"I shall esteem it a very great favour if you will be so good as to turn over in your mind the probable theory of those statements, and give me your opinion. If Mr. Watt's reports of his experiments are correct, how is it possible that the high-pressure engine that I built at the Herland thirteen years ago, which discharged the steam in open air, did more than twenty-eight millions? If you wish, I will send a copy of the certificate of the duty done by this engine, which states very minutely every circumstance. Now that cylinder, with every part of the engine, was exposed to the cold; had it been heated around those surfaces, as on the present plan, it would have done above forty millions.
"Suppose the Binner Downs 70-inch cylinder engine, 10-feet stroke, working with full steam to the bottom of the stroke, when, by the experiment, the heated flues were again laid on would have worked one-third expansive, by the heat of 5 bushels of coal around the cylinder. Now one-third of the power would make a 3 feet 4 inch stroke, 11 lbs. to the inch effective power, eight strokes a minute, during twenty-four hours, by the consumption of 5 bushels of coal applied on the surface sides of the cylinder, performing a duty of 324 millions with a bushel of coal. Now suppose the cylinder without the heating flues had the steam cut off at two-thirds of the stroke, and that it is possible in a moment to heat the cylinder by the flues; in that case the steam would, by its expansion from the hot sides, fill the last third of the cylinder to the bottom of the stroke; then if that steam could be suddenly cooled, so as to contract it one-third, the piston would ascend one-third its stroke in the cylinder; and it appears in theory by this plan, that a cylinder once filled two-thirds full of steam, by receiving the heat on its surface sides from 5 bushels of coal, and again suddenly cooling down, would continue to work for ever, without removing the steam from the cylinder, and would perform a duty of 324 millions. This never can be accomplished in practice in this way, but the effect may be obtained by partially condensing in a suitable condenser, and again heating by hot sides.
"This mystery ought to be laid open by experiment, for what I have stated are plain facts from actual proofs, and I have no doubt that time will show that the theory of Mr. Watt is incorrect. Though there were 300 feet of cold sides, yet 200 feet were not condensing steam, because on the return of the piston, what was condensed below, and while the engine was resting, did not make against it more than what was condensed above the piston on its descent; therefore you may count on 150 feet of cold external sides constantly condensing, that made this third-part difference against the expansion of the steam.
"I remain, Sir,
"Your humble servant,
"Ricd. Trevithick.
The writer's note-book used during those experiments is in his possession, as well as Trevithick's note-book giving particulars of experiments at several mines, from which the following extracts are taken:—
"Cornwall, August, 1828.—Wheal Towan 80-inch cylinder, 10-feet stroke, 6·9 strokes per minute, loaded to 9·5 lbs. on the inch of the piston, with three of Trevithick's boilers, each 37 feet long, 6 feet 2 inches diameter, with fire-tube 3 feet 9 inches diameter, fire-place 6 feet long, evaporated 13 square feet of water with 1 bushel of coal,[165] duty 87 millions. The heat in the stack was just the same as the heat of the steam in the boiler. Another engine of the same size on the same mine, with similar boilers, but working only 4·06 strokes per minute, loaded to 4·55 lbs. on each inch of the piston, did 50·8 millions.
"Wheal Vor 53-inch cylinder, 9-feet stroke, 6·59 strokes per minute, loaded to 19·58 lbs. on each square inch of the piston, did 36·6 millions.
"Wheal Damsel 41-inch cylinder, 7 feet 6 inch stroke, 5·52 strokes per minute, loaded to 21·5 lbs. on the inch of the piston, did 33 millions.
"It would appear, therefore, that about 10 lbs. to the inch on the piston allows of the best duty, and that a 10-feet stroke exceeds in duty a 7 feet 6 inch stroke.