CASES CITED FOOTNOTES INDEX A Aliens, as citizens and allegiance of, [1] Allegiance, [222] Ambassadors, [119] , [120] , [137] Amendments, protect fundamental rights, [22] ;the Sixteenth, [23] , [24] , [57] , [61] ; I.-XVII., [28] , [29] , [57] , [58] , [61] ; Fourteenth, [96] , [97] ; Eleventh, the, [114] , [115] ; first ten, [173–175] , [199] , [200] ; Fifth, Sixth, Seventh, Eighth, Ninth, Tenth, [175] ; Thirteenth, [176] , [198] , [200] ; Fourteenth, [176] , [198] , [200] , [206] , [207] , [216] , [217] ; Fifth, [198] ; Fifteenth, [222] , [223] ; Ninth, [200] ; Tenth, [200] , [203] ; Fourth, [203] ; Seventh, [210] Anti-Trust Act, [83] , [84] , [85] Appropriations, [22] , [171] ; of Representatives and Senators, [179] Arizona, admission of, [158] Army, [171] Asylum, right of, [152] , [153] Attainder, bill of, [22] , [171] , [172] B Bank, State, [89] , [90] Bankruptcies, [36] , [37] Bible, in public schools, [202] , [203] Bill of credit, [41] Bill of Rights, [173–175] ; the Constitution a, [187] , [210] , [211] Bonds, [90] Boycott, [84] C Cabinet, the, [105] , [106] California, law of, held constitutional, [220] Carriers, Common, [87] Charters, [91] Checks and balances, [164] , [165] ; on the Executive, [166–169] ; on Congress, [170–177] , [178] ; on the States, [176–181] Checks on Congress, [27] Chief Justice, in Court of Impeachment, [103] , [108] , [109] Cities, jurisdiction over, [48] Citizen, of a territory, of a State, [141] , [142] ; privileges and immunities of, [149] , [150] , [212] , [215] , [220] ; as participant in the federal government, [182] ; as elector, [216] Citizens, privileges and immunities of, [149] , [150] , [163] (note) Citizenship, defined, [212] ; two citizenships, [212] , [213] , [226–229] Civil Rights Bill, [218] , [219] Comity, the law of State, [146–163] Commerce, regulation of interstate, [22] ; law of, [63–88] ; regulation of, belongs to sovereignty, [63] , [64] ; defined, [67] ; State and interstate, [63–88] ; unlawful restraint of, [72] ; when an article is of, [73] ; distinguished from manufacture, [73] ; “taxation of commerce,” meaning of, [75] ; principal of regulation of, [76] , [77] , [78] ; interstate, [78] , [88] ; intrastate, [79] , [80] , [88] ; “foreign commerce,” [87] , [88] Confederation, a league, [7] ; unable to regulate commerce, [66] Congress, law making by, [2] , [18–50] ;determines extent of taxation, regulates commerce, protects citizens, determines jurisdiction of federal courts, assigns duties and powers to the President, [25] ; powers of, political, [26] ; abuse of powers by, [27] ; checks on, [27] ; test of authority of, [30] , [31] ; powers of, derived, [34] , [35] ; war power of, [46] ; power over territory, [48] , [49] , [50] ; power of, over commerce, [63–88] ; limitation of powers of, as to commerce, [69–88] ; debates in, as evidence in court, [127] ; decides political questions, [128] ; governs territory, [158–163] ; power over outlying possessions, [161] , [162] , [163] ; checks on, [170–176] ; unconstitutional legislation, [218] , [219] Constitution, the supreme law, [1] ; essential to sovereignty, [2] ; ordained by the people, [2] ; a practical instrument, [19] , [20] ; provides only for judicial interpretation, [24] ; relative rank with act of Congress, [24] , [25] ; unwritten, [27] ; how amended, [180] , [181] ; administrative provisions in, [191] , [192] ; essential features of, [194] Constitutions, State, 1776–1787, [21] ; limit Legislatures, [22] , [23] Consuls, [119] , [120] , [137] Contracts, between citizens of different States, [37] , [38] ; obligation of, [37] ; a lawful, [40] ; law of, the, [89–101] ; obligation of, under the Constitution, [93] , [94] ; constitutional use of the word, [98] Convention, [107] , [108] Convention (federal), [6] ; to amend Constitution, [180] , [181] Cooley, quoted, [205] Copyrights, [36] , [43] Corporations, municipal, [59] ; as citizen, [139] , [142] ; rights of, [139] , [140] , [149] Counterfeiting, [36] , [41] , [42] Counties, jurisdiction over, [48] Courts, inferior, [122] et seq. Courts, Territorial, [125] Courts, Supreme and inferior, [113] , [122] , [123] ; jurisdiction of federal, [115] et seq. ; Territorial, [125] ; political questions and the, [126] ; do not decide political questions, [128] ; province and duty of, [129] ; judicial supremacy, [129–131] ; essential power of the Supreme Court, [142] , [143] ; federal sitting as State, [144] , [145] ; limitation of federal, [178] D Debts, of the U. S., [40] Domain, eminent, exercise of, by U. S. or the States, [95] , [97] , [98] , [99] , [100] “Due process of law,” charitable institutions not entitled to, or a person, [60] ; a fundamental right, [95] , [204] , [220] Duties, export, [22] ; uniform, [40] , [171] Duty, a ministerial, [110] , [111] , [112] E Election, disputed, of President or Vice-President, [180] Elections, disputed presidential, [167] Electors, denial of right of, [179] England, as sovereign, [2] Excises, [40] , [171] Executive, law of, [102–112] ; checks on, [166–169] Exemption, from taxation (Churches, Schools, etc.), [60] ; from income tax, [61] Expatriation, [222] Expenditures, public statement of, [22] Ex post facto law, [22] , [171] , [177] , [224] F Federalist, The , quoted or cited, [4] , [8] , [12] , [13] , [17] , [33] , [34] , [35] , [36] , [116] , [117] , [118] , [187] Fee, license, [74] Felonies, [44] Florida, as a territory, status in U. S., [127] France, as sovereign, [2] Fugitives from justice, [151] , [152] ; political, [153] , [154] Ft. Leavenworth Military Reservation, [48] G Gallatin, Albert, on Louisiana purchase, [14] , [15] Government, representative, [2] ; republican form guaranteed, [6] ; a unit, [19] ; distinguished from sovereignty, [23] ; limited, affected by Sixteenth Amendment, [23] , [24] ; national, when supreme, [34] ; nature of national, [38] ; Marshall’s differentiation between State and federal, [51] ; of the U. S., distinct from the State, [116] ; what constitutes a lawful State, [128] ; principal of separation of powers of, [135] , [136] ; of the U. S. power of, [137] , [138] ; what is a republican form of? [154] , [155] , [156] Governor, power of extradition, [151] , [152] ; issues writs of election, [179] H Habeas Corpus, [21] , [143] Hamilton, on National and State systems, [13] ; as interpreter of the Constitution, [28] ; as to State and federal sovereignty [35] , [36] ; on residuary sovereignty, [177] ; on the Constitution as a Bill of Rights, [187] Hayes, President, on power of the President, [109] , [110] House of Representatives (U. S.) members, [103] , [172] , [179] ; election of, [182] , [216] . (See also [Congress] , [Powers] .) I Impeachment, [107] Imports, [40] Imposts, [171] Information, prosecution by, [220] Interstate commerce, testimony before, [225] , [226] J Jefferson, on Louisiana purchase, [13] ; as interpreter of the Constitution, [28] Johnson, President, [103] Judges, bound by the Constitution, [1] Judiciary Act, [141] Judiciary, as agent, [3] , [4] ; law of judicial power, the, [113–145] ; supremacy of, [129–133] Jurisdiction, of congress and legislatures, [18–50] ; principle of, [38] ; of the U. S., [45] , [58] , [63] ; of a State, [48] ; State and federal compared, [51] , [68] , [72] , [73] , [78] , [80] , [81] , [82] , [86] , [91] , [92] , [95] , [97] ; the test, [53] ; of the Executive, [102–112] ; of the Judiciary, [113–145] ; of Supreme and of inferior federal courts, [118] , [119] , [120] , [122] , [123] ; admiralty, [121] ; federal and State distinguished, [124] , [125] ; as to political questions, [126] , [127] ; original of Supreme Court, [136] , [137] ; national commercial, [137] ; principal of State, [146] , [147] ; no new conferred by the constitution, [146] ; determines citizenship, [151] Jury , as used in the Constitution, [209] , [210] ;indictment of, [220] Justice, principles of natural, [50] K Kansas, jurisdiction over Ft. Leavenworth Military Reservation, [48] Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions, [17] (note) L Law, presumption of, [31] ; test of constitutionality, [30] , [31] ; bankrupt, insolvent, [37] , [38] ; postal, [42] ; patent, [44] ; common, [45] ; inspection, [81] ; due process of, [95] ; what is constitutional? [132] , [135] ; ex post facto , [22] , [171] , [224] Legislatures, State, powers of, [22] , [35–37] , [53] , [90] ; discretion of, [54] , [79] ; appoints presidential electors, [167] ; office of, [218] Limitations, the law of, [164–190] Lincoln, Levi, on Louisiana purchase, [14] Lincoln, President, on law of limitations, [166] ; on tenure of Cabinet officers, [105] Liquors, [97] , [98] Louisiana, power to purchase, [13] , [14] , [15] M Madison, defines a republic, [4] , [5] ; on power of national government, [12] , [13] Mails, [42] ; and lottery tickets, [43] , [85] , [86] Mandamus, [111] Manufacture, distinguished from commerce, [73] ; right to, [98] Marque and reprisal, [37] Marshall, Chief Justice, defines U. S. government, [6] , [7] ; on taxing power, [9] , [10] ; on war and treaty-making powers, [15] ; enthrones Hamilton’s ideas, [28] ; on sovereignty, [34] ; distinction by, between State and federal, [51] ; on regulation of commerce, [63] , [119] ; on international law, [148] ; lays down principle of constitutional interpretation, [186] , [187] Massachusetts, constitution of 1780, [5] Measures, [36] , [37] Ministers, public, [119] , [120] , [137] Monopolies, [72] , [83] , [84] N Naturalization, [221] Nobility, title of, [172] Nuisance, [97] Nullification, [17] O Oath, [2] Office, legal right to, [91] ; constitutional meaning of, [103] P Package, original, [75] Parliament, [21] Parties, political, interpret the Constitution, [27] , [28] Patent rights, [36] , [43] People, The, sovereign, [2] ; author of supreme law, [5] , [6] ; power to amend constitution, [7] ; sovereignty of, [12] , [13] Piracies, [44] , [45] Polygamy, [203] Possessions, outlying, power of Congress over, [161] , [162] , [163] Post offices, [42] Post roads, [42] Powers, derivative [2] ;original and derivative distinguished, [5] ; taxing, [9] ; legislative, [18–50] ; defined, [18] ; character of, [18–50] ; separation of, [19] , [20] ; of respective Houses, [20] , [21] , [22] ; limitations of, [18] , [22] , [23] , [24] ; American doctrine of, [19] ; parliamentary, [20] , [21] ; nature and extent of Constitutional, [21] ; of Congress reflect eighteenth century ideas, [25] , [26] ; of Congress derivative, [34] , [35] ; implied, [36] ; conflict between State and federal, [36–39] ; implied or expressed, [38] , [39] , [55] ; police, [42–45] , [73] , [74] , [79] , [81] , [91] , [92] , [98] , [121] , [205–208] ; of Congress as to crime or immorality, [42] ; taxing, [52] , et seq. ; of State governments, [55] , [56] ; judicial review of taxing, [57] , [58] ; police powers of U. S. and States distinguished, [68] ; residuary of States, [73] ; taxing by State and U. S. defined, [76] ; law of executive, [102–112] ; law of judicial, [113–145] ; the U. S. Government, [137–139] ; exact division between State and federal unknown, [183] ; delegated, [191] Preamble, [26] , [76] President, veto of, [2] ; military and naval power, [46] ; executes U. S. laws, [46] ; character of his decisions, [46] , [47] ; nature of powers of, [102–112] ; oath of, [102] ; trial of, [103] ; test of execution of office of, [103] ; Johnson, [103] ; impeachment of, [102] , [103] , [107] , [108] Principles of Constitutional law, as to sovereignty, [9] , [39] , [217] ; separation of powers, [19] ; limitations, [22] , [27] ; learned from judicial decisions, [30] ; as to adequate federal powers, [33] , [34] , [54] ; of natural justice, [50] ; as to commerce, [70] ; as to the police power, [92] ; as to obligation of contracts, [93] ; consequentive damages, [99] ; of judicial power, [130] ; [136] ; of federal judicial jurisdiction, [142] , [143] ; of State comity, [147] , [150] ; as to powers of Congress, [183] ; constitutional interpretation, [186] , [187] ; fundamental rights, [191–211] ; equality of citizens, [217] ; due process of law, [219] , [220] ; of citizenship, [221] Prohibition, [97] , [98] R Receipts, publication of, [22] Residuary sovereignty, [12] Revenue, bills of, [172] Rights, the law of fundamental, [190–211] ; religious liberty, [191] , [195] ; freedom of speech, of the press, [196] , [197] ; right of petition, [197] ; exemption from searches and seizures, [197] , [198] , [225] ; life, liberty, property, [199] ; realized through the Judiciary, [201] ; relation to Constitutional limitations, [202] ; trial by jury, [209] , [210] ; bills of, [210] , [211] S Senate (U. S.) members, [103] , [172] , [179] ; treaties, [104] ; as Court of Impeachment, [108] ; represents the States, [180] ; election of, [216] . (See also [Congress] , [Powers] .) Services, Constitutional meaning of, [103] Sovereignty, agent of, [2] , [3] , [4] , [5] , [6] , [8] , [9] , [10] , [11] , [12] ; delegated to Congress, [19] , [20] ; of the people, [34] ; Hamilton on State and federal, [35] , [36] ; national, [38] , [39] , [41] , [100] ; possessed by U. S. and by States, [47] ; State distinguished from federal, [51] ; as to commerce, [63] ; of Congress over outlying possessions, [161–163] State (in the Union), quasi-sovereign, [2] ; Legislature, [2] ; sovereignty of, [6–9] , [55] , [100] ; supremacy of, [34] ; powers of Legislatures derivative, [35] , [36] State, powers of legislature extinguished by Congress, [36] ; implied powers of, [36] ; power to punish counterfeiting, [41] , [42] ; police power of, [43] , [44] , [45] , [79] , [81] , [91] , [92] , [98] , [121] , [205] , [206] , [207] , [208] ; meaning of “State” in the Constitution, [47] , [48] , [141] ; and U. S. possess sovereignty, [47] ; subdivisions of, [48] ; system of State government distinguished from federal, [51] ; power of, over commerce, [64] , [67] ; limitation of jurisdiction of, [82] ; may be petitioned, not suable, [114] , [115] ; what constitutes a republican form of, [128] ; suability, [140] ; the word “States” in the Constitution, [141] ; jurisdiction of, determined, [147] ; principle of relation of State to State, [147] , [148] ; law of in federal courts, [148] ; the States mutually foreign to one another, [148] ; rights of citizens of, [149] ; admission of a, [156] , [157] ; the States indestructible, [158] ; new States, [173] ; limitation of power of, [176–181] ; the States as limitations on the U. S., [179] , [180] ; appoints presidential electors, [179] ; subdivision of, [180] ; guaranteed a republican form of government, [180] ; States and amendment of the Constitution, [180] , [181] ; citizenship, [213] Suffrage, [223] Supreme Court of the U. S., Marshall’s decisions, [28] ; principle of interpretation, [31] , [34] , [39] , [186] ; on boundary between the federal and State systems, [51] ; part of the judicial department, [56] ; powers not delegated, [59] ; has not defined power over commerce, [63] ; nature of power of U. S. over commerce, [65] , [76] , [77] ; decisions on Anti-Trust Act, [83] , [84] ; on obligation of contracts, [93] ; adequacy of its authority, [106] ; on executive and ministerial powers, [112] ; judicial power of, [113] , [114] et seq. ; jurisdiction, original and appellate, [119–136] ; on the war power, [127] ; nature of jurisdiction, [129–142] ; determines constitutional law, [133–135] ; jurisdiction under the Judiciary Act, [141] ; relation to State tribunals, [144] , [145] ; as to republican form of government, [155] , [156] ; decision of as to power of Congress over Territories and possessions, [160–163] , [183] , [184] , [201] ; on delegated powers, [175] ; jurisdiction when a State is a party, [178] ; function of the Judiciary, [185] ; power of U. S. to acquire territory, [193] ; power vested in, [194] ; on the nature of American institutions, [210] , [211] ; on citizens’ rights, [214] ; on “due process of law,” [220] ; on the Fifteenth Amendment, [222] , [223] “Sweeping Clause,” [26] T Tax, export, [22] , [52] ; essentials of a good, [52] , [60] , [61] ; income, [58] (and see under [Amendment] ); exemptions, [60] ; direct, indirect, [61] Taxation, law of, [51–62] ; by a State, [52–56] ; national, [54] ; power of U. S. over, [65] , [66] Tender, legal, [38] , [39] Territory, when sovereign, [47] ; power of Congress over, [48] , [141] , [183] ; the law of, and of territories, [146–163] ; becoming a State, [157] , [158] ; governed by Congress, [159] , [160] , [162] , [163] Texas, law of, regulating commerce, [80] Tickets, lottery, [43] , [83] , [85] Treason, [172] Treaties, [104] ; in the Senate, [180] U United States, supreme law of, [2] et seq. ; laws of, by whom made, [2] ; guarantees republican form of government, [6] ; sovereignty of, [8–13] ; organization of, reflects popular will, [18] ; governmental functions of, [19] , [20] ; powers of, [20] et seq. ; admiralty, jurisdiction of, [45] , [46] ; war power of, [46] ; and States possess sovereignty, [47] ; civil system of, distinguished from State, [51] ; powers of, as to States, [54–57] ; power over commerce, [63–88] ; the peace of, [85] ; police power of, [95] ; citizenship, [214] , [216] , [217] V Veto, [2] Vice-President, [108] W Waite, Chief Justice, quoted, [92] Waters, navigable, [46] Webster, Daniel, his definition of law, [205] Weights, [36] , [37] Wilson, James, on the Constitution a Bill of Rights, [187] , [188]