| Sir John Robinson, Kt. | 1670-1675 |
| Sir James Hayes, Kt. | 1675-1685 |
| The Hon. Sir Edward Dering, Kt. | 1685-1691 |
| Samuel Clarke | 1691-1701 |
| John Nicholson | 1701-1710 |
| Thomas Lake | 1710-1711 |
| Sir Bibye Lake, Bart. | 1711-1712 |
| Captain John Merry | 1712-1729 |
| Samuel Jones | 1729-1735 |
| Benjamin Pitt | 1735-1743 |
| Thomas Knapp | 1743-1746 |
| Sir Atwell Lake, Bart. | 1746-1750 |
| Sir William Baker, Kt. | 1750-1760 |
| Captain John Merry | 1760-1765 |
| Bibye Lake | 1765-1770 |
| Robert Merry | 1770-1774 |
| Samuel Wegg | 1774-1782 |
| Sir James Winter Lake, Bart. | 1782-1799 |
| Richard Hulse | 1799-1805 |
| Nicholas Caesar Corsellis | 1805-1806 |
| Wm. Mainwaring | 1806-1807 |
| Joseph Berens, Junior | 1807-1812 |
| John Henry Pelly | 1812-1822 |
| Nicholas Garry | 1822-1835 |
| Benjamin Harrison | 1835-1839 |
| Andrew Colville | 1839-1852 |
| John Shepherd | 1852-1856 |
| Henry Hulse Berens | 1856-1858 |
| Edward Ellice, M.P. | 1858-1863 |
| Sir Curtis Miranda Lampson, Bart. | 1863-1871 |
| Eden Colville | 1871-1880 |
| Sir John Rose, Bart., G.C.M.G. | 1880-1888 |
| Sir Donald A. Smith, G.C.M.G. | 1888-1889 |
| The Earl of Lichfield | 1889-1898 |