133. If the spectator is at rest without their Orbits, the Planets will seem to be at the same distance as the Stars; but continually changing their places with respect to the Stars, and to one another: assuming various phases of increase and decrease like the Moon. And, notwithstanding their regular motions about the Sun, will sometimes appear to move quicker, sometimes slower, be as often to the west as to the east of the Sun; and at their greatest distances seem quite stationary. The duration, extent, and points in the Heavens where these digressions begin and end, would be more or less according to the respective distances of the several Planets from the Sun: but in the same Planet they would continue invariably the same at all times; like pendulums of unequal lengths oscillating together, the shorter move quick and go over a small space, the longer move slow and go over a large space. If the observer is at rest within the Orbits of the Planets, but not near the common center, their apparent motions will be irregular, but less so than in the former case. Each of the several Planets will appear bigger and less by turns, as they approach nearer or recede farther from the observer; the nearest varying most in their size. They will also move quicker or slower with regard to the fixed Stars, but will never be retrograde or stationary.
134. Next, let a spectator in motion view the Heavens: the same apparent irregularities will be observed, but with some variation resulting from his own motion. If he is on a Planet which has a rotation on it’s Axis, not being sensible of his own motion he will imagine the whole Heavens, Sun, Planets, and Stars to revolve about him in the same time that his Planet turns round, but the contrary way; and will not be easily convinced of the deception. If his Planet moves round the Sun, the same irregularities and aspects as above will appear in the motions of the Planets: only, the times of their being direct, stationary and retrograde will be accelerated or retarded as they concur with, or are contrary to his motion: and the Sun will seem to move among the fixed Stars or Signs, directly opposite to those in which his Planet moves; changing it’s place every day as he does. In a word, whether our observer be in motion or at rest, whether within or without the Orbits of the Planets, their motions will seem irregular, intricate and perplexed, unless he is in the center of the System; and from thence, the most beautiful order and harmony will be observed.
The Sun’s center the only point from which the true motions and places of the Planets could be seen.
135. The Sun being the center of all the Planets motions, the only place from which their motions could be truly seen, is the Sun’s center; where the observer being supposed not to turn round with the Sun (which, in this case, we must imagine to be a transparent body) would see all the Stars at rest, and seemingly equidistant from him. To such an observer the Planets would appear to move among the fixed Stars, in a simple, regular, and uniform manner; only, that as in equal times they describe equal Areas, they would describe spaces somewhat unequal, because they move in elliptic Orbits § [155]. Their motions would also appear to be what they are in fact, the same way round the Heavens; in paths which cross at small Angles in different parts of the Heavens, and then separate a little from one another § [20]. So that, if the solar Astronomer should make the Path or Orbit of any one Planet a standard, and consider it as having no obliquity § [201], he would judge the paths of all the rest to be inclined to it; each Planet having one half of it’s path on one side, and the other half on the opposite side of the standard Path or Orbit. And if he should ever see all the Planets start from a conjunction with each other[[28]]; Mercury would move so much faster than Venus as to overtake her again (though not in the same point of the Heavens) in a quantity of time almost equal to 145 of our days and nights; or, as we commonly call them, Natural Days, which include both the days and nights: Venus would move so much faster than the Earth as to overtake it again in 585 natural days: the Earth so much faster than Mars as to overtake him again in 778 such days: Mars is much faster than Jupiter as to overtake him again in 817 such days: and Jupiter so much faster than Saturn as to overtake him again in 7236 days, all of our time.
The judgment that a solar Astronomer would probably make concerning the distances and bulks of the Planets.
136. But as our solar Astronomer could have no idea of measuring the courses of the Planets by our days, he would very probably take the period of Mercury, which is the quickest moving Planet, for a measure to compare the periods of the others by. As all the Stars would appear quiescent to him, he would never think that they had any dependance upon the Sun; but could naturally imagine that the Planets have, because they move round the Sun. And it is by no means improbable, that he would conclude those Planets whose periods are quickest to move in Orbits proportionably less than those do which make slower circuits. But being destitute of a method for finding their Parallaxes, or, more properly speaking, as they could have no Parallax to him, he could never know any thing of their real distances or magnitudes. Their relative distances he might perhaps guess at by their periods, and from thence infer something of truth concerning their relative bulks, by comparing their apparent bulks with one another. For example, Jupiter appearing bigger to him than Mars, he would conclude it to be much bigger in fact; because it appears so, and must be farther from him, on account of it’s longer period. Mercury would seem bigger than the Earth; but by comparing it’s period with the Earth’s, he would conclude that the Earth is much farther from him than Mercury, and consequently that it must be really bigger though apparently less; and so of the rest. And, as each Planet would appear somewhat bigger in one part of it’s Orbit than in the opposite, and to move quickest when it seems biggest, the observer would be at no loss to determine that all the Planets move in Orbits of which the Sun is not precisely in the center.
The Planetary motions very irregular as seen from the Earth.
[PLATE III].
137. The apparent magnitudes of the Planets continually change as seen from the Earth, which demonstrates that they approach nearer to it, and recede farther from it by turns. From these Phenomena, and their apparent motions among the Stars, they seem to describe looped curves which never return into themselves, Venus’s path excepted. And if we were to trace out all their apparent paths, and put the figures of them together in one diagram, they would appear so anomalous and confused, that no man in his senses could believe them to be representations of their real paths; but would immediately conclude, that such apparent irregularities must be owing to some Optic illusions. And after a good deal of enquiry, he might perhaps be at a loss to find out the true cause of these inequalities; especially if he were one of those who would rather, with the greatest justice, charge frail man with ignorance, than the Almighty with being the author of such confusion.
Those of Mercury and Venus represented.
Fig. I.
138. Dr. Long, in his first volume of Astronomy, has given us figures of the apparent paths of all the Planets separately from Cassini; and on seeing them I first thought of attempting to trace some of them by a machine[[29]] that shews the motions of the Sun, Mercury, Venus, the Earth and Moon, according to the Copernican System. Having taken off the Sun, Mercury, and Venus, I put black-lead pencils in their places, with the points turned upward; and fixed a circular sheet of paste-board so, that the Earth kept constantly under it’s center in going round the Sun; and the paste-board kept its parallelism. Then, pressing gently with one hand upon the paste-board to make it touch the three pencils, with the other hand I turned the winch which moves the whole machinery: and as the Earth, together with the pencils in the places of Mercury and Venus, had their proper motions round the Sun’s pencil, which kept at rest in the center of the machine, all the three pencils described a diagram from which the first Figure of the third Plate is truly copied in a smaller size. As the Earth moved round the Sun, the Sun’s pencil described the dotted Circle of Months, whilst Mercury’s pencil drew the curve with the greatest number of loops, and Venus’s that with the fewest. In their inferiour conjunctions they come as much nearer the Earth, or within the Circle of the Sun’s apparent motion round the Heavens, as they go beyond it in their superiour conjunctions. On each side of the loops they appear Stationary; in that part of each loop next the Earth retrograde; and in all rest of their paths direct.