“Aaron, what is your belief about my brother, Mark Shore? Is he dead?”
Aaron was building, that day, the forward partition of the new cabin, fitting his boards meticulously, and driving home each nail with hammer strokes that seemed smooth and effortless, yet sank the nail to the head in an instant. He looked up over his shoulder at Joel, between nails.
“Dead, d’ye say?” he countered quizzically.
Joel nodded. “The Islanders? Did they do it, do you believe?”
Old Aaron chuckled asthmatically. He had lost a fore tooth, and the effect of his mirth was not reassuring. “There’s a brew i’ the Islands,” he said. “More like ’twas the island brew nor the island men.”
Joel, for a moment, sat very still and considered. He knew Mark Shore had never scrupled to take strong drink when he chose; but Mark had always been a strong man to match his drink, and conquer it. Said Joel, therefore, after a space of thought:
“Why do you think that, Aaron? Drink was never like to carry Mark away.”
Aaron squinted up at him. “Have ye sampled that island brew? ’Tis made of pineapples, or sago, or the like outlandish stuff, I’ve heard. And one sip is deviltry, and two is madness, and three is corruption. Some stomachs are used to it; they can handle it. But a raw man....”
There was significance in the pause, and the unfinished sentence. Joel considered the matter. There had always been, between him and Mark, something of that sleeping enmity that so often arises between brothers. Mark was a man swift of tongue, flashing, and full of laughter and hot blood; a colorful man, like a splash of pigment on white canvas. Joel was in all things his opposite, quiet, and slow of thought and speech, and steady of gait. Mark was accustomed to jeer at him, to taunt him; and Joel, in the slow fashion of slow men, had resented this. Nevertheless, he cast aside prejudice now in his estimate of the situation; and he asked old Aaron:
“Do you know there were Islanders about? Or this wild brew you speak of?”