Insanity: Its Causes and Prevention

by Henry Putnam Stearns

Now, one of the inferences of the gynæcologist is likely to be, that the uterine lesion, of whatever nature it may chance to be, is the cause of the failure in mental and general health; that it is the “fons et origo” whence has arisen the long train of nervous symptoms, and, doubtless, in some cases this may be a correct inference; but in a vast majority of cases my impression is that both the existing debility of the nervous system and the uterine lesion are to be regarded as consequences, and that neither is a cause of the other, but rather that they both result mainly from a failure in the discharge of those functions which more especially pertain to the sexual system, and a disregard of the laws of health as to physical exercise.

But what I desire to specially note in this connection is, that these symptoms or manifestations of nervous derangement are not those of insanity, that they rarely pass over or develop into those of insanity. There is prevalent, both among lay and professional persons, an idea that a large number of females become insane, from the existence of some such uterine conditions, or that these have a large influence in producing insanity. My experience, however, points to an opposite conclusion. It is rare to find any of the uterine lesions referred to existing among insane women; and this is doubtless explicable for physiological reasons.

In almost all cases of acute insanity there exists a much larger amount of mental activity than when the brain is in a normal condition. The processes of thought go on during a larger number of hours every day, and the period of sleep, in which there is a demand for a more limited supply of blood in the brain, is correspondingly diminished. Then, again, the character of mental operations is generally of much greater intensity; impressions are more numerous, sensations are more vivid, and thoughts press their way onward through the channels of nerve-cells and fibres of the brain with greater rapidity and constancy.

Almost the whole force and energy of the nervous system appear to be centred in the brain, and to supply the wear arising from such increased activity of the brain, the system calls for a larger supply of blood in this organ. It is therefore diverted from other portions, and there results a diminished sensibility and activity especially of the sexual system. In a large majority of these cases also, the monthly discharge ceases to appear, and the sexual functions are in partial abeyance.

Now, in consequence of those changes which tend to occur in the vessels and cells of the brain when a person becomes insane, if there were existing any such functional uterine lesions as I have referred to, there would at once arise a tendency to recovery from them; the monthly congestions generally disappear, and such passive congestions as may have long existed would also tend to pass away. An inflamed, or irritable, or ulcerated neck would, in the absence of the usual physiological activities of the organ, have a tendency toward recovery, except in some few rare cases; and by the removal of congestions there would exist little if any cause for displacements.

This may be said to be mere theory, but it happens to be certainly in accordance with the experience of those psychologists who have studied the tendencies and conditions of the uterus during periods of insanity. In an experience extending over many years and embracing many cases, the number of the above-named uterine diseases found by me could almost, if not quite, be counted on my fingers.

While, therefore, such diseases of different kinds and degrees may, and generally do, co-exist with general debility of the nervous system, they are rarely found to be, and probably seldom are sufficient in themselves, as causes of insanity, though they may sometimes be allied with other and more potent influences in its production.

I may add that similar conditions of the female nervous system not unfrequently arise among the married, when persons long live in the relations of marriage, and yet without its natural results in the way of a number of children, especially if, as is almost always the case, improper measures are used to prevent the increase of the family.

I might in this place refer to another of those conditions of life inherent in our civilization, which is unfavorable to the mental health of the female sex, viz., the limited sphere of physical and mental occupation, as compared with that of the male sex. So much, however, has been written on this subject in its relations to and effects upon the general welfare of women, and there appears to be so large a tendency on the part of society, at least in this country, to admit her to any and almost all such occupations as she may qualify herself to follow, that I shall not refer to it further than to remark that, in so far as there may exist a disposition on the part of women to avoid the care and responsibility incident to home life and family, and, instead, to indulge in physical inactivity; in so far as they avoid physical exercise in the open air, and spend their hours of leisure in reading exciting novels, or love-stories, whose heroes and heroines are generally of almost any other kind of character than real, living, healthy, ones; in so far as they avoid the conscientious discharge of those duties which devolve upon them by virtue of their high mission as wives and mothers, and seek, instead, to follow occupations or professions for which they cannot be best qualified by reason of the nature, physiological activities, and duties of their sex; in so far as they divert that nervous energy and physical strength which is designed by nature to enable them to discharge the sacred function of motherhood into other channels of activity, however high and ennobling they may be,—in just so far are they deviating from that great highway which leads to mental health and the highest interests of humanity.

No aspirations of woman can ever reach so high and grand a sphere in the activities of the world as that enshrined in the name of mother; and since Nature has crowned her with this supremest function, all effort to forget or change it, to belittle or push it aside for other more transitory pleasures or missions, can only lead, in the end, to unhappiness and too often to disease.