[To face page 12.]
It was found at Berlin that, owing to the difficulty of properly cleaning the open filters in winter, it was impossible to keep the usual proportion of the area in effective service, and as a result portions of the filters were greatly overtaxed during prolonged periods of cold weather. This resulted in greatly decreased bacterial efficiency, the bacteria in March, 1889, reaching 3000 to 4000 per cc. (with 100,000 in the raw water), although ordinarily the effluent contained less than 100. An epidemic of typhoid fever followed, and was confined to that part of the city supplied from the Stralau works, the wards supplied from the covered Tegel filters remaining free from fever. Open filters have since been abandoned in Berlin.
At Altona also, where the water is taken from an excessively polluted source, decreased bacterial efficiency has repeatedly resulted in winter, and the occasional epidemics of typhoid fever in that city, which have invariably come in winter, appear to have been directly due to the effect of cold upon the open filters. The city has just extended the open filters, and hopes with an increased reserve area to avoid the difficulty in future without resource to covered filters. (See Appendices II and VII.)
Brunswick, Lübeck, and Frankfort on Oder with cold winters have open filters, but draw their water-supplies from less polluted sources, and have thus far escaped the fate of Berlin and Altona. The new filters at Hamburg also are open. At Zürich, where open and covered filters were long used side by side, the covered filters were much more satisfactory, and the old open filters have recently been vaulted over.
Königsberg originally built open filters, but was afterward obliged to cover them, on account of the severe winters; and at Breslau, where open filters have long been used, the recent additions are vaulted over.
The fact that inferior efficiency of filtration results with open filters during prolonged and severe winter weather is generally admitted, although there is some doubt as to the exact way in which the disturbance is caused. In some works I am informed that in cutting the ice around the edges of the filter and repeatedly piling the loose pieces upon the floating cake, the latter eventually becomes so thickened at the sides that the projecting lower corners actually touch the sand, with the fluctuating levels which often prevail in these works, and that in this way the sediment layer upon the top of the sand is broken and the water rapidly passes without adequate purification at the points of disturbance.
This theory is, however, inadequate to account for many cases where such an accumulation of ice is not allowed. In these cases the poor work is not obtained until after the filters have been scraped. The sand apparently freezes slightly while the water is off, and when water is brought back and filtration resumed, normal results are for some reason not again obtained for a time.
In addition to the poorer work from open filters in cold weather, the cost of removing the ice adds materially to the operating expenses, and in very cold climates would in itself make covers advisable.
I have arranged the European filter plants, in regard to which I have sufficient information, in the table on page 15, in the order of the normal mean January temperatures of the respective places. This may not be an ideal criterion of the necessity of covering filters, but it is at least approximate, and in the absence of more detailed comparisons it will serve to give a good general idea of the case. I have not found a single case where covered filters are used where the January temperature is 32° F. or above. In some of these places some trouble is experienced in unusually cold weather, but I have not heard of any very serious difficulty or of any talk of covering filters at these places except at Rotterdam, where a project for covering was being discussed.
Those places having January temperatures below 30° experience a great deal of difficulty with open filters; so much so, that covered filters may be regarded as necessary for them, although it is possible to keep open filters running with decreased efficiency and increased expense by freely removing the ice, with January temperatures some degrees lower.