CLERK SANDERS
The Text is given in full from Herd’s MSS., where it concludes with a version of Sweet William’s Ghost; and the last three stanzas, 42-44, are from Scott’s later version of the ballad (1833) from recitation. Child divides the ballad as follows:— Clerk Sanders, 1-26 of the present version; Sweet William’s Ghost, 27-41. Scott made ‘one or two conjectural emendations in the arrangement of the stanzas.’
The Story of this admirable ballad in its various forms is paralleled in one or two of its incidents by a similar collection of Scandinavian ballads. Jamieson introduced into his version certain questions and answers (of the prevaricating type found in a baser form in Our Goodman) which are professedly of Scandinavian origin.