Dr. Dushman chose for his title the one which we adopted for this book. It became necessary, therefore, for us to find a new title for his essay; aside from this instance, the main titles appearing at the heads of the various complete essays are those of the authors. The subtitles have in practically every instance been supplied editorially.

Dr. Pickering submitted two essays, one written from the viewpoint of the physicist, the other from that of the astronomer. To make each complete, he naturally found it necessary to duplicate between them certain introductory and general material. We have run the two essays together into a single narrative, with the elimination of this duplicated material; aside from this blue-penciling no alteration has been made in Dr. Pickering’s text. This text however served as the basis of blue-penciling that of several other contestants, as indicated in the foot notes.

For the reader who is qualified or who can qualify to understand it, Dr. Murnaghan’s essay is perhaps the most illuminating of all. Even the reader who does not understand it all will realize that its author brings to the subject a freshness of viewpoint and an originality of treatment which are rather lacking in some of the published essays, and which it will readily be understood were conspicuously lacking in a good many of the unpublished ones. Dr. Murnaghan of all the competitors has come closest to making a contribution to science as well as to the semi-popular literature of science.

In the composite chapters, the brackets followed by reference numbers have been used as the most practicable means of identifying the various individual contributions. We believe that this part of the text can be read without allowing the frequent occurrence of these symbols to distract the eye. As to the references themselves, the asterisk marks the contributions of the Editor. The numbers are those attached to the essays in order of and at the time of their receipt; it has been more convenient to use these than to assign consecutive numbers to the quoted essays. The several numbers identify passages from the essays of the following contestants:

10: Frederick W. Shurlock, Derby, England.
18: L. L. Whyte, Cambridge, England.
24: Prof. Moritz Schlick, University of Rostock, Germany.
30: C. E. Rose, M.E., Little Rock, Ark.
33: H. Gartelmann, Bremen, Germany.
35: Prof. Joseph S. Ames, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore.
47: James O. G. Gibbons, East Orange. N. J.
82: Charles H. Burr, Philadelphia.
101: L. F. H. de Miffonis. B.A., C.E., Ottawa, Canada.
102: Charles A. Brunn, Kansas City.
106: J. Elias Fries, Fellow A.I.E.E., Birmingham, Ala.
114: Dean W. P. Graham, Syracuse University, Syracuse, N. Y.
115: Rev. George Thomas Manley, London.
116: Prof. J. A. Schouten, Delft, Netherlands.
121: Elwyn F. Burrill, Berkeley, Cal.
125: Dorothy Burr, Bryn Mawr, Pa.
130: C. W. Kanolt, Bureau of Standards, Washington.
135: Robert Stevenson, New York.
139: Leopold Schorsch, New York.
141: Dr. M. C. Mott-Smith, Los Angeles, Calif.
147: Edward A. Clarke, Columbus, O.
149: Edward A. Partridge, Philadelphia.
150: Col. John Millis, U. S. A., Chicago.
152: George F. Marsteller, Detroit.
156: D. B. Hall, Cincinnati.
165: Francis Farquhar, York, Pa.
178: Dr. George de Bothezat, Dayton, O.
179: Professor A. E. Caswell, University of Oregon, Eugene, Ore.
182: C. E. Dimick, New London, Conn.
186: Earl R. Evans, Washington, D. C.
188: Norman E. Gilbert, Dartmouth College, Hanover, N. H.
192: A. d’Abro. New York.
194: L. M. Alexander, Cincinnati.
197: Kenneth W. Reed, East Cleveland, O.
198: Prof. E. N. da C. Andrade, Ordnance College, Woolwich, England.
216: Professor Andrew H. Patterson, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, N. C.
220: Prof. Arthur Gordon Webster, Clark College, Worcester, Mass.
221: Walter van B. Roberts, Princeton University, N. J.
223: Paul M. Batchelder, Austin, Tex.
227: Prof. R. W. Wood, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore.
229: E. P. Fairbairn, M.C., B.Sc., Glasgow.
231: R. F. Deimel, Hoboken, N. J.
232: Lieut. W. Mark Angus, U. S. N., Philadelphia.
235: Edward Adams Richardson, Kansas City.
263: Prof. William Benjamin Smith, Tulane University, New Orleans.
264: James Rice, University of London, London.
267: William Hemmenway Pratt, Lynn, Mass.
272: R. Bruce Lindsay, New Bedford, Mass.
283: Frank E. Law, Montclair, N. J.

In addition to the specific credit given by these references for specifically quoted passages, the Editor feels that he ought to acknowledge his general indebtedness to the competing essayists, collectively, for the many ideas which he has taken away from their text to clothe in his own words. This does not mean that the Editor has undertaken generally to improve upon the language of the competitors, but merely that the reading of all their essays has given him many ideas of such complex origin that he could not assign credit if he would.

Table of Contents

I.—[The Einstein $5,000 Prize]: How the Contest Came to be Held, and Some of the Details of Its Conduct. By the Editor 1

II.—[The World—And Us]: An Introductory Discussion of the Philosophy of Relativity, and of the Mechanism of our Contact with Time and Space. By various contributors and the Editor 19