Market Street Dutch Reformed Church |
| 1820-1835 | William McMurray, D.D. † 1835. |
| 1836-1853 | Isaac Ferris, D.D., † 1873. |
| 1853-1860 | Theodore Ledyard Cuyler, D.D., † 1909. |
| 1861-1862 | Chauncey D. Murray. |
| 1863-1865 | Jacob C. Dutcher. |
Presbyterian Church of the Sea and Land |
| 1865-1866 | Alexander McGlashan, D.D., † 1867. |
| 1867-1868 | John Lyle, † 1881. |
| 1869-1888 | Edward Hopper, D.D., † 1888. |
| 1888-1889 | Andrew Beattie, Ph.D.; San Anselmo, Cal. |
| 1890-1893 | Alexander W. Sproull, D.D., † 1912. |
| 1895-1902 | John Hopkins Denison; France. |
| 1903-1905 | William Raymond Jelliffe; New York. |
| 1906-1908 | Orrin Giddings Cocks; New York. |
| 1909-1913 | Russell Stanley Gregory; East Aurora, N. Y. |
| 1914-1917 | John Ewing Steen; France. |
| 1910 | Joseph Anthony Villelli. |
| 1917 | Alfred D. Moore. |
| 1919 | Russell J. Clinchy. |