In making this investigation into the history of lynching in the United States, my point of view has been that of a student of society and social phenomena. The purpose of the investigation has not been primarily to write the history of lynching, but to determine from the history the causes for the prevalence of the practice, to determine what the social conditions are under which lynch-law operates, and to test the validity of the arguments which have been advanced in justification of lynching.

At the present time many positive opinions are held with reference to lynching, and these are quite at variance one with another. Any one who attempts to investigate a subject under such conditions cannot hope to escape criticism; neither can he hope to have given the subject equal consideration from every standpoint. The most that one can say is that he has pursued the investigation with perfect honesty of purpose and with openness of mind. To this study of the history of lynching I have brought no theories to prove and no conscious prejudices to confirm. My first endeavor has been to obtain all the facts possible; my final endeavor has been to point out the conclusions clearly warranted by such facts.

The material for a study of this nature is found in a wide range of sources and I gratefully record here my obligations to those who have aided me in the task of collecting and sifting this material. For some very valuable notes on the early history of lynch-law I am indebted to Mr. Albert Matthews, of Boston, Massachusetts. Of his notes I have made free use, indicating my obligation to him in each instance, either by the use of the letter (M) or by special mention. Six of the chapters have been read by him in the manuscript, and he has given me much encouragement and kindly criticism during the preparation of these pages for publication.

For many valuable suggestions during the prosecution of this study I am indebted to members of the Faculty of the Social Sciences of Yale University, especially to Professors Sumner, Farnam, Bourne, and Keller. The editors of the Yale Review have very courteously permitted me to use in Chapter VIII the material which was published in a condensed form in the Yale Review for August, 1904. To many others whom I cannot here mention by name I desire to express my thanks and acknowledge my indebtedness for information given in response to inquiries.

The number of requests which have come to hand for copies of this study, from persons living in various sections of the United States as well as in Europe, and the attention that has been given the subject of lynchings in newspapers and magazines, indicate a desire on the part of the general public to learn the facts concerning lynchings. By many it is believed that in no other respect to-day is American civilization so open to reproach as in its toleration of the practice of lynching, and there is an increasing demand that this summary method of administering justice be suppressed and utterly abolished. That this book may contribute in some measure to a better understanding of this most serious and difficult problem is the hope with which it is placed in the hands of the reader.

J. E. C.

CONTENTS

Chapter I
PAGE
Introduction[1]
Chapter II
Origin of the Term Lynch-law[13]
Chapter III
Early Lynch-law[41]
Chapter IV
Lynch-law 1830–1860[90]
Chapter V
The Reconstruction Period[137]
Chapter VI
Lynchings[155]
Chapter VII
Lynch-law and its Justification[193]
Chapter VIII
Remedies[227]
Chapter IX
Some Conclusions[267]
List of Periodicals Cited[280]
Index[282]

CHARTS

FACING PAGE
I.Number lynched compared with number legally executed, 1882–1903[162]
II.Number lynched according to months in different sections of the U. S., 1882–1903[163]
III.Percentages lynched for various causes by months, 1882–1903[170]
IV.Number of Whites, Negroes and Others lynched according to years, 1882–1903[171]
V.Number of women (Whites and Negroes) lynched according to years, 1882–1903[172]
Proportion lynched for various causes, 1882–1903, Women (Whites and Negroes).
VI.Percentages lynched for various causes by years, 1882–1903, Whites and Others[173]
VII.Percentages lynched for various causes by years, 1882–1903, Negroes[174]
VIII.Proportion lynched for various causes, 1882–1903, Whites and Others[175]
IX.Proportion lynched for various causes, 1882–1903, Negroes[176]
X.Proportion lynched for various causes in Southern States, 1882–1903, Whites and Others[177]
XI.Proportion lynched for various causes in Southern States, 1882–1903, Negroes[178]
XII.Proportion lynched for various causes in Western States, 1882–1903[179]
XIII.Proportion lynched for various causes in Eastern States, 1882–1903[180]