"Yes. But he knew nothing about the tie. He could not have taken it. I am sure he didn't."
The detective smiled in a puzzled manner. "Upon my word Mr. Ainsleigh, you defend everyone. First Tung-yu, now Mr. Burgh, who is your enemy."
"I have so many enemies," said Rupert with a shrug, "Tung-yu told me that Burgh and Forge and Major Tidman were my enemies."
"That's a lie on Tung-yu's part," chimed in the Major angrily. "I am not your enemy."
Rupert turned on him quickly. "Prove it then," he said, sharply, "by stating that I was with you on the beach last night after eleven."
"Oh, oh," cried Rodgers smiling, "so you can prove an alibi after all, Mr. Ainsleigh."
"Yes," said Rupert shortly. "But I did not wish to speak, until I heard what Major Tidman had to say."
Rodgers shook his head. "You have too nice a sense of honour," was his remark, "or else you are very deep."
Rupert did not reply. His eyes were fixed on the Major's face, which changed to various colours. "You knew my father well Tidman?"
"Yes. We were old friends--good friends," faltered the other.