- LITHOGRAPHERS.—Sarony & Major, 117 Fulton street, New York.
- WOOD ENGRAVERS.—Orr & Richardson, 90 Fulton street, New York.
- PRINTER.—Edward O. Jenkins, 114 Nassau street, New York.
PLATES SUPPLEMENTAL DATA.
- Plate
- “Date of survey.”
- Surveyors
- Delineators.
- I.
- ——
- Charles Sullivan,
- II.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier,
- III.
- 1840
- James McBride,
- No. 2.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier,
- IV.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis.
- E. G. Squier,
- V.
- 1846
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis.
- E. G. Squier,
- VI.
- 1836
- James McBride.
- James McBride.
- VII.
- 1842
- John Locke, M.D.
- John Locke.
- VIII.
- 1840
- James McBride and J. W. Erwin,
- James McBride,
- No. 2.
- 1840
- James McBride J. W. Erwin,
- James McBride,
- No. 3.
- 1846
- James McBride,
- James McBride,
- No. 4.
- 1846
- James McBride and Sam. Forrer,
- James McBride,
- IX.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis,
- E. G. Squier.
- No. 2.
- ——
- No. 3.
- 1818
- C. S. Rafinesque,
- C. S. Rafinesque.
- X.
- 1845
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis,
- E. G. Squier,
- XI.
- 1836
- James McBride and J. W. Erwin,
- J. W. Erwin,
- No. 2.
- 1832
- James McBride,
- James McBride.
- No. 3.
- 1840
- James McBride and J. W. Erwin,
- James McBride,
- XII.
- ——
- C. S. Rafinesque,
- C. S. Rafinesque,
- No. 2.
- 1846
- James McBride.
- James McBride,
- No. 3.
- 1846
- S. T. Oweins and L. K. Dille,
- S. T. Oweins,
- No. 4.
- 1846
- P. N. White,
- P. N. White,
- XIII.
- 1820
- C. S. Rafinesque,
- C. S. Rafinesque,
- No. 2.
- 1836
- James McBride and J. W. Erwin,
- James McBride,
- XIV.
- ——
- Charles Whittlesey,
- Charles Whittlesey,
- No. 2.
- ——
- Charles Whittlesey,
- Charles Whittlesey,
- No. 3.
- 1820
- C. S. Rafinesque.
- C. S. Rafinesque,
- No. 4.
- 1820
- C. S. Rafinesque.
- C. S. Rafinesque.
- XV.
- ——
- Charles Whittlesey,
- Charles Whittlesey,
- No. 2.
- ——
- Charles Whittlesey,
- Charles Whittlesey,
- No. 3.
- ——
- Charles Whittlesey,
- Charles Whittlesey,
- No. 4.
- ——
- Charles Whittlesey,
- Charles Whittlesey,
- No. 5.
- ——
- Charles Whittlesey,
- Charles Whittlesey,
- No. 6.
- ——
- Charles Whittlesey,
- Charles Whittlesey,
- No. 7.
- ——
- Charles Whittlesey
- Charles Whittlesey
- No. 8.
- ——
- Charles Whittlesey
- Charles Whittlesey
- XVI.
- 1846
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- XVII.
- 1845
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- XVIII.
- 1846
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- XIX.
- 1846
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- XX.
- 1846
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- XXI.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier
- E. G. Squier
- No. 2.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- No. 3.
- 1846
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- No. 4.
- 1846
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- XXII.
- 1845
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- No. 2.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- XXIII.
- 1846
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- No. 2.
- 1836
- S. P. Hildreth
- S. P. Hildreth,
- XXIV.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier,
- XXV.
- 1836
- C Whittlesey E. G. S. and E. H. D.
- XXVI.
- 1837
- C Whittlesey and E. G. Squier
- Charles Whittlesey,
- XXVII.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier,
- XXVIII.
- 1846
- E. G. Squier and D Morton
- E. G. Squier,
- No. 2.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis,
- E. G. Squier,
- No. 3.
- 1846
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis,
- E. G. Squier,
- XXIX.
- ——
- James McBride
- James McBride,
- No. 2.
- ——
- Charles Whittlesey,
- Charles Whittlesey,
- No. 3.
- 1823
- Charles Whittlesey,
- Charles Whittlesey,
- XXX.
- 1840
- James McBride,
- James McBride,
- No. 2.
- 1847
- James McBride and J. W. Erwin,
- James McBride,
- No. 3.
- 1845
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier,
- No. 4.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier,
- XXXI.
- 1846
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier,
- No. 2.
- ——
- James McBride and J. W. Erwin
- J. W. Erwin
- No. 3.
- ——
- James McBride and J. W. Erwin
- J. W. Erwin
- No. 4.
- 1842
- James McBride and J. W. Erwin
- James McBride
- XXXII.
- ——
- James McBride and J. W. Erwin
- James McBride
- No. 2.
- 1846
- No. 3.
- 1846
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier,
- No. 4.
- 1846
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier,
- No. 5.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier,
- No. 6.
- 1818
- C. S. Rafinesque
- C. S. Rafinesque,
- XXXIII.
- 1818
- C. S. Rafinesque
- C. S. Rafinesque,
- No. 2.
- 1847
- James McBride,
- James McBride,
- XXXIV.
- 1847
- E. H. Davis,
- E. H. Davis,
- No. 2.
- ——
- Gen Lytle,
- Gen Lytle,
- No. 3.
- 1846
- S. Kyle and L. K. Dillo
- No. 4.
- 1846
- S. Kyle and L. K. Dillo
- XXXV.
- 1846
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- XXXVI.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- No. 2.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- No. 3.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier and E. H. Davis
- E. G. Squier
- No. 4.
- 1847
- E. G. Squier
- XXXVII.
- ——
- William Blanding
- William Blanding
- XXXVIII.
- ——
- C. S. Rafinesque.
- C. S. Rafinesque.
- ----
- ——
- No. 2.
- 1846
- R. Morris.
- R. Morris.
- No. 3.
- 1846
- R. Morris.
- R. Morris.
- No. 4.
- ——
- C. G. Forshey.
- C. G. Forshey.
- XXXIX.
- ——
- James Hough.
- James Hough.
- ——
- James Hough.
- James Hough.
- XL.
- ——
- R. C. Taylor.
- R. C. Taylor.
- XLI.
- ——
- R. C. Taylor and John Locke.
- No. 2.
- ——
- John Locke.
- John Locke.
- XLII.
- ——
- John Locke.
- John Locke.
- No. 2.
- ——
- S. Taylor.
- S. Taylor.
- XLIII.
- ——
- S. Taylor.
- S. Taylor.
- ——
- S. Taylor.
- S. Taylor.
- XLIV.
- ——
- ——
- S. Taylor.
- S. Taylor.
- XLV.
- 1847
- C. Sullivan.
- XLVI.
- ——
- E. G. Squier.
- XLVII.
- ——
- J. French.
- XLVIII.
- ——
- J. French.
LIST OF WOOD ENGRAVINGS.
- [1.]
- View of Great Mound at Miamisburgh, Ohio,
- 3
- [2.]
- Section, exhibiting Septaria,
- 13
- [3.]
- Group of Mounds within an enclosure,
- 27
- [4.]
- Plan of Ancient Work, Lorain county, Ohio,
- 39
- [5.]
- Plan of Ancient Work, Lorain county, Ohio,
- 39
- [6.]
- Plan of Ancient Work, Cuyahoga county, Ohio,
- 40
- [7.]
- Plan of Ancient Work, Cuyahoga county, Ohio,
- 40
- [8.]
- Plan of Ancient Work, Wood county, Ohio,
- 40
- [9.]
- Circle and truncated Pyramid,
- 53
- [10.]
- Plan of Ancient Work, at Circleville, Ohio,
- 60
- [11.]
- Plan of Sacred Enclosure, Pike county, Ohio,
- 66
- [12.]
- Bird-shaped Mound, Newark, Ohio,
- 68
- [13.]
- View of Gateway of Octagon, Newark, Ohio,
- 69
- [14.]
- Truncated Mound covering gateway,
- 69
- [15.]
- Crown-work of Circle,
- 69
- [16.]
- View of “Observatory” at Newark,
- 70
- [17.]
- “Elevated Squares” at Marietta, Ohio,
- 74
- [18.]
- Plan of Ancient Work, Parkersburgh, Virginia,
- 77
- [19.]
- Circle and Mound, Greenup county, Kentucky,
- 82
- [20.]
- Graded Way, Piketon, Ohio,
- 88
- [21.]
- Plan of Ancient Work in Alabama,
- 109
- [22.]
- Plan of Ancient Work in Bolivar county, Mississippi,
- 116
- [23.]
- Public Square of the Muscogulges,
- 121
- [24.]
- Mound at Mount Royal, Florida,
- 122
- [25.]
- Plan of Mound and Parallels,
- 122
- [26.]
- Plan of Works in Wisconsin,
- 133
- [27.]
- Group illustrating the forms of the Mounds,
- 139
- [28.]
- Hill Mounds,
- 141
- [29.]
- Section of Sacrificial Mound,
- 144
- [30.]
- Structure of Mounds,
- 144
- [31.]
- Section of Sacrificial Mound,
- 147
- [32.]
- Plan of Altar,
- 147
- [33.]
- Section of Sacrificial Mound,
- 148
- [34.]
- Section of Sacrificial Mound,
- 149
- [35.]
- Section of Altar,
- 150
- [36.]
- Section of Altar,
- 150
- [37.]
- Section of Sacrificial Mound,
- 152
- [38.]
- Plan of Altar,
- 152
- [39.]
- Section of Sacrificial Mound,
- 153
- [40.]
- Position of recent deposits,
- 153
- [41.]
- Section of Sacrificial Mound,
- 154
- [42.]
- Plan of Excavation, etc.
- 154
- [43.]
- Section of Sacrificial Mound,
- 155
- [44.]
- Section of Sacrificial Mound,
- 156
- [45.]
- Section of Sacrificial Mound,
- 156
- [46.]
- Section of a Stratified Mound,
- 158
- [47.]
- Section of a Mound,
- 159
- [48.]
- View of Elliptical Mound,
- 160
- [49.]
- Group of Sepulchral Mounds,
- 161
- [50.]
- Section of Sepulchral Mound,
- 162
- [51.]
- Plan of Sepulchral Chamber,
- 162
- [52.]
- Section of Sepulchral Mound,
- 164
- [53.]
- Position of Skeleton,
- 164
- [54.]
- Section of Sepulchral Mound,
- 165
- [55.]
- Section of Grave creek Mound,
- 169
- [56.]
- View of Grave creek Mound,
- 169
- [57.]
- Plans of groups of Mounds,
- 170
- [58.]
- Mounds of Oregon,
- 171
- [59.]
- Terraced Mound,
- 173
- [60.]
- Plan of Cahokia Mound,
- 174
- [61.]
- Lozenge-shaped Mound,
- 175
- [62.]
- Section of a truncated Mound,
- 176
- [63.]
- Plan of an Ancient octagonal Terrace,
- 176
- [64.]
- Plan of an Ancient rectangular Terrace,
- 176
- [65.]
- Plan of Temple Mound with graded ascent,
- 177
- [66.]
- Group of Sepulchral Mounds,
- 177
- [67.]
- Plan and Section of Anomalous Mound,
- 178
- [68.]
- Ancient Pipe from the Mounds,
- 179
- [69.]
- Section of Anomalous Mound,
- 180
- [70.]
- Conical Mound,
- 185
- [71.]
- Ancient Pottery, three figures,
- 191
- [72.]
- Ancient Pottery, three figures,
- 192
- [73.]
- Ancient Earthen Vessel,
- 192
- [74.]
- Ancient Earthen Vessel,
- 192
- [75.]
- Ancient Terra Cotta,
- 193
- [76.]
- Terra Cotta from the Mounds,
- 194
- [77.]
- Terra Cotta from the Mounds,
- 194
- [78.]
- Terra Cotta from the Mounds,
- 194
- [79.]
- Terra Cotta from the Mounds,
- 194
- [80.]
- Terra Cotta from the Mounds,
- 194
- [81.]
- Copper Axe from the Mounds,
- 197
- [82.]
- Earthen Pipes, two figures,
- 197
- [83.]
- Adjustment of Ancient Axes,
- 198
- [84.]
- Copper Axe from the Mounds,
- 199
- [85.]
- Copper Gravers from the Mounds, five figures,
- 200
- [86.]
- Copper Spear-head and Knife,
- 201
- [87.]
- Ancient Copper Implements, five figures,
- 201
- [88.]
- Copper Bracelets from the Mounds,
- 204
- [89.]
- Copper Gorgets from the Mounds,
- 205
- [90.]
- Copper Ornament from the Mounds,
- 206
- [91.]
- Copper Ornament from the Mounds,
- 206
- [92.]
- Ancient Work-block of stone,
- 206
- [93.]
- Copper Beads from the Mounds,
- 207
- [94.]
- Copper Fibulæ from the Mounds,
- 207
- [95.]
- Copper Bands, etc.,
- 207
- [96.]
- Silver Beads from the Mounds,
- 207
- [97.]
- Silver Cross,
- 208
- [98.]
- An article of Lead,
- 209
- [99.]
- Flint Spear-heads, three figures,
- 211
- [100.]
- Quartz Spear-head,
- 211
- [101.]
- Ancient Mexican mahquahuitl,
- 211
- [102.]
- Sword of Pacific Islanders,
- 211
- [103.]
- Arrow-heads, nine figures,
- 212
- [104.]
- Hornstone Disks, three figures,
- 214
- [105.]
- Flint Knives, three figures,
- 215
- [106.]
- Hematite Cutting Implements,
- 215
- [107.]
- Slate Cutting Implements,
- 216
- [108.]
- Ancient Stone Axe,
- 216
- [109.]
- Ancient Stone Axe, four figures,
- 217
- [110.]
- Stone Axe from Mounds,
- 217
- [111.]
- Stone Hand-axe,
- 218
- [112.]
- Ancient Stone-axe, four figures,
- 218
- [113.]
- Ancient Scandinavian Axes, two figures,
- 218
- [114.]
- Ancient ornamented Axes, six figures,
- 218
- [115.]
- Ancient ornamented Axe,
- 219
- [116.]
- Ancient Club-head of Stone,
- 219
- [117.]
- Ancient Club-head of Stone,
- 219
- [118.]
- Pestles of Stone, two figures,
- 220
- [119.]
- Implements of Bone, three figures.
- 220
- [120.]
- Ancient Bone Awls,
- 220
- [121.]
- Discoidal Stones, six figures,
- 221
- [122.]
- Tubes of Stone, two figures,
- 224
- [123.]
- Ornamented Stone Tube,
- 225
- [124.]
- Stone Tube,
- 226
- [125.]
- Stone Tubes,
- 227
- [126.]
- Ancient Mound Pipe,
- 227
- [127.]
- Granite Pipe,
- 228
- [128.]
- Modern Indian Pipes,
- 230
- [129.]
- Beads of Shell,
- 232
- [130.]
- Beads of Shell, three figures,
- 233
- [131.]
- Pendants, eight figures,
- 234
- [132.]
- Pendants of Stone,
- 235
- [133.]
- Stone Gorgets, two figures,
- 236
- [134.]
- Stone Gorget,
- 237
- [135.]
- Stone Gorget,
- 237
- [136.]
- Stone Gorgets, seventeen figures,
- 237
- [137.]
- Section of Gorget,
- 238
- [138.]
- Stone Ornaments,
- 239
- [139.]
- Prismatic Tube,
- 240
- [140.]
- Articles of Stone,
- 240
- [141.]
- Mica Ornaments,
- 240
- [142.]
- Sculptured head from the Mounds, two views,
- 244
- [143.]
- Sculptured head from the Mounds, two views,
- 244
- [144.]
- Sculptured head from the Mounds, two views,
- 245
- [145.]
- Sculptured head from the Mounds, two views,
- 245
- [146.]
- Ancient Sculpture,
- 247
- [147.]
- Sculptured Pipe,
- 247
- [148.]
- Sculptured Pipe,
- 248
- [149.]
- Sculptured Pipe,
- 249
- [150.]
- Mask of Stone,
- 250
- [151.]
- Mask of Stone,
- 251
- [152.]
- Mask of Stone,
- 251
- [153.]
- Sculpture of the Manitus,
- 251
- [154.]
- Sculpture of the Manitus,
- 252
- [155.]
- Sculpture of the Beaver,
- 256
- [156.]
- Sculpture of the Otter,
- 256
- [157.]
- Sculpture of the Otter,
- 256
- [158.]
- Sculpture of the Panther,
- 256
- [159.]
- Sculpture of the Panther,
- 256
- [160.]
- Sculpture of the Panther,
- 256
- [161.]
- Sculptured head of Elk,
- 257
- [162.]
- Sculptured Head,
- 258
- [163.]
- Sculptured Head,
- 258
- [164.]
- Sculpture of tufted Heron,
- 259
- [165.]
- Sculpture of Eagle,
- 259
- [166.]
- Sculpture of Hawk,
- 261
- [167.]
- Sculpture of Swallow,
- 261
- [168.]
- Sculpture of Summer Duck,
- 261
- [169.]
- Sculpture of Toucan?
- 261
- [170.]
- Sculpture of Grouse,
- 261
- [171.]
- Sculpture of Turkey Buzzard?
- 261
- [172.]
- Sculpture of Paroquet,
- 263
- [173.]
- Sculpture of Bird
- 263
- [174.]
- Sculpture of Bird
- 263
- [175.]
- Sculpture of Bird
- 263
- [176.]
- Sculpture of Bird
- 263
- [177.]
- Sculpture of Bird
- 264
- [178.]
- Sculpture of Toucan,
- 266
- [179.]
- Sculpture of unknown Bird,
- 267
- [180.]
- Heads of Eagles,
- 267
- [181.]
- Head of Raven?
- 267
- [182.]
- Sculpture of unknown Bird,
- 267
- [183.]
- Sculpture of Toad,
- 269
- [184.]
- Sculpture of Toad,
- 269
- [185.]
- Sculpture of Frog,
- 269
- [186.]
- Sculpture of Rattlesnake,
- 269
- [187.]
- Sculptured head of Goose,
- 269
- [188.]
- Sculptured Death’s Head,
- 269
- [189.]
- Sculptured Head of Bear?
- 271
- [190.]
- Sculptured Head of Wolf?
- 271
- [191.]
- Sculptured Head of unknown animal,
- 271
- [192.]
- Sculptured Head of unknown animal,
- 271
- [193.]
- Sculptured Head of unknown animal,
- 271
- [194.]
- Front View of Tablet found at Cincinnati,
- 275
- [195.]
- Reverse of same,
- 275
- [196.]
- Carving of Rattlesnake, coiled,
- 276
- [197.]
- Shark’s Teeth, fossil,
- 282
- [198.]
- Marine Shell, pyrula perversa,
- 283
- [199.]
- Section of Hill Mound,
- 289
- [200.]
- Inscribed Rock on Guyandotte river, Va.,
- 294
- [201.]
- Inscribed Rock on Guyandotte river, Va.,
- 295
- [202.]
- Inscribed Rock on Guyandotte river, Va.,
- 295
- [203.]
- Inscribed Rock on Guyandotte river, Va.,
- 296
- [204.]
- Inscribed Rock on Guyandotte river, Va.,
- 296
- [205.]
- Inscribed Rock on Guyandotte river, Va.,
- 297
- [206.]
- Inscribed Rock on Ohio river,
- 298
- [207.]
- Site of Sculptured Rocks of the Guyandotte
- 299
PREFACE.
The fact of the existence, within the valley of the Mississippi river and its tributaries, of many ancient monuments of human labor and skill, seems to have escaped the notice of the adventurers who first made known to the world the extent and fertility of that vast region. Except some incidental allusions by La Vega, and the Portuguese chronicler of De Soto’s unfortunate expedition, to structures bearing some analogy to those of the West, (and which seem to have been occupied, if they were not built, by the Indians of Florida,) we find no mention made of these monuments by any of the earlier explorers. No sooner, however, had trade been opened with the Indians beyond the Alleghanies, and the valley of the Mississippi begun to attract the attention of the rival nations that laid claim to this division of the continent, than the less prominent features of the country became subjects of observation and remark. Then, for the first time, we find these ancient monuments distinctly alluded to. It was not however until some time afterwards, when settlements had been established at various prominent points within the valley, and the tide of emigration began to flow thitherward, that any special attention was directed to them. Carver in 1776, and Hearte and others in 1791, were among the earliest of these observers at the North. Their accounts, however, served scarcely to make known the existence of these remains, and failed to convey any clear idea of their extent or character. But as the country became better known and more densely populated, notices of their existence became more numerous, and some detailed accounts of particular groups were presented to the world, in the form of incidental notices in books of travel and local gazetteers, or in contributions to the pages of periodicals, and to the transactions of learned societies. HARRIS, in his “Tour into the Territory north-west of the Ohio,” published in 1805, noticed at considerable length the ancient remains at Marietta on the Ohio river; and H. H. BRACKENRIDGE, one of the most accurate of the early explorers of the West, in his “Views of Louisiana,” published in 1814, and in a paper in the first volume of the new series of the Transactions of the “American Philosophical Society,” presented accounts of ancient remains at various points, together with some general remarks upon our antiquities, distinguished for their comprehensiveness and sound philosophical spirit. Bishop MADISON of Virginia, in 1803, addressed to Dr. Barton, then Vice President of the American Philosophical Society, a communication of considerable length “upon the supposed fortifications of the western country,” which was published in the sixth volume of the old series of the Transactions of that institution. It contains some interesting facts relative to the ancient remains found within the valley of the great Kenhawa river, in Virginia, and is principally devoted to combating the popular notion that all the ancient earthworks were of defensive origin. BARTRAM, in his animated Journal of Travels in Florida, published in 1779, makes frequent mention of the ancient remains which fell under his notice. His accounts have been amply confirmed by later observations, and they may be regarded as presenting a very accurate view of their general character. Previous to Bartram’s expedition, Adair, in his “Account of the American Indians,” published in 1775, mentioned the existence of these remains, but gave no details respecting them.
In 1817, DE WITT CLINTON, whose active mind neglected no department of inquiry, read a paper before the “Literary and Philosophical Society of New York,” (an institution no longer existing,) upon the “Antiquities of the western part of New York,” which was subsequently published in a pamphlet form. It gave a connected view of these antiquities so far as then known, and indicated their character with such clearness, as to identify them at once as belonging to that imposing class of remains found in the valley of the Mississippi. MCCAULEY, in his “History of New York,” published at a later period, (1829,) added considerably to the number of facts presented by Mr. CLINTON.
Among the earliest and more important contributions to the general stock of information respecting the western monuments, is the chapter entitled “Antiquities,” contained in “The Natural and Statistical View of Cincinnati and the Miami country,” by DANIEL DRAKE, M.D., published in 1815. It not only embraces many facts, but is free from the tendency towards exaggeration which has been the prevailing fault of most that has been written upon the subject of American Antiquities. In connection with what was published by Mr. BRACKENRIDGE, and at a subsequent date by the late President HARRISON, (Address before the Historical Society of Ohio, 1832,) it presents a better view of the ancient remains of the region north of the Ohio, than can be obtained from any other source,—Mr. ATWATER’S Memoir, in the Transactions of the American Antiquarian Society, alone excepted.
It would be impossible, as it is unnecessary, particularly to point out all that has been published upon this subject, chiefly consisting, as it does, of detached and incidental observations. In addition to the several authorities above named, we may mention LEWIS and CLARKE, Major LONG, Dr. EDWIN JAMES, HENRY R. SCHOOLCRAFT, TIMOTHY FLINT, HUGH WILLIAMSON, Dr. BARTON, Rev. JOSEPH DODDRIDGE, President JEFFERSON, Dr. LEWIS C. BECK, Dr. S. P. HILDRETH, KEATING, HAYWOOD, HOWE, NUTTALL, LATROBE, ROCHEFAUCAULT, SHORT, COLLINS, DICKESON, BROWN, FEATHERSTONHAUGH, Professors GERARD TROOST, JOHN LOCKE, and C. G. FORSHEY, R. C. and S. TAYLOR, Prince MAXIMILIAN, Prof. RAFINESQUE, CHARLES WHITTLESEY, etc., etc., as among those who have contributed to the general stock of information upon this subject.