school bands. They have marched right into the hearts of the people, young and old, rich or poor, from Maine to California.
“All these bands have something in common,” wrote Dr. Edwin Franko Goldman. “They are manifestations of a popular musical culture which finds in them an expression of something not provided by any other type of concert organization. Most important, they are a form of local, or regional, or national organization fulfilling a genuine community need and serving a genuine community interest....
“The band has introduced many people to music—both listeners and performers. A band plays for the masses with mixed tastes. It is close to the people, bringing many into firsthand contact with live music.”
Bands are able to perform in outdoor concerts, football games, parades and on many varied occasions. They stand or march when they play, inspiring action. Informal, outdoor band concerts will always remain great popular attractions for few concert halls are large enough to accommodate all the people who want to hear live band music. Besides, outdoor band concerts are free.
The United States is today’s greatest musical nation, and bands have played a great part in developing and spreading the love and understanding of music among young and old in this country. A band is a strong music educational force; a school or college band has the widest opportunity in the world to personally convey music to the people.
With the extensive program of concerts, radio and recording engagements, dances, football pageants, as well as the many regular functions in which the college bandsmen take part, a wealth of opportunity is given a college student interested in gaining experience in music.
In a more limited way this is true with high school bands. School bands are constantly being required to play at many public affairs in their community and school. And with ability to play in the band there comes to each bandsman a sense of citizenship, of belonging to an organization which is considered necessary to the success of public enterprises, of pride and importance in having a part in civic affairs.
People who are qualified to know state that the number of town, municipal, and industrial bands is decreasing, but it is gratifying to learn that these same authorities have found that college and school bands are rapidly increasing in all parts of the country. These organizations are recognized developments of our American culture. A national survey reveals that in 1951 there were 75,000 bands in the United States. And there were fully 9,000,000 high school boys and girls belonging to school bands.
The activities of the high school bands are unified by the National High School Band Association; the musicians composing the Music Educators’ National Conference exercise helpful supervision. The school band is recognized as one of the greatest agencies for teaching democracy and good citizenship, as well as inducing a nation-wide love for music.
“Music,” says the Preface to the 1940 Resolutions of the Music Educators’ National Conference, “is an essential factor in building a cultured and happy people. It belongs to everyone.”
The shrill, noisy brass bands of early days have been supplanted by fine symphonic bands. Master instrument makers have invented a variety of new band instruments capable of producing many novel and artistic effects. Gifted musicians are composing and arranging music especially suited to these various instruments. The band has proved its worth and earned its right to the large place which it now occupies in our American way of life. A band is a necessary part of every community.
And just as the whole future of America is dependent upon the young people of today, in like manner, the fate of the bands of tomorrow depends upon the musical education and training received by the boys and girls of this present time. Youth must go marching on.
Throughout the ages man has found music to be essential in voicing his own innate sense of beauty. Music is not a thing apart from man: it is the spiritualized expression of his finest and best inner self.
There is no one wholly unresponsive to the elevating appeal of music. If only the right contacts and experiences are provided, every life can find in music some answer to its fundamental need for aesthetic and emotional outlet.
The Music Educators’ National Conference, at its national meeting held at Los Angeles in 1940, in full acceptance of its responsibilities as the representative and champion of progressive thought and practice in music education, pledged its united efforts in behalf of a broad and constructive program for music education for the youth of America. The organization recommended that the following measures be taken in the direction of general improvement:
1. Provision in all the schools of our country, both urban and rural, for music experience and training for every child, in accordance with his interests and capacities.
2. Continued effort to improve music teaching, and to provide adequate equipment.
3. Carry-over of school music training into the musical, social and home life of the community, as a vital part of its cultural, recreational and leisure-time activities.
4. Increased opportunities for adult education in music.
5. Improvement of choir and congregational singing in the churches and Sunday schools; increased use of instrumental ensemble playing in connection with church activities.
6. Encouragement and support of all worthwhile musical enterprises as desirable factors in making our country a better place in which to live.
At the 1951 national meeting of the Music Educators’ National Conference, an optimistic view of the future of school music was generally expressed.
Books, Magazines, and Newspapers Consulted—
Annals of Music in America by Henry C. Lahee. Boston, Mass.: Marshall Jones Company, 1922
ARGOSY. Popular Publications, Inc., 205 East 42nd Street, New York, N. Y.
Band At-ten-tion! by Mark H. Hindsley. Chicago, Illinois: Gamble Hinged Music Company, 1932
Band on Parade, The, by Raymond F. Dvorak. New York: Carl Fischer, Inc., 1937
Band’s Music, The, by Richard F. Goldman. New York: Pitman Publishing Corp., 1938
Christian Science Monitor, 1 Norway Street, Boston, Mass.
College and University Bands; Their Organization and Administration, by La Verne Buckton. New York: Teachers College, Columbia University, 1929
COLLIER’S. Crowell-Collier Publishing Company, 640 Fifth Avenue, New York, N. Y.
Concert Band, The, by Richard F. Goldman. New York: Rinehart & Company, Inc., 1946
Current Biography. H. W. Wilson Company, 950 University Avenue, New York, N. Y.
Etude. Bryn Mawr, Penna.
GOOD HOUSEKEEPING. Hearst Magazines, Inc., 57th Street & 8th Avenue, New York, N. Y.
Gridiron Pageantry, by Charles B. Righter. New York: Carl Fischer, Inc., 1941
“Here Comes the Band!” by Ray Giles. New York: Harper & Brothers, 1936
History of American Music, The, by L. C. Elson. New York: The Macmillan Company, 1904
History of Military Music in America, A, by William C. White. New York: The Exposition Press, 1945
History of Public School Music in the United States, by Edward B. Birge. New York: Oliver Ditson Company, 1937
History of the National Peace Jubilee and Great Musical Festival, by P. S. Gilmore. Published by the author, Boston, 1869
HOBBIES. Camden, New Jersey (Merged into COLLECTORS’ JOURNAL, Milford, Conn.)
HOLIDAY. Curtis Publishing Company, Independence Square, Philadelphia, Penna.
How I Became a Cornetist, by Herbert L. Clarke. St. Louis, Missouri: J. L. Huber, 1934
Instrumental Music in the Public Schools, by T. F. Norman. Philadelphia, Penna.: Presser Company, 1941
INTERNATIONAL MUSICIAN, St. Louis, Missouri and Newark, New Jersey.
JACOBS BAND MONTHLY, W. Jacobs, Boston, Mass.
JACOBS ORCHESTRA MONTHLY, W. Jacobs, Boston, Mass.
LIFE. Time, Inc., 9 Rockefeller Plaza, New York, N. Y.
LITERARY DIGEST, New York, N. Y.
Military Band, The, by George Miller. London: Novello & Company, Ltd. 1912
MODERN MUSIC, New York, N. Y.
Monarchs of Minstrelsy from “Daddy” Rice to Date, by Edward LeRoy Rice. New York: Kenny Publishing Company, 1911
MUSIC AND LETTERS, London, England
MUSIC DEALER, New York, N. Y.
MUSIC EDUCATORS’ JOURNAL, 64 E. Jackson Blvd., Chicago, Illinois
MUSICIAN, 14 East 47th Street, New York, N. Y.
MUSICAL OBSERVER, Boston, Mass.
MUSIC COURIER. Music Periodicals Corp., 119 West 57th Street, New York, N. Y.
Music in Industry, by Kenneth S. Clark. New York: National Bureau for the Advancement of Music, Inc., 1929
MUSIC QUARTERLY, New York, N. Y.
NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC. National Geographical Society, Washington, D. C.
NEWSWEEK, New York, N. Y.
New York Times, 229 West 43rd Street, New York, N. Y.
NEW YORK TIMES MAGAZINE. New York Times, 229 W. 43rd Street, New York, N. Y.
NEW YORKER, New York, N. Y.
OUTLOOK. The Outlook Company, New York, N. Y.
PRESTO MUSIC TIMES, Chicago, Illinois
POPULAR MECHANICS. Popular Mechanics Company, 200 E. Ontario St., Chicago, Ill.
POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY. Popular Science Publishing Company, New York, N. Y.
SATURDAY EVENING POST. Curtis Publishing Company, Independence Square, Philadelphia, Penna.
SCHOLASTIC MAGAZINE. Scholastic Corporation, 351 Fourth Avenue, New York, N. Y.
SCHOOL MUSICIAN, Chicago, Illinois
Success in Teaching School Orchestras and Bands, by Charles B. Righter. Minneapolis, Minn.: Paul A. Schmitt Music Company, 1945
TIME. Time, Inc., 9 Rockefeller Plaza, New York, N. Y.
TOP NOTES, East Stroudsburg, Penna. (Merged into MUSICAL DIGEST)
TRAVEL. Travel Magazine, Inc., 115 West 45th Street, New York, N. Y.
Washington Evening Star, 1101 Penna. Avenue, N. W., Washington, D. C.
Washington Post, 1515 L Street, N. W., Washington, D. C.
WOMAN’S HOME COMPANION. The Crowell-Collier Publishing Company, 640 Fifth Avenue, New York, N. Y.
The verse at the beginning of Chapter V is reprinted from “The History of The Salvation Army” by Robert Sandall by permission of the author and Thomas Nelson & Sons, Ltd., Edinburgh.
TRANSCRIBER’S NOTES:
Obvious typographical errors have been corrected.
Inconsistencies in hyphenation have been standardized.
Incorrect page numbers in the Table of Contents have been corrected.
New original cover art included with this eBook is granted to the public domain.
Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.