A warehouseman has a lien on the property for his charges. The warehouseman or storage-keeper must exercise ordinary care in the protection of the property. The bailor must reveal to the bailee the character of the goods stored. If the goods are of a dangerous character and injury results, the bailor is responsible to the bailee for damages, if he has failed to reveal the dangerous character of the goods.
234. Degree of Care Required of Bailee. A bailee of property is required to exercise a certain degree of care in the use, preservation and protection of the property placed in his possession, and is liable for a certain degree of negligence. The amount of care a bailee is obliged to exercise, and the amount of negligence for which he is liable, depends upon the kind of property bailed, and whether the bailment is for the sole benefit of the bailor, the bailee, or for the mutual benefit of both the bailor and the bailee. If the property bailed is of great value, or so delicate that it is easily lost, destroyed or injured, a greater degree of care is required on the part of the bailee than if the property is of little value, or is of such a nature that it is not easily damaged, lost or destroyed.
If A, with B's permission, stores his wagon in B's barn, and the wagon is stolen, B is not liable unless he was grossly negligent. He was not paid for the bailment, and was obliged to exercise only slight care in the protection of the wagon. If, however, A leaves his watch with B while he attends a ball game, and the watch is stolen, B must have exercised greater care than in the case of the wagon by reason of the value and nature of the property bailed. Otherwise, he will be liable. In this case as well as in the case of the wagon, B received no compensation for the bailment, and is obliged to exercise only slight care in the protection of the property bailed, and is liable only for gross negligence. What constitutes slight care and gross negligence differs materially in the case of the wagon and in the case of the watch.
In connection with bailments, care is said to have three degrees, great, ordinary and slight. Negligence is also said to have three degrees, gross, ordinary and slight. Ordinary care or negligence is the standard for testing each case. After ordinary care or negligence is determined, slight or great care, and slight or gross negligence is determined by ascertaining whether the care or negligence is above or below ordinary. Any care greater than ordinary is great care; any care less than ordinary is slight care. Any negligence greater than ordinary is gross negligence. Any negligence less than ordinary is slight negligence. If a person takes such precautions in the use, preservation, and protection of the property as an ordinarily prudent person would take of his own property under similar circumstances, he is said to exercise ordinary care. The degree of care required of a bailee depends upon the kind of a bailment in question, as well as upon the kinds of property bailed.
If the bailment is for the sole benefit of the bailor, the bailee receiving no compensation for his inconvenience and work, he is required to exercise only slight care, and is liable only for gross negligence. If the bailment is for the sole benefit of the bailee, the bailor receiving no compensation for his inconvenience and the loss of the use of his property, the bailee is required to exercise great care in the use and preservation of the property, and is liable for slight negligence. In case of mutual benefit bailments, the bailee is obliged to exercise ordinary care in the use and protection of the property, and is liable for ordinary negligence. Two classes of mutual benefit bailees, innkeepers and common carriers, do not come within the above rule. These are known as exceptional mutual benefit bailments, and are discussed under separate chapters.
235. Rights of Bailee as Against Bailor. A bailee has the right to keep the property, to use it according to the terms of the contract of bailment, and to defend this right even against the bailor himself. While the title to the property in question remains in the bailor, the right of possession during the period covered by the contract of bailment is in the bailee. He may retain possession of the property for the purpose of the bailment. A bailee is entitled to use the property bailed, and is restricted only by the limitations of the contract. If the bailee uses this property in a way not authorized by the contract of bailment, he is liable in damages to the bailee.
Where a mutual benefit bailment requires the bailee to use skill in connection with the property bailed, the bailor must exercise a degree of skill ordinarily used by persons who perform similar work. If the bailee fails to use this degree of skill, he is liable in damages to the bailor. For example, if A leaves his horse with B, a blacksmith, to be shod, and B attempts the work, but performs it so unskillfully, or carelessly that the horse is injured or lamed thereby, B is liable to A for the damage caused.
236. Rights of Bailee as Against Third Persons. A bailee has the right to keep the property bailed as against third persons who endeavor to interfere with his possession. The bailee is not permitted to dispute the title of the bailor for his own benefit. If, however, the property is taken away from the bailee by action at law, by one whose title is superior to that of the bailor, the bailee is relieved from liability to the bailor. In this event, the one who has the paramount title coupled with the right of immediate possession, may take the property from the bailee. If the bailee yields possession to one whose right of possession and title are inferior to the bailor's, the bailee is answerable to the bailor for any losses sustained. The bailee cannot confer good title upon anyone to whom he attempts to sell the property bailed, even though the purchaser buys without notice of the bailment. Anyone who injures the property while it is in the possession of the bailee is responsible either to the bailor or bailee for the damages.
237. Lien of Bailee. A bailee who has performed work on the article bailed, for which he is to be paid a consideration, is said to have a lien for the value of the work performed, or materials furnished. By a lien is meant the right of the bailee to retain possession until the value of his labor or material has been received. At common law, a livery stable keeper had no lien upon horses fed and cared for. By statute in most states, livery stable keepers now have a lien upon horses left with them. If a bailee is employed to perform work or labor upon personal property, and the property is destroyed without fault of the bailee after part of the work has been performed, the bailee may recover for the amount of work performed and materials furnished, unless the contract of bailment is to the effect that the entire job is to be completed before any payment is made.
A bailee loses his lien by parting with possession of the property. At common law, a bailee could not sell the property to enforce his lien. By statute in most states, the bailee is permitted to sell the property, by giving notice of the time and place of sale to the bailor, or by foreclosing his lien by a legal action.