i. VENTS
A large number of vents rise through the Carboniferous rocks of Scotland. Some of these are not associated with any interbedded volcanic material, so that their geological age cannot be more precisely defined than by saying that they must be later than the particular formations which they pierce. Some of them, as I shall endeavour to show, are in all probability of Permian age. But many, from their position with reference to the nearest intercalated lavas and tuffs, are to be regarded as almost certainly belonging to the Carboniferous period. Those which are immediately surrounded by sheets of lava and tuff, similar in character to the materials in the vents themselves, may without hesitation be connected with these sheets as marking the orifices of discharge.
The vents of the puys are in general much less than those of the plateaux. Their smallest examples measure only a few yards in diameter, their largest seldom much exceed half a mile.[452]
[452] The following measurements of necks belonging to the puy-eruptions in different parts of Scotland are taken from the 6-inch field-maps of the Geological Survey:—Saline Hill, Fife, 6000 × 4000 feet; Binn of Burntisland, 3500 × 1500; Hill of Beath, Fife, 2900 × 1550; Binns Hill, Linlithgowshire, 4800 × 2200; Tor Hill, Ecclesmachan, Linlithgowshire, 1900 × 1000 ([Fig. 155]); Great Moor, near Maiden Pap, Roxburghshire, 2600 × 2400; Tinnis Hill, Liddesdale, 1500 × 1000; Roan Fell, Liddesdale, 300 × 200; Hadsgarth Burn, Liddesdale, 250 × 200; Dalbate Burn, 250 × 120. In some cases, especially in those of the larger necks, it is probable that the tuff belongs to more than one funnel. Thus the Binn of Burntisland almost certainly includes two necks, a smaller one to the west and a much larger one to the east. Saline Hill may also conceal more than one vent. But in the continuous mass of tuff at the surface it is at present impossible to determine precisely the number and boundaries of the several orifices.
The dislocations of the Carboniferous system are probably on the whole later than its volcanic phenomena. It is at least certain that the lavas and tuffs of the puys have been extensively faulted, like the surrounding sedimentary strata, and the vents seldom show any apparent relation to faults. It may sometimes be observed, however, that the vents are arranged in lines suggestive of fissures underneath. A remarkable instance of the linear distribution is furnished by the chain of necks which extends from the Vale of the Tweed at Melrose south-westwards across the watershed and down Liddesdale. The most notable part of this line lies among the uplands to the east of the Old Mosspaul Inn at the head of the Ewes Water. A string of masses of agglomerate has there solidified in a fissure among the Silurian greywackes and shales, running in a north-easterly direction for several miles. The largest connected mass of agglomerate is 4700 feet long, and from 350 to 600 feet broad (see No. 1 in [Fig. 22]). That this curious vent, or connected line of vents along a great fissure, belongs to the puy-eruptions of Liddesdale is shown by the abundant fragments of yellow sandstone and cement-stone which occur in the agglomerate.[453]
[453] These facts were ascertained by Mr. Peach in mapping the ground for the Geological Survey. See Sheet 17, Scotland.
Most frequently the vents are distributed irregularly in groups. As examples of this arrangement I may cite those of the west of Fife, of West Lothian and of the north of Ayrshire.
A convenient classification of the vents may be made by dividing them into four groups according to the nature of the material that now fills them: 1st, Necks of non-volcanic debris; 2nd, Necks of tuff and agglomerate; 3rd, Necks of similar materials, but with a central plug of basalt; 4th, Bosses of basalt or other lava, without agglomerate or tuff.
1. Necks of Non-volcanic Debris.—In a few instances the orifices of eruption have been filled up entirely with non-volcanic debris. They have served as funnels for the discharge of explosive vapours only, without the expulsion of any solid volcanic materials. At least no trace of fragmentary lavas is met with in them, nor are any beds of tuff or lava intercalated among the surrounding strata. Some interesting examples of this kind were laid bare in the open ironstone-workings near Carluke in Lanarkshire. They were circular in ground-plan, descended vertically into the strata, and were somewhat wider at the top of the quarry than at the bottom. They were filled with angular pieces of Carboniferous sandstone, shale, limestone, ironstone and other rocks, these materials being rudely arranged with a dip towards the centre of the neck, where the blocks were largest in size. Though no fragments of igneous rocks were observed among the debris, a few string-like veins of "white trap," or altered basalt, were seen to traverse the agglomerate here and there. The necks and the strata surrounding them were highly impregnated with pyrites and sulphate of lime.[454]
[454] Prof. Jas. Geikie, Mem. Geol. Surv. Scotland, Explanation of Sheet 23, p. 39.
Fig. 143.—Section of volcanic vent at East Grange, Perthshire coal-field, constructed by Mr. B. N. Peach from the rocks exposed in a railway-cutting, and from plans of ironstone- and coal-pits.
1. Three feet coal; 2. Ontake coal; 3. Upper and Lower Black-band Ironstones; 4. Index Limestone; 5. Gas Coal and Janet Peat Coal; 6. Calmy Limestone; 7. Neck.
A vent of the same nature, but on a much larger scale, has been mapped by Mr. Peach in the south of Perthshire, near East Grange, where it rises through the higher coal-bearing part of the Carboniferous Limestone series ([Fig. 143]). It has been encountered in the mining of coal and ironstone, and its cross-section has been ascertained in the underground workings which have been carried up to its margin. It measures 1500 feet in diameter from east to west and 2000 feet from north to south. It does not appear ever to have emitted any ashes or lava. Mr. Peach found it filled with dark sandy crumbling clays, full of fragments of sandstone, shale and coal. These sediments are arranged in layers that dip in the same general direction as the strata surrounding the vent. They contain abundant calcareous nodules of all sizes from that of a hazel-nut up to concretions 18 feet in diameter. The clays likewise include many of the common shells and crinoids of the Carboniferous Limestone sea, and the same fossils are enclosed in the nodules. A remarkable feature in this vent is the occurrence of abundant vertical rents, which have been filled partly with the same material that forms the nodules, and partly with sandstone.
The formation of the neck took place after the deposition of the Index Limestone, and probably about the time of the accumulation of the next limestone, which lies immediately to the west somewhat higher in the series. It would appear that the eruption which produced this funnel gave forth only gaseous explosions, and occurred on the sea-floor; that the low crater-walls were washed down to such an extent that the sea entered and carried some of its characteristic organisms into the lagoon or maar within; further, that as the silt gathered inside, successive subsidences occurred, whereby the sediment was rent by cracks into which sand and calcareous mud were washed from above.[455]
[455] The vent is shown in Sheet 39, Geol. Surv. Scotland.
Many necks occur wherein non-volcanic materials, though not forming the whole of the agglomerate, make up by far the larger part, with only a slight admixture of volcanic tuff between them. Among the Burntisland necks of Fife, for instance, abundant fragments of the well-marked cyprid limestone and shale may be observed, while at Niddry in Linlithgowshire blocks several yards in length, and consisting of different layers of shale and cement-stone still adhering to each other, may be seen imbedded at all angles in the tuff.
Where only the debris of non-volcanic rocks occupies a vent, we may infer that the volcanic action was limited to the explosion of steam, whereby the rocks were dislocated, and an orifice communicating with the surface was drilled through them, and that while no true volcanic rock in such a case appeared, the pipe was filled up to perhaps not far from the surface by the falling back of the shattered detritus. A little greater intensity or farther prolongation of the volcanic action would bring the column of lava up the funnel, and allow its upper part to be blown out as dust and lapilli; while still more vigorous activity would be marked by the rise of the lava into rents of the cone or its actual outflow at the surface. Every gradation in this scale of progress may be detected among the Carboniferous volcanoes of the basin of the Firth of Forth.
2. Necks of Tuff and Agglomerate.—The majority of the necks connected with the puys consist of tuff or agglomerate. Externally they generally appear as smooth rounded grassy hills that rise disconnected from other eminences. In some districts their materials consist of a greenish granular often stratified tuff, enclosing rounded balls of various basic lavas and pieces of sandstone, shale, limestone or other strata through which they have been drilled. This is their usual character in the Forth region. But in some cases, the tuff becomes a coarse agglomerate, made up partly of large blocks of basalt and other volcanic rocks and partly of the sedimentary strata around them, of which large masses, many cubic yards in bulk, may be seen. Among the enclosed fragments it is not unusual to find pieces of older stratified tuff. These resemble in general petrographical character parts of the tuff among which they are imbedded. Sometimes they have been derived from previous tuffs which, interstratified among the sedimentary strata, had been broken up by the opening of a new vent. But probably in most cases they should be regarded as portions of the volcanic debris which, having solidified inside the crater, was blown out in fragments by subsequent explosions. In a modern volcano a considerable amount of stratified tuff may be formed inside the crater. The ashes and stones thrown out during a period of activity fall not only on the outer slopes of the cone, but on the steep inner declivities of the crater, where they arrange themselves in beds that dip at high angles towards the crater bottom. This feature is well seen in some of the extinct cones in the Neapolitan district. In some of the Scottish puys the tuff is stratified and has tumbled down into a highly inclined or vertical position ([Fig. 145]).
Fig. 144.—View of the Binn of Burntisland—a volcanic neck of agglomerate. (This illustration and Figs. [145], [152], [153], [164], [166] and [168] are from photographs taken by Mr. Robert Lunn for the Geological Survey.)
As a good illustration of the variety and relative proportions of the ejected blocks in the green tuff of the puy-vents, I may cite the following table of percentages which I took many years ago in the tuff which rises through the Cement-stone group on the beach at the Heads of Ayr.
| Diabase and basalt | 57 | per cent. |
| Older tuff | 3 | " |
| Andesite (probably from Old Red Sandstone volcanic series of the neighbourhood) | 14 | " |
| Limestone (cement-stone, etc.) | 20 | " |
| Shale | 3 | " |
| Sandstone | 2 | " |
| Fossil wood | 1 | " |
| 100 |
While many examples might be cited where no molten rock of any kind has risen in the vents, or where at least all the visible materials are of a fragmentary character, yet small veins and dykes of basalt have not infrequently been injected into the tuff or agglomerate. These seldom run far, and usually present a more or less tortuous course. Thus, on the south front of the Binn of Burntisland (Figs. [166], [168]) a number of basalt-dykes, which vary in breadth from five or six feet to scarcely so many inches, bifurcate and rapidly disappear in the tuff, one of them ascending tortuously to near the top of the cliff. They at once recall the appearance of the well-known dykes in the great crater wall of Somma.
Though not by any means the largest or most perfect of the vents in the basin of the Firth of Forth, the Binn of Burntisland, of which a view is given in [Fig. 144], may be cited in illustration of their general characters. It presents in detail some of the most strikingly volcanic aspects of scenery anywhere to be seen in that region. Consisting of a dull green granular volcanic tuff, it rises abruptly out of the Lower Carboniferous formations to a height of 631 feet above the sea. The southern edge of this neck has been so extensively denuded, that it presents steep craggy slopes and rugged precipices, which descend from the very summit of the cone to the plain below—a vertical distance of nearly 500 feet. Here and there the action of atmospheric waste has hollowed out huge crater-like chasms in the crumbling tuff. Standing in one of these, the geologist can realize what must have been the aspect of the interior of these ancient Carboniferous volcanic cones. The scene at once reminds him of the crater-walls of a modern or not long extinct volcano. The dull-green rudely stratified tuff rises around in verdureless crumbling sheets of naked rock, roughened by the innumerable blocks of lava, which form so conspicuous an element in the composition of the mass. The ribs or veins of columnar basalt run up the declivities as black shattered walls. The frosts and rains of many centuries have restored to the tuff its original loose gravelly character. It disintegrates rapidly, and rolls down the slopes in long grey lines of volcanic sand, precisely as it no doubt did at the time of its ejection, when it fell on the outer and inner declivities of the original cone. Some of these features may be partly realized from [Fig. 145], which represents a portion of the south front of the hill. Sections of this neck are given in Figs. [149] and [159].
(3) Necks of Tuff or Agglomerate with a Central Plug of Basalt or other Lava.—It has often happened that, after the explosions in a vent have begun to decrease in vigour, or have at last ceased, lava has risen in the chimney and finally sealed it up. In such cases the main mass of the rock may consist of tuff or agglomerate, which the enfeebled volcanic activity has been unable to expel from the orifice, while a plug of basalt, dolerite, or even more basic material, of much smaller dimensions, may have risen up the pipe in the centre or towards one side. Binns Hill, West Lothian, the Beath and Saline Hills of Fife, and Tinnis Hill in Liddesdale are good examples of this structure. (See Figs. [26], [148], [149] and [174]).
(4) Necks of Basalt, Dolerite, etc.—In other cases no fragmental material is present in the vent, or possibly traces of it may be seen here and there adhering to the walls of the funnel, the prevailing rock being some form of lava. Necks of this kind are much less frequent in the puy- than in the plateau-type. But examples may be found in several districts. The most striking with which I am acquainted are those which form so picturesque a group of isolated cones around the volcanic basin of Limerick, to be afterwards described (Figs. [195], [196]). The vents there have been filled by the uprise of much more acid rocks than the lavas of the basin, for, as I have already stated, they include even quartziferous trachytes. In the basin of the Firth of Forth some prominent bosses of basalt probably mark the sites of former vents, such as Dunearn Hill in Fife, the Castle Rock of Edinburgh, and Galabraes Hill near Bathgate. Some striking vents which occur in the Jedburgh district, in the debateable land between the plateau series on the east and the puy-series on the west, show the nearly complete usurpation of the funnel by basalt, but with portions of the tuff still remaining visible.
Fig. 145.—View of part of the cliffs of vertical agglomerate, Binn of Burntisland.
Relation of the Necks to the Rocks through which they rise.—A remarkable feature among the Carboniferous and Permian vents of central Scotland is presented by the effect which has been produced on the strata immediately surrounding them. In the interior of the country this effect is often concealed by herbage, but where the rocks have been laid bare by the sea it may be most instructively studied. In such shore-sections, a singular change of dip is often observable among the strata round the edge of a vent. No matter what may be the normal inclination at the locality, the beds are bent sharply down towards the wall of the neck, and are frequently placed on end. This structure (shown in Figs. [24], [143], [147], [148] and [149]) is precisely the reverse of what might have been anticipated, and can hardly be due to upward volcanic explosions. It is frequently associated with considerable metamorphism in the disturbed strata. Shales are converted into porcellanite or various jaspery rocks, according to their composition. Sandstones pass into quartzite, with its characteristic lustrous fracture. It is common to find vents surrounded with a ring of this contact-metamorphism, which, from the hardness and frequently vertical or highly inclined bedding of its strata, stands up prominently on the beach (as in Figs. [126] and [210]), and serves to mark the position of the necks from a distance.
I have not been able to find an altogether satisfactory explanation of this inward dip of the strata around vents. Taking it in connection with the metamorphism, I am inclined to believe that it arose after the close of the long-continued volcanic action which had hardened the rocks around the volcanic pipe, and as the result of some kind of subsidence within the vent. The outpouring of so much tuff and lava as escaped from many of the volcanoes would doubtless often be apt to produce cavities underneath them, and on the decay of volcanic energy there might be a tendency in the solid or cavernous column filling up the funnel, to settle down by mere gravitation. So firmly, however, did much of it cohere to the sides of the pipe, that if it sank at all, it could hardly fail to drag down a portion of these sides. So general is this evidence of downward movement in all the volcanic districts of Scotland where the necks have been adequately exposed, that the structure may be regarded as normal to these volcanic vents. It has been observed among the shore-sections of the volcanoes of the Auckland district, New Zealand. Mr. C. Heaphy, in an interesting paper upon that district, gives a drawing of a crater and lava-stream abutting on the edge of a cliff where the strata bend down towards the point of eruption, as in the numerous cases in Scotland.[456]
[456] Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. 1860, vol. xvi. p. 245.
Evidence for the probable subærial Character of some of the Cones or Puys of Tuff.—From the stratigraphical data furnished by the basin of the Firth of Forth, it is certain that this region, during a great part of the Carboniferous period, existed as a wide shallow lagoon, sometimes overspread with sea-water deep enough to allow of the growth of corals, crinoids, and brachiopods; at other times, shoaled to such an extent with sand and mud as to be covered with wide jungles of a lepidodendroid and calamitoid vegetation. As volcanic action went on interruptedly during a vast section of that period, the vents, though generally submarine, may occasionally have been subærial. Indeed, we may suppose that the same vent might begin as a subaqueous orifice and continue to eject volcanic materials, until, as these rose above the level of the water, the vent became subærial. An instance of a submarine vent has been cited from the Perthshire coal-field ([p. 426]).
Among the evidence which may be collected to show that some Carboniferous volcanoes probably rose as insular cones of tuff above the surrounding waters, the structure of the tuff in many necks may be cited, for it suggests subærial rather than subaqueous stratification. The way in which the stones, large and small, are grouped together in lenticular seams may be paralleled on the slopes of many a modern volcano. Another indication of this mode of origin is supplied by the traces of wood to be met with in some of the tuff-necks. The vents of Fife and Linlithgowshire contain these traces sometimes in great abundance. The specimens are always angular fragments, and are frequently encrusted with calcite.[457] Sometimes they present the glossy fracture and clear ligneous structure shown by sticks of well-made wood charcoal. In a neck at St. Magdalen's, near Linlithgow, the wood fragments occur as numerous black chips. So far as can be ascertained from the slices already prepared for the microscope, the wood is always coniferous. These woody fragments seldom occur in the interstratified tuffs or in the associated strata where Stigmaria, Lepidodendron, etc., are common. They are specially characteristic of the necks and adjacent tuffs. The parent trees may have grown on the volcanic cones, which as dry insular spots would support a different vegetation from the club-mosses and reeds of the surrounding swamps. As the fragments occur in the tuffs which, on the grounds already stated, may be held to have been deposited within the crater, they seem to point to intervals of volcanic quiescence, when the dormant or extinct craters were filled with a terrestrial flora, as Vesuvius was between the years 1500 and 1631, when no eruptions took place. Some of the cones, such as Saline Hill and the Binn of Burntisland, may have risen several hundred feet above the water. Clothed with dark pine woods, they would form a notable feature in the otherwise monotonous scenery of central Scotland during the Carboniferous period.
[457] The largest I have observed is a portion of a stem about two feet long and six inches broad, in the (Permian?) neck below St. Monan's church.
Fig. 146.—Diagram of buried volcanic cone near Dalry, Ayrshire. Constructed from information obtained in mining operations.
1. Hurlet Limestone. 2. Clayband Ironstone. 3. Black-band Ironstone. 4. Borestone Coal. 5. Wee Coal. 6. Highfield Limestone. 7 and 8. Thin Limestones. 9. Linn Limestone. 10. Volcanic neck and cone of tuff.
Entombment of the Volcanic Cones and their relation to the bedded Lavas and Tuffs.—From the facts above detailed, it is evident that in most cases the necks represent, as it were, the mere denuded stumps of the volcanoes. As the puys took their rise in areas which, on the whole, were undergoing a movement of subsidence, they were eventually submerged and buried under sedimentary accumulations. Their loose ashes would be apt to be washed down and strewn over the sea-bottom, so that only the lower and inner part of a cone might remain. We can hardly hope to discover any of the actual craters among these volcanic relics. The cones having been submerged and buried under many hundred feet of sediment, their present position at the surface is due to subsequent elevation and prolonged denudation. It is obvious that there must still be many buried cones which the progress of denudation has not yet reached. Some of these have been revealed in the course of mining operations. Valuable seams of coal, ironstone and oil-shale in the Scottish Carboniferous Limestone and Calciferous Sandstone series are extensively worked, and in the underground operations many illustrations of former volcanic action have been met with. The most remarkable instances of the discovery of buried volcanoes have occurred in the Dalry coal-field in the north of Ayrshire. In one pit-shaft about a mile and a half to the south-west of the village of Dalry, a thickness of 115 fathoms of tuff was passed through, and in another pit 90 fathoms of similar tuff were sunk into before the position of the black-band ironstone of that mineral field was reached by driving levels through the tuff into the sedimentary strata outside of it. Only a short distance from these thick piles of tuff, their place is entirely taken up by the ordinary sedimentary strata of the district. The working-plans of the mines show the tuff to occur in irregular patches and strips, between which the ironstone is workable. From these data we perceive that the shafts have in some cases been sunk directly upon the tops of puys of tuff, which were, in one case, nearly 700 feet, and in another instance, 540 high[458] ([Fig. 146]).
[458] Explanation of Sheet 22, Geol. Surv. of Scotland, p. 16.
It is obvious that from the condition of a completely buried and concealed cone every stage may be expected to occur up to the deeply worn-down neck representing merely the stump of the volcanic column. The subjoined diagram ([Fig. 147]) may serve to illustrate this process of gradual re-emergence.
Fig. 147.—Diagram to illustrate how Volcanic Necks may be concealed and exposed.
1, Neck, still buried under the succeeding sedimentary accumulations; 2, Neck uncovered and denuded.
When, in the progress of denudation, a volcanic cone began to show itself from under the cover of removed strata, it would still for a time maintain its connection with the sheets of tuff or of lava which, when active, it had erupted. A number of examples of this structure may be observed in the basin of the Firth of Forth, where the degradation of the surface has not yet proceeded so far as to isolate the column of agglomerate or tuff from the sheets of tuff that were strewn around the old volcano. In such cases, the actual limits of the vent are still more or less concealed, or at least no sharp line can be drawn between the vent and its ejections. As an illustration of this connection of a volcanic pipe with the materials ejected from it over the surrounding country I would cite Saline Hill in the west of Fife. That eminence rises to a height of 1178 feet above the sea, out of a band of tuff which can be traced across the country for fully three miles. Numerous sections in the water-courses show that this tuff is regularly interbedded in the Carboniferous Limestone series, so that the relative geological date of its eruption can be precisely fixed. On the south of Saline Hill, coal and ironstone, worked under the tuff, prove that this portion of the mass belongs to the general sheet of loose ashes and dust, extending outwards from the original cone over the floor of the sheet of water in which the Carboniferous Limestone series of strata was being deposited. But the central portion of the hill is occupied by one or more volcanic pipes. A section across the eminence from north-west to south-east would probably show the structure represented in [Fig. 148]. Immediately to the east of the Saline Hill lies another eminence, known as the Knock Hill, which marks the site of another eruptive vent. A coal-seam (the Little Parrot or Gas Coal) is worked along its southern base, and is found to plunge down steeply towards the volcanic rocks. This seam, however, is not the same as that worked under the Saline Hill, but lies some 600 feet below it. Probably the whole of the Knock Hill occupies the place of a former vent.
Fig. 148.—Section across the Saline Hills, Fife.
The thick parallel black lines mark the position of seams of coal and ironstone, some of which are worked under Saline Hill. T, Tuff of the necks; t, Tuff at a little distance from the cone, interstratified with the ordinary sedimentary beds; B, Basalt. The larger eminence is Saline Hill, the lower is Knock Hill.
A further stage of decay and denudation brings before us the entire severance of the volcanic column from the materials that were ejected from it. An excellent example of this isolation of the neck in the midst of surrounding masses of tuff and lava which proceeded from it is presented by the Binn of Burntisland, to which I have already alluded. A section across that eminence gives the geological structure represented in [Fig. 149]. The dip of the rocks away from the volcanic pipe at this locality has been produced long after the volcanic phenomena had ceased. The arch here shown is really the prolongation and final disappearance of the great anticlinal fold of which the Pentland Hills form the axis on the opposite side of the Firth. But if we restore the rocks to a horizontal, or approximately horizontal position, we find the Binn of Burntisland rising among them in one or more necks, which doubtless mark centres of volcanic activity in that district. A series of smaller neck-like eminences runs for two miles westward.
Striking as the forms of many of the necks are, and much as their present conical forms resemble those of active and extinct volcanoes, the evidence of extensive denudation proves that these contours are not the original outlines of the Carboniferous vents, but are in every case the result of prolonged waste. What we now see is a section of the volcanic chimney, and the conical form is due to the way in which the materials filling the chimney have yielded to the forces of denudation.
Fig. 149.—Section across the Binn of Burntisland, in an East and West direction.
1, Sandstones; 2, Limestone (Burdiehouse); 3, Shales, etc.; b, b, Interstratified basalts; t t, Bedded tuff, etc.; T, Tuff of the great neck of Burntisland; B, Basalt veins.