Records of the Kirk of Scotland / containing the Acts and Proceedings of the General Assemblies from 1638 downwards, as authenticated by the clerks of assembly.

by Church of Scotland. General Assembly

Then were the Articles that were approven against Mr Thomas Sydserff, pretendit Bishop of Galloway, given in; and it was sufficiently proven and notour to the whole Assembly that he was guiltie of the breach of the Caveats, besyde many poyntes of Poprie and Arminianisme, and many grosse personall faults.

Then was red the paynes and censures of the Caveats furth of the Acts of Assembly.

Then the Moderatour said—We must not esteeme of mans faults according to the worlds estimatione; for ye know if a man be not a drunkard, a theiff and robber, &c., in their estimatione he is a good man, whatever fault he has utherwayes. But we of this Assemblie ought to thinke utherwayes; not that I would extenuat the foir-named faults, but are to consider their habituall and ordinary transgressions of a publict law is a great guiltines; or, as schoolmen speakes, spiritualia peccata are greater than temporalia peccata. So say I. The preaching of false doctrine, and venemous poysone of that kynde, to bring the people from the trueth of their profession to Papistrie and Idolatrie, must have a great censure; and, consequently, the breach of these Caveats by him, the declyning of this Assembly, and the bringing in of the Service Booke—which you have alreadie censured and condemned for the manifold guiltinesse that it hes in the bowells of it—he deserves no lessa than excommunication. I remember in the English Church there is a sort of excommunication which the Papists call excommunicatio lata—that is, when the man committs the cryme, he shall be declaired to be excommunicat. And there is two sortes of excommunication used in this Church: the one is called summar excommunication, and the uther uses to have admonition before, and is propter contumaciam. Summar excommunication hath beene used in this Church in two cases and was for hynous crymes. The uther was when the Kirk was in danger by suffering of such a member—as a rotten member is cut off least it should corrupt the whole bodie. The uther, which is propter contumaciam, is knowne to all men. In respect that this pretendit Bishop of Galloway is guiltie of contumacie, being cited to compeir heir, and having declyned this Assembly, his excommunication cannot be called summar, but propter contumaciam. It is pittifull to see some hath such a great conceat of their owne words, learning, and engyne that they will not be ranked among uthers; but, as they thinke themselves above uthers in gifts, so they thinke they should be advanced above them in place—and, therefore, ane ordinary stipend cannot content them; and then they begin to tyre of preaching and catechising; and thus are tane away with the pleasures and caires of the world and idlenes. Therefore ye have to consider what shall be their censure; and least you eire, ye shall heare some articles that were gathered out of the Acts of the Generall Assemblies of the Kirk, as lykewayes ane Act of 9 Parlᵗ K. Ja. 6., wherein is exprest the censures that is due to them. And ye shall understand, whatsoever sentence the Assembly shall thinke fit to pronounce against these, when it is all for their good—for the destruction of their fleshe that their saule may be saved in the day of the Lord. But let us remember that these that are deponed witnesses against them sitt not heir as voiters.

Then the Moderatour desyred some of the brethren to give their advyce how they should proceed in that mutter.

Mr David Dick said—It is weill enough knowne that they, having exeemed themselves from ane particular flocke, and from the censure of Presbitrie, and acknowledged no kind of Judicatories but only the Generall Assembly, whilk cannot alwayes sitt; and, therefore, for the wronges they have done to Christ Jesus our Lord, and to the poore Kirk of Scotland, which they have tossed to and fro now these sixteene moneths; and, notwithstanding that everie sermon hes bein taught all this tyme hes bein a summonds for them to repentance, yet doe we see no appearance of it, but a constant ongoing to bring this Kirk to ruine—stirring up the Prince against the people: therefore, my opinion is, that we declair our zeale for the Lord; and that the last censure which is the meanes to humble proud men, be given out against them though they should laugh at us for so doing; for since neither the troubling of this poore Kirk, nor our prayers and teares could humble them, it is good the last meane be assayed, and solicite God to voiting.

My Lord Lowdoun said—The not appearance of these men upon their citation and declyning of this Assembly, proves their contumacie.

Moderatour said—Their great guiltinesse is notour to the world; and yet, notwithstanding of all, they could never cry so much as peccavi; and since we excommunicat all that wer Papists, and disobedient to preachers and pastors, from partaking of the holy Communion; since they are guiltie of both, why should not the censure pas against them? I will read some words of a reverend Father, Mr Andro Melvill. When the Bishop of Sᵗ Androwes was to be excommunicat, he said, “That old dragon had so stinged him with avarice, and swalled so exorbitantlie, that he threatened the destruction of the whole bodie, if he were not cutt off.”

Then the Moderatour stated the question, which was this—Whither Master Thomas Sydserff, pretendit Bishop of Galloway, upon things layd to his charge—the breacking of the Caveats—for preaching of false doctrine, Arminianisme, and Papistrie, and bringing in of the Service Booke—whither he shall be deposed and excommunicat, or not?

Then the rolles were called.

Mr Alexʳ Kerse, being first nominat, answered—I chanced lately to see ane Extract of ane Act of a Generall Assembly holden at Glasgow, Appryle 26, 1580, wherein is registrat that the Bishops of Isles, Aberdeine, and Sᵗ Androwes submitted themselves to the Assembly, and I looked that our oune Bishops should have done the lyke; but instead of their submission, whereby they might have quenched the fire that they have kindled, they have addit contumacie; and the said Mr Thomas Sydserff is Incendiarius. Soloman sayes, “he that breakes doune ane hedge, a serpent shall byte him;” and they have brocken doune a hedge, and therefore the serpent of sharpe excommunication shall byte them. And since he is alse guiltie as any, he deserves excommunication, so abscindatur quem nos perturbatur.