For the longer distances the rates of 1824 were found to be oppressive for ordinary letters, and burdensome to commerce and literature. Financially also the increase was not a success. For 1824, the last year of the old rates, the surplus was 823,229 thalers, an increase of 100,325 thalers over the surplus of 1823. The surplus for 1825, the first year of the new rates, was 1,121,616 thalers, an increase of 298,387 thalers over the surplus of 1824. Apparently, therefore, the new rates had produced an immediate increase of net revenue. This was, however, not the case. While the actual proceeds of postage in 1824 were 73,152 thalers greater than in 1823, the proceeds of postage in 1825 were only 80,890 thalers greater than in 1824.[237] The increased yield of postage was therefore quite small. And even this small increase disappeared in 1826. For that year the yield of postage was only 40,547 thalers greater than in 1825, and in 1827 there was an actual falling off of 41,942 thalers. The increase of net revenue was therefore attributable to other causes. Thus, for example, in 1825, by some means or other, a reduction of no less than 136,160 thalers was effected in the expenses of the service.
The rates were soon found to need amendment. Changes were made in the subsidiary rates, the rates for commercial papers, for magazines, etc., but the letter rate remained unchanged until 1844, when a considerable reduction was made. The following rates for a single letter (not exceeding ⅜ ounce in weight), were established:—
| Not exceeding 5 miles | 1 | silver groschen | ||||
| From | 5 | miles to | 10 | miles | 1½ | " |
| " | 10 | " | 15 | " | 2 | " |
| " | 15 | " | 20 | " | 2½ | " |
| " | 20 | " | 30 | " | 3 | " |
| " | 30 | " | 50 | " | 4 | " |
| " | 50 | " | 100 | " | 5 | " |
| For each further 100 miles within the Prussian administration | 6 | " | ||||
These rates were applied to letters, printed matter sent under band, and letters containing samples of merchandise. It was estimated that this change would reduce the gross receipts from postage by 700,000 thalers, and the net revenue for 1845 was estimated at 700,000 thalers instead of 1,400,000 thalers. The actual decrease in 1845 in the gross receipts from postage was, however, only 302,563 thalers, and the actual falling off in net revenue only 346,208 thalers. The gross revenue soon recovered, and in 1847 exceeded that of 1844.[238]
The Prussian administration, while not prepared to introduce complete uniformity of rate irrespective of distance, were yet desirous of simplifying the rates, and of removing from them any trace of the fiscal tradition, so far as this course could be followed without involving serious sacrifice of net revenue.[239]
In September 1848 the distinction between the letter rate and the rate for printed matter and documents was abolished, and on the 1st October 1848 the following scale of weights for all letters, publications, etc., was introduced, viz.:—
| Not exceeding | ⅜ | oz. | 1 | rate (i.e. 1 sgr.) | ||
| From | ⅜ | oz. to | ½ | oz. | 1½ | " |
| " | ½ | " | ¾ | " | 2 | rates |
| " | ¾ | " | 1 | " | 2½ | " |
| " | 1 | " | 4 | " | 3 | " |
| " | 4 | " | 8 | " | 4 | " |
and over 8 ounces 4 rates, until the charge was less than double parcel rate.
The rates were still based on the old theory of distance. The Prussian administration feared that a complete reform