Either wages fall, or the weaker hands are dismissed;
Wages do not fall:
∴ The weaker hands are dismissed.
But we cannot argue—
Wages fall:
∴ The weaker hands are not dismissed;
since in 'hard times' both events may happen together.
Rule of the Modus tollendo ponens: If one alternative be denied, the other is affirmed.
When, however, the alternatives of the Disjunctive are mutually exclusive, we have also the
| Modus ponendo tollens. | ||
| Either | A is B, or C is D; | |
| A is B (or C is D): | ||
| ∴ | C is not D (or A is not B). | |
Either the Tories or the Whigs win the election;