| De Witt Clinton High School | 377 |
| High School of Commerce | 363 |
| Morris High School | 345 |
| Boys' High School | 344 |
The winning team averaged 47-3/8 out of 50.
Two boys made perfect scores.
Each member of the winning team was given a bronze badge modeled from the Whitney trophy.
The result of this match greatly stimulated interest in the shooting. It also attracted public attention.
During the fall of 1905, and the spring of 1906, the league was able to equip the remainder of the other six high schools with the machine.
In 1906 it employed Capt. G. W. Corwin, inspector of rifle practice in the Seventy-first Regiment, New York National Guard, and one of the best shots in the National Guard, as a general instructor, who served until after the Creedmoor competition.
He selected in each school a teacher who was interested in the subject (usually the athletic instructor) as superintendent of shooting, and in each class four boys as sergeant-instructors. The superintendent and these boys were carefully instructed by Captain Corwin in the theory and practice of shooting, so as to make them competent instructors.
The system adopted varied in the different schools. Most of them preferred to use school hours for the purpose. In these schools, usually when each class was sent to the gymnasium for physical exercise, squads of boys in rotation were detached to practice their firing under the immediate direction of a sergeant-instructor, and the general direction of the superintendent of shooting, the whole being carefully supervised by Captain Corwin.
Some schools preferred to have their shooting after school hours, in which case, however, it was carried on under the same general principle.