Climate and Time in Their Geological Relations / A Theory of Secular Changes of the Earth's Climate

by James Croll

But as the shells were not preserved, we have, of course, no means of determining whether they were of marine or of freshwater origin.

In another pit, at a short distance from the above, Cyprina Islandica was found in a bed at the depth of 54 feet below the surface.[287]

In a paper read by Mr. James Smith, of Jordanhill, to the Geological Society, April 24th, 1850,[288] the discovery is recorded of a stratified bed containing Tellina proxima intercalated between two distinct boulder clays. The bed was discovered by Mr. James Russell in sinking a well at Chapelhall, near Airdrie. Its height above sea-level was 510 feet. The character of the shell not only proves the marine origin of the bed, but also the existence of a submergence to that extent during an inter-glacial period.

On the other hand, the difficulty besetting the theory of the marine origin of the deposits is this. The intercalated boulder clays bear no marks of stratification, and are evidently the true unstratified till formed when the country was covered by ice. But the fact that these beds are both underlaid and overlaid by stratified deposits would, on the marine theory, imply not merely the repeated appearance and disappearance of the ice, but also the repeated submergence and emergence of the land. If the opinion be correct that the submergences and emergences of the glacial epoch were due to depressions and elevations of the land, and not to oscillations of sea-level, then the difficulty in question is, indeed, a formidable one. But, on the other hand, if the theory of submergences propounded in Chapters [XXIII.] and [XXIV.] be the true one, the difficulty entirely disappears. The explanation is as follows, viz., during a cold period of the glacial epoch, when the winter solstice was in aphelion, the low grounds would be covered with ice, under which a mass of till would be formed. After the cold began to decrease, and the ice to disappear from the plains, the greatest rise of the ocean, for reasons already stated, would take place. The till covering the low grounds would be submerged to a considerable depth and would soon be covered over by mud, sand, and gravel, carried down by streams from the high ground, which, at the time, would still be covered with snow and ice. In course of time the sea would begin to sink and a warm and continental period of, perhaps, from 6,000 to 10,000 years, would follow, when the sea would be standing at a much lower level than at present. The warm period would be succeeded by a second cold period, and the ice would again cover the land and form a second mass of till, which, in some places, would rest directly on the former till, while in other places it would be laid down upon the surface of the sands and gravels overlying the first mass. Again, on the disappearance of the ice the second mass of till would be covered over in like manner by mud, sand, and gravel, and so on, while the eccentricity of the earth’s orbit continued at a high value. In this way we might have three, four, five, or more masses of till separated by beds of sand and gravel.

It will be seen from [Table IV.] of the eccentricity of the earth’s orbit, given in [Chapter XIX.], that the former half of that long succession of cold and warm periods, known as the glacial epoch, was much more severe than the latter half. That is to say, in the former half the accumulation of ice during the cold periods, and its disappearance in polar regions during the warm periods, would be greater than in the latter half. It was probable that it was during the warm periods of the earlier part of the glacial epoch that the two buried channels of the Midland valley were occupied by rivers, and that it was during the latter and less severe part of the glacial epoch that these channels became filled up with that remarkable series of deposits which we have been considering.

Other buried River Channels.—A good many examples of buried river channels have been found both in Scotland and in England, though none of them of so remarkable a character as the two occupying the valley of the Forth and Clyde Canal which have been just described. I may, however, briefly refer to one or two localities where some of these occur.

(1.) An ancient buried river channel, similar to the one extending from Kilsyth to Grangemouth, exists in the coal-fields of Durham, and is known to miners in the district as the “Wash.” Its course was traced by Mr. Nicholas Wood, F.G.S., and Mr. E. F. Boyd, from Durham to Newcastle, a distance of fourteen miles.[289] It traverses, after passing the city of Durham, a portion of the valley of the Wear, passes Chester-le-Street, and then follows the valley of the river Team, and terminates at the river Tyne. And what is remarkable, it enters the Tyne at a depth of 140 feet below the present level of the sea. This curious hollow lies buried, like the Scottish one just alluded to, under an enormous mass of drift, and it is only through means of boring and other mining operations that its character has been revealed. The bottom and sides of this channel everywhere bear evidence of long exposure to the abrading influence of water in motion; the rocky bottom being smoothed, furrowed, and water-worn. The river Wear of the present day flows to the sea over the surface of the drift at an elevation of more than 100 feet above this buried river-bed. At the time that this channel was occupied by running water the sea-level must have been at least 140 feet lower than at present. This old river evidently belongs to the same continental period as those of Scotland.

(2.) From extensive borings and excavations, made at the docks of Hull and Grimsby, it is found that the ancient bed of the Humber is buried under more than 100 feet of silt, clay, and gravel. At Hull the bottom of this buried trough was found to be 110 feet below the sea-level. And what is most interesting at both these places, the remains of a submerged forest was found at a depth of from thirty to fifty feet below the sea-level. In some places two forests were found divided by a bed of leafy clay from five to fifteen feet thick.

(3.) In the valleys of Norfolk we also find the same conditions exhibited. The ancient bed of the Yare and other rivers of this district enter the sea at a depth of more than 100 feet below the present sea-level. At Yarmouth the surface was found 170 feet thick, and the deep surface extends along the Yare to beyond Norwich. Buried forests are also found here similar to those on the Humber.

It is probable that all our British rivers flow into the sea over their old buried channels, except in cases where they may have changed their courses since the beginning of the glacial epoch.