“I’m not sure you can show that logically,” said Mr Graham. “I will think it over, however—not that I mean to take up any defence of myself. But now I have letters to write, and must ask you to leave me. Come and see me again to-morrow.”

Malcolm went from him—

like one that hath been stunned,
And is of sense forlorn.

Here was trouble upon trouble! But what had befallen him compared with what had come upon the schoolmaster! A man like him to be so treated! How gladly he would work for him all the rest of his days! And how welcome his grandfather would make him to his cottage! Lord Lossie would be the last to object. But he knew it was a baseless castle while he built it, for Mr Graham would assuredly provide for himself, if it were by breaking stones on the road and saying the Lord’s Prayer. It all fell to pieces just as he lifted his hand to Miss Horn’s knocker.

She received him with a cordiality such as even she had never shown him before. He told her what threatened Mr Graham. She heard him to the end without remark, beyond the interjection of an occasional “Eh, sirs!” then sat for a minute in troubled silence.

“There’s a heap o’ things an ’uman like me,” she said at length, “canna un’erstan’. I didna ken whether some fowk mair nor preten’ to un’erstan’ them. But set Sandy Graham doon upo’ ae side, an’ the presbytery doon upo’ the ither, an’ I hae wit eneuch to ken whilk I wad tak my eternal chance wi’. Some o’ the presbytery’s guid eneuch men, but haena ower muckle gumption; an’ some o’ them has plenty o’ gumption, but haena ower muckle grace, ta jeedge by the w’y ’at they glower an’ rair, layin’ doon the law as gien the Almichty had been driven to tak coonsel wi’ them. But luik at Sandy Graham! Ye ken whether he has gumption or no; an’ gien he be a stickit minister, he stack by the grace o’ moadesty. But, haith, I winna peety him! for, o’ a’ things, to peety a guid man i’ the richt gate is a fule’s folly. Troth, I’m a hantle mair concernt aboot yersel’, Ma’colm!”

Malcolm heard her without apprehension. His cup seemed full, and he never thought that cups sometimes run over. But perhaps he was so far the nearer to a truth: while the cup of blessing may and often does run over, I doubt if the cup of suffering is ever more than filled to the brim.

“Onything fresh, mem?” he asked, with the image of Mrs Stewart standing ghastly on the slopes of his imagination.

“I wadna be fit to tell ye, laddie, gien ’t warna, as ye ken, ’at the Almichty’s been unco mercifu’ to me i’ the maitter o’ feelin’s. Yer freen’s i’ the Seaton, an’ ower at Scaurnose, hae feelin’s, an’ that’s hoo nane o’ them a’ has pluckit up hert to tell ye o’ the waggin’ o’ slanderous tongues against ye.”

“What are they sayin’ noo?” asked Malcolm with considerable indifference.