All the Brothers Were Valiant

by Ben Ames Williams

Rachel’s sister, Priscilla, was a gay and careless child. She was six years younger than Joel, and she had acquired in babyhood the habit of thinking Joel the most wonderful created thing. Their yards adjoined; and she was the baby of her family, and he of his. Thus the big boy and the little girl had always been comrades and allies against the world. Before Joel first went to sea, as ship’s boy, the two had decided they would some day be married....

Joel went to supper that night at Priscilla’s home. He was alone in his own house; and Mrs. Holt was a person with a mother’s heart. Rachel lived at home. She gave Joel quiet welcome at the door, before Priscilla in the kitchen heard his voice and came flying to overwhelm him. She had been making popovers, and there was flour on her fingers—and on Joel’s best black coat, when she was done with him. Rachel brushed it off, when Priss had run back to her oven.

They sat down at table. Mrs. Holt at one end, her husband—he was a big man, an old sea captain, and full of yarns as a knitting bag—at the other; and Rachel at one side, facing Priss and Joel. Joel’s ship had come in only that day; the Nathan Ross had been in port for weeks. So the whole town knew Mark Shore’s story. They spoke of it now, and Joel told them what he knew.... Rachel wondered if there was any chance that Mark might still be alive. Her father broke in with a story of Mark’s first cruise, when the boy had saved a man’s life by his quickness with the hatchet on the racing line. The town was full of such stories; for Mark was one of those men about whom legends arise. And now he was gone....

Priscilla listened to the talk with the wide eyes of youth, awed by the mystery and majesty of tragic things. She remembered Mark as a huge man, like a pagan god, in whose eyes she had been only a thin-legged little girl who made faces through the fence.... After supper, when the others had left them in the parlor together, she said to Joel: “Do you think he’s dead?” Her voice was a whisper.

“I aim to know,” said Joel.

Rachel looked in at the door. “You needn’t bother with the dishes, Priss,” she said. “I’ll do them.”

Priscilla had forgotten all about that task. She ran contritely toward her sister. “Oh, I’m sorry, Rachel. I will, I will do them. Joel and I....”

Rachel laughed softly. “I don’t mind them. You two stay here.”

Priscilla accepted the offer, in the end; but she had no notion of staying in the tight-windowed parlor, with its harsh carpet on the floor, and its samplers on the walls. She was of the new generation, the generation which discovered that the night is beautiful, and not unhealthy. “Let’s go outside,” she said to Joel. “There’s a moon. We can sit on the bench, under the apple tree....”

They went out, side by side. Joel was not a tall man, but he was inches taller than Priscilla. She was tiny; a dainty, sweetly proportioned creature, built on fine lines that were strangely out of keeping with the stalwart stock from which she sprung. Her hair was darker than Joel’s; it was a brown so dark that it was almost black. But her eyes were vividly blue, and her lips were vividly red, and her cheeks were bright.... She slipped her hand through Joel’s big arm as they crossed the yard; and when they had found the seat, she drew his arm frankly about her shoulders. “I’m cold,” she said, laughing up at him. “You must keep me warm....”