A first book in organic evolution

by D. Kerfoot Shute

In briefly outlining the transmutations of living forms that took place during the Geologic Ages, we have said that changing conditions of life—through an ever-shifting environment—have compelled modifications in the form, structure, and habits of living creatures; and that those creatures which were unable to adapt themselves, through useful variations, to the altering conditions of life have perished, while those that did adapt themselves lived and progressed in organization. What, then, is the great agency through which some life forms have been eliminated during the ages, while others have been selected to continue through these ages? This agency is Natural Selection. The phrase “natural selection” is simply a convenient, condensed statement of observable and easily verifiable facts, viz.: that animals and plants are so situated in this world that they can only secure their food and mates by work, by effort, by struggles, whether consciously or unconsciously, and whether directly or indirectly; and that in these struggles those that are best equipped for their life duties are the ones that are most naturally successful in living and procreating their kind. The survival of those best adapted to their environment may be spoken of, in the language of Spencer, as the Survival of the Fittest. Darwin’s phrase—Natural Selection—has precisely the same significance and means that those creatures which are best fitted to their surroundings are the survivors. The working of Natural Selection may be made clearer by a brief reference to the Artificial Selection by Man of various animals and plants. Variations frequently take place in domesticated animals and plants. Some of these variations appeal to man as being of practical value, others as beautiful, and others again as curious or interesting. He selects those individuals whose variations he wishes to preserve, breeding only them together, and in this way accentuates those variations he desires to perpetuate. In course of time the accumulation of these differences becomes so marked as to make the animals differ greatly from the original stock from whence they came. A well-known illustration of this process is the pigeon. All our domestic pigeons, forming a large number of well-marked races, such as the fantail, the tumbler, the pouter, etc., have been produced from the ordinary wild rock pigeon of Europe. The bird fancier, noticing individual differences in the offspring of the wild rock pigeon, selected the peculiar individuals, and bred only them together. By this simple process of artificial selection and isolation of the chosen or selected individuals, all the races of pigeons have been produced. [Plate I] shows the wild rock pigeon Columba livia and the domesticated pouter. The forms of these pigeons are very different, yet the wild rock pigeon has been transmuted into the pouter through the agency of Artificial Selection. The same is the case with our pigs, dogs, cats, apples, grapes, and other domesticated animals and plants. [Fig. 16] shows the domesticated pig that has been derived from the wild boar by Artificial Selection. By this process, such distinct races as the Newfoundland, the Skye Terrier, and the Bulldog have been produced—creatures that have all come from common ancestors, yet so different looking, one from the other, that if they had been found in the wild state, they would not only have been ranked as distinct species, but as even distinct genera. The same method has given us different races of horses, cows, sheep, flowers, grains, etc. The swiftest horses, for instance, are selected to breed together; then the fleetest offspring of these, time after time, until horses are produced whose speed far surpasses that of the originally selected pair from whence they were derived. Darwin has taught us that what man does on a small scale, in a comparatively short time, Nature has been doing on a vast scale for long ages and has thus given rise, from simple forms, to the infinite variety and complexity of animal and plant life, as we behold it on the globe to-day. The selection by man of useful variations in domesticated creatures being appropriately called Man’s Selection, or Artificial Selection; the vastly greater selection by nature of animals and plants with useful variations and on an infinitely grander scale, through inconceivably long ages, is most fittingly called Natural Selection. The struggles—of animals, for instance—that necessarily lead to the survival of the fittest, are intensified and made exceedingly acute and severe by the fact that all animals tend to increase in a geometrical ratio, and by the further fact that the food and place for animals are limited. In other words, the population of the animals in a given area tends greatly to outrun the means of subsistence. And since animals are constantly varying in many directions and are as plastic in the hands of Nature as clay under the chisel of the modeler, those that possess any useful variations, whether congenital or acquired, that give them any advantages in this great battle of life, will most likely come out of the struggle as victors.

Fig. 16.—Wild Boar contrasted with a modern Domesticated Pig. Reproduced from Romanes’ “Darwin, and After Darwin.” By courtesy of The Open Court Publishing Company.

Multiplication of Animals. Even in the slow-breeding elephant, the offspring tend to increase threefold in each generation. Some animals tend to increase twenty or thirty fold in each generation, while still others tend to increase a thousand fold or even ten thousand fold. If all the offspring of the elephant lived, in eight hundred years there would be over nineteen million elephants alive. If the eight million eggs which the roe of certain fishes, such as the cod or the eel, contains, were to develop into adult forms, the ocean would quickly become a solid mass. The aphis or plant louse is so very prolific that it has been estimated that the tenth brood of one female alone would contain more ponderable matter than all the population of China,—estimating this population at five hundred millions. Yet, in spite of this tendency on the part of animals and plants to increase in numbers at such a stupendous rate, it is found that, in any given area, the conditions of which are not changing, the number of the animals and plants remains fairly constant. This is because of the fact that, along with the stupendously large birth rate, there is an equally stupendous death rate. This high death rate is to a large extent indiscriminate, for it involves those that are physically fit to live, as well as those that are unfit to live. At the edge of a coral-reef, free-swimming, active embryos are found in immense numbers. After a while some of these settle at too great a depth in the water or on the muddy bottom, and die; others get into a more suitable position and live. Again, whole nests of bees are destroyed by the badger; tongue loads of ants are engulfed at one gulp by the ant-bear; hundreds of thousands of fry are destroyed by the Greenland whale at one swallow. In all these cases, the destruction is indiscriminate,—the good, bad, and indifferent are alike decimated, but in spite of this wholesale and indiscriminate destruction, keeping down, as it does, the stupendous birth rate of living creatures, more animals and plants are born than are required to keep up the normal number of individuals that can be supported in a given area. Among these creatures there arises a struggle for existence, a struggle for food and place, and those that are the best fitted to live come out of the contest as conquerors. In this struggle those creatures that emerge as victors, on account of having been best adapted to their conditions of life, may be spoken of as having been selected by Nature; or they may be spoken of as chosen by Natural Selection. In this great struggle, over which Natural Selection presides as some inexorable, ever-watchful, sharp-eyed task-master, the victory is to the cunning instead of the stupid; the race is to the swift instead of the slow; and the battle is to the strong. The wolves of keenest scent, the tigers of more supple spring and sharper sight, secure their prey and thrive, while the weaker members fail to get their food and starve. During migration the birds that are strongest on the wing reach the land whither they are flying, while the weaker perish on their course. Thus Natural Selection acts in two ways, eliminating the unfit and selecting the fit, and there are, besides, two special modifications of Natural Selection which are called Sexual Selection and Insect Selection.

The following analysis of Natural Selection may be useful to the reader, viz.:

Natural Selection	{	Elimination	{	Physical and Climatic Causes.
			{	Enemies.
			{	Competition.
	{	Selection	{	Natural Selection Proper.
			{	Sexual Selection.	{	By Preferential Mating.
					{	By Battle.
			{	Insect Selection.

Elimination of the Unfit. The elimination of the unfit takes place through the agency of physical and climatic causes and also through enemies, and competition of members of the same species. Elimination through the action of surrounding physical and climatic conditions is shown by the following facts: if certain tropical animals be transferred to sub-Arctic or even temperate regions they are unable to adapt themselves to the requirements of the new climatic conditions, and die sooner or later; many animals are killed if the fresh-water lake in which they live be invaded by the waters of the ocean; fishes which live at great depths in the sea and are, therefore, subject to great pressure, are killed when they are brought to the surface, on account of the expansion of the gases in their tissues; if the water where corals are living becomes too fresh, too muddy, or too cold, they will die. The change of climate to a much colder temperature at the close of the Jurassic Ages was probably the cause of the extinction of the huge reptiles that took place at that time. In the winter of 1854-5, four-fifths of the birds in Darwin’s grounds perished on account of the severity of the cold.

As to elimination by enemies, it is well known to naturalists that throughout nature battle within battle is continually recurring with varying success. When weaker animals are preyed upon by stronger ones, and self-defense is useless, the bulky and slow animals are eliminated, while the swift and agile ones escape; the stupid are destroyed, while the cunning often survive. As to elimination by competition, the stronger animals kill the weaker ones, and then quarrel and fight with one another over the prey, the strongest, etc., getting the food. While weaker animals are being preyed upon by various enemies, and are thus eliminated, these enemies are also competing with one another for the prey. At the same time that the stupid and slow creatures are being destroyed by their captors, thus leaving the more cunning and agile animals in possession of their habitat, the stupider and less active captors are gradually eliminated by competition, through failing to capture their more agile and cunning prey.

The agency of Natural Selection in bringing about the innumerable adaptations of animals and plants, and, therefore, causing transmutations of living creatures, can most interestingly and instructively be illustrated by a study of the coloration of animals and plants.