[27] In the first edition of the Memoir on the Geology of North Derbyshire, published in 1859, the authors of which were Messrs. A. H. Green, C. le Neve Foster and J. R. Dakyns.
The subject, however, has now been resumed by Mr. H. Arnold Bemrose, who in 1894, after a prolonged study of the petrography of the rocks, communicated the results of his researches to the Geological Society.[28] In his excellent paper, to which I shall immediately make fuller reference, he mentions the localities at which lava-form and fragmental rocks may be observed, but does not enter on the discussion of the geological structure of the region or of the history of the volcanic eruptions. Before the announcement of his paper, hearing that I proposed to make for the first time a rapid traverse of the toadstone district, for the purpose of acquainting myself with the rocks on the ground, he kindly offered to conduct me over it. My chief object, besides that of seeing the general nature of the volcanic phenomena of the region, was to examine more particularly the areas of the volcanic fragmental rocks, with the view of discovering whether among them some remains might not be found of the actual vents of discharge. In this search I was entirely successful. Aided by Mr. Bemrose's intimate knowledge of the ground, I was enabled to visit in rapid succession those tracts which seemed most likely to furnish the required evidence, and in a few days was fortunate enough to obtain proofs of six or seven distinct vents, ranging from the extreme northern to the furthest southern boundary of the volcanic district. Mr. Bemrose has undertaken to continue the investigation, and will, I trust, work out the detailed stratigraphy of the Carboniferous Limestone so as eventually to furnish an exhaustive narrative of the whole volcanic history of Derbyshire. Meanwhile no adequate account of the area can be given. But I will here state all the essential facts which up to the present time have been ascertained.
[28] Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. vol. l. (1894), p. 603.
1. THE ROCKS ERUPTED.—Mr. Allport has described the microscopic character of some of the toadstones,[29] and further details have been supplied by Mr. Teall.[30] The fullest account of the subject, however, is that given by Mr. Bemrose in the paper above referred to. This observer distinguishes the lava-form from the fragmental rocks, and gives the minute characters of each series. He does not, however, separate true interstratified lavas from injected sills, nor the bedded tuffs from the coarse agglomerates which fill up the vents. These distinctions are obviously required in order that the true nature and sequence of the materials in the volcanic eruptions may be traced, and that the phenomena exhibited in Derbyshire may be brought into comparison with those found in other Carboniferous districts. But to establish them satisfactorily the whole region must be carefully re-examined and even to some extent re-mapped.
[29] Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc. xxx. (1874), p. 529.
[30] British Petrography, p. 209.
The lavas (including, in the meantime, sheets which there can be little doubt are sills) show three main types of minute structure and composition, which are discriminated by Mr. Bemrose as—(a) Olivine-dolerites; these, the most abundant of the series, consist of augite in grains, olivine in idiomorphic crystals, plagioclase giving lath-shaped and tabular sections, and magnetite or ilmenite in rods and grains; (b) Ophitic olivine-dolerites, consisting of augite in ophitic plates forming the groundmass, in which are imbedded idiomorphic olivine, plagioclase (often giving large lath-shaped sections and magnetite or ilmenite); (c) Olivine-basalts; these rocks are distinguished by containing crystals of augite and olivine in a groundmass of small felspar-laths, granular augite and magnetite or ilmenite, with very little interstitial matter. They have been noticed only in two of the outcrops of toadstone.
The fragmental rocks have been shown by Mr. Bemrose to cover a much more extensive space than had been previously supposed. He has found them to be distinguished by an abundance of lapilli varying from minute fragments up to pieces about the size of a pea, and composed of a material that differs in structure from the dolerites and basalts with which the tuffs are associated. These lapilli consist largely of a glassy base more or less altered, which is generally finely vesicular and encloses abundant skeleton crystals and crystallites. The tuffs thus very closely resemble some of the Carboniferous basic tuffs of Fife, already referred to ([vol. i. p. 422]), and like these they include abundant blocks of dolerite and basalt.
2. GEOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF THE TOADSTONE DISTRICT.—As the volcanic rocks of Derbyshire lie among the Carboniferous Limestones of a broad anticlinal dome, they are only exposed where these limestones have been sufficiently denuded, and as the base of the limestones is nowhere laid bare, the lowest parts of the volcanic series may be concealed. Over the tract where the toadstones can be examined they appear as bands regularly intercalated with the limestones, but varying in thickness in the course of their outcrops. As they are prone to decay, they usually form smooth grassy slopes between the limestone scarps, though isolated blocks of the dull brown igneous rocks may often be seen protruding from the surface. Now and then a harder bed of toadstone caps a hill, and thus forms a prominent feature in the landscape, but as a rule these igneous bands play no distinguishing part in the scenery, and are indeed less conspicuous than the white escarpments of limestone which overlie them.
It was the opinion of the older geologists that three distinct platforms of toadstone extend without break throughout the district, and subdivide the limestones into four portions. But this opinion does not seem to have been based on good evidence either of sequence or of continuity. Various facts were brought forward by the officers of the Geological Survey to show that the supposed persistence of the three platforms of toadstone did not really exist, but that these sheets of igneous material are found at different spots on very different horizons, and are of limited horizontal range.[31] So far as my own limited observations go, they entirely corroborate this view. There can be little doubt, I think, that the identity of certain outcrops of toadstone has been assumed, and the assumption has been carried throughout the district. The truth is that the number of successive platforms on which igneous materials appear will never be satisfactorily determined until the stratigraphy of the Derbyshire Carboniferous Limestone is worked out in detail. When the successive members of this great calcareous formation have been identified by lithological and palæontological characters over the district, it will be easy to allocate each outcrop of toadstone to its true geological horizon. When this labour has been completed, it will probably be found that instead of three, there have been many discharges of volcanic material during the deposition of the limestone series; that these have proceeded from numerous small vents, and that they are all of comparatively restricted horizontal extent. Such a detailed examination will also determine how far the toadstones include veritable sills, and on what horizons these intrusive sheets have been injected.