This boiler has some obvious defects. It is evident that thin flat plates are the form which, mechanically considered, is least favourable to strength; nor does it appear that any material advantage is gained to compensate for this by the magnitude of the surface exposed to the action of the fire. It is a great defect that a part of the surface of each of the plates is exposed to the action of the fire while it is out of contact with the water; in fact, in the upper part of the spaces marked E, [fig. 66]., steam only is contained. It has been observed by engineers, and usually shown by experiment, that if steam be heated on the surface of water it will be decomposed, and its elasticity destroyed; this is not the only evil connected with the arrangement, for on this part of the metal, nevertheless, the fire acts,—with less intensity, it is true, than on that part which contains the water,—but still with sufficient intensity to destroy the metal. Mr. Hancock appears to have attempted to remedy this defect by occasionally inverting the position of the flat chambers, placing that which at one time was at the bottom at the top, and vice versâ. This may equalise the wear produced by the action of the fire upon the metal out of contact with water, but still the wear on the whole will not be less rapid. There appears to be no provision or space for separating the steam from the water with which it is charged; in fact, there are no means in this engine of discharging the function of Mr. Gurney's separator. This will be found to produce considerable waste and loss of power in practice.
The bars upon which the fire rests are of solid metal; and such is the intense heat to which they are subject, that, in an engine constantly at work, it is unlikely that they will last, without being renewed, more than about a week, if so much. The draft is maintained in this engine by means of a revolving fan worked by the engine. This, perhaps, is one of the greatest defects as compared with other locomotives. The quantity of power requisite to work this bellows, and of which the engine is robbed, is very great. This defect is so fatal, that I consider it is quite impossible that the ingenious inventor can persevere in the use of it. Mr. Hancock has abandoned the use of the cranks upon his working axle, and has substituted an endless chain and rag-wheels. This also appears to me defective, and a source by which considerable power is lost. On the other hand, however, the weakness of the axle which is always produced by cranks is avoided.
(111.) Mr. Nathaniel Ogle of Southampton obtained a patent for a locomotive carriage, and worked it for some time experimentally; but as his operations do not appear to have been continued, I suppose he was unsuccessful in fulfilling those conditions, without which the machine could not be worked with economy and profit. In his evidence before a committee of the House of Commons, he has thus described his contrivance:—
"The base of the boiler and the summit are composed of cross pieces, cylindrical within and square without; there are holes bored through these cross pieces, and inserted through the whole is an air tube. The inner hole of the lower surface, and the under hole of the upper surface, are rather larger than the other ones. Round the air tube is placed a small cylinder, the collar of which fits round the larger aperture on the inner surface of the lower frame, and the under surface of the upper frame-work. These are both drawn together by screws from the top; these cross pieces are united by connecting pieces, the whole strongly bolted together; so that we obtain, in one tenth of the space, and with one tenth of the weight, the same heating surface and power as is now obtained in other and low-pressure boilers, with incalculably greater safety. Our present experimental boiler contains 250 superficial feet of heating surface in the space of 3 feet 8 inches high, 3 feet long, and 2 feet 4 inches broad, and weighs about 8 cwt. We supply the two cylinders with steam, communicating by their pistons with a crank axle, to the ends of which either one or both wheels are affixed, as may be required. One wheel is found to be sufficient, except under very difficult circumstances, and when the elevation is about one foot in six, to impel the vehicle forward.
"The cylinders of which the boiler is composed are so small as to bear a greater pressure than could be produced by the quantity of fire beneath the boiler; and if any one of these cylinders should be injured by violence, or any other way, it would become merely a safety valve to the rest. We never, with the greatest pressure, burst, rent, or injured our boiler; and it has not once required cleaning, after having been in use twelve months."
(112.) Dr. Church of Birmingham has obtained a succession of patents for contrivances connected with a locomotive engine for stone roads; and a company, consisting of a considerable number of individuals, possessing sufficient capital, has been formed in Birmingham for carrying into effect his designs, and working carriages on his principle. The present boiler of Dr. Church is formed of copper. The water is contained between two sheets of copper, united together by copper nails, in a manner resembling the way in which the cloth forming the top of a mattress or cushion is united with the cloth which forms the bottom of it, except that the nails or pins, which bind the sheets of copper, are much closer together. The water, in fact, seems to be "quilted" or "padded," in between two sheets of thin copper. This double sheet of copper is formed into an oblong rectangular box, the interior of which is the fire-place and ash-pit, and over the end of which is the steam-chest. The great extent of surface exposed to the immediate action of the fire causes steam to be produced with great rapidity.
An obvious defect which such a boiler presents is the difficulty of removing from it any deposite or incrustation, which may collect between the sheets of copper so closely and intricately connected. Dr. Church proposes to effect this, when it is required, by the use of an acid, which will combine readily with the incrustation, and by which the boiler may therefore be washed. This method of cleansing boilers was recommended by Dr. Wollaston to Mr. Gurney, who informed me, however, that he found that it was not practicable in the way in which boilers must commonly be used.
I apprehend, also, that the spaces between the sheets of copper, in Dr. Church's boiler just described, will hardly permit the steam bubbles which will be formed to escape with sufficient facility into the steam-chest; and being retained in that part of the boiler which is exposed to the action of the fire, the metal will be liable to receive an undue temperature.
I have, however, seen this engine working, and its performance was very satisfactory.
(113.) Various other projects for steam carriages on common roads are in various degrees of advancement, among which may be mentioned those of Messrs. Maudslay and Field, Col. Macerone, and Mr. Russell of Edinburgh; but our limits compel us to omit any detailed account of them.