EXTINCTION OF TUBERCULOSIS IN CATTLE.
As cattle are the great propagators of tuberculosis on the farm, the question of extinction necessarily centres around this race. As in all other dangerous infections, the most prompt and successful method would be in the time honored one of destroying the infected and thoroughly disinfecting all their products. The only barrier to success in such a case would be the conveyance of infection anew from man to cattle after the herd had been purified. The demonstration that cattle are less susceptible to infection by the human sputa than many had supposed does away largely with this objection, as in a generally purified bovine race, the few primary cases contracted from man could be easily taken care of. Then, if tuberculous persons were interdicted from attendance on cattle, the danger in this direction would become very nearly a negligible quantity.
There remains the question of expense and many honestly consider this as absolutely prohibitory. The estimate of 5 per cent. of our 68,000,000 head to be killed and paid for at $25 per head, would be $85,000,000. But there is no necessity for this. Our fat steers at the packing houses are tuberculous only to the extent of 0.02 per cent., speaking well for their dams and nurses. The estimate of 5 per cent., based upon the testing of those few herds that have been taken because they were already known to be tuberculous, is unquestionably far above the actual ratio for the United States. It may apply to dairy cattle in some infected districts, but, for the bovine race of the whole country, it is absurdly high. If we had 10, 20 or 50 per cent. infected, as in some countries of Europe, the objection of expense might be a formidable one, but when the ratio of the infected is but 2:10000, we have every encouragement on the score of expense to enter on a campaign of extinction. But again, we do not need to deal with 68,000,000 cattle as we can omit the steers which are so little affected and which will all come to the slaughter house in two or three years. The source of their infection (a few cases excepted) is in the older cows and bulls of the dairy and breeding herds, and this brings down our total to a little over 17,000,000. The average census price for dairy cows is $29 and, as the condemned cows are depreciated by their condition, it would be a high average to estimate them at $20. Again, the average infected ratio of cows for the entire country would be set high at 2 per cent., and on this basis it might well be that the required indemnity would not aggregate much over $6,000,000. Five or even ten times that amount would be a mere trifle in comparison with the $3,000,000,000 value, constantly encreasing, of our domestic animals, with the $99,210,272, representing our yearly product of beef and beef products, with our annual dairy products, worth $500,000,000, (Alford), or with our yearly loss of 100,000 of our population in the very prime of life when they are of the greatest value to the country, representing a yearly drain of $100,000,000, beside all the suffering and loss entailed by their prolonged and too often helpless idleness. Though this last item is doomed to continue for a length of time after the disease has been extinguished in our herds, it is receiving constant accessions from the latter, and can never be entirely done away with until our cattle are above suspicion.
An even more serious problem is the demand for tuberculin and above all for accomplished, experienced and honorable veterinarians fitted to conduct the sanitary campaign over the entire country. The tuberculin cannot be produced in a week or a month, yet the problem of its production in any required amount in a few months is merely one of the encrease of existing plants under the management of the same careful hands now engaged upon it. As to veterinarians it would be impossible to secure at once the required staff of men capable of carrying out the work over the whole country. But this is not essential. The work can be begun in the counties supplying the large cities with milk, and in the great butter and cheese producing areas where it is so urgently needed, and it must be made to include all thoroughbred herds, which are so constantly drawn upon to improve the blood elsewhere, and each herd, county and district, as freed from infection must be scheduled and no additions made to it from outside, except under the guarantee of the tuberculin test, repeated in six months. The reacting animals, must be appraised, excluded from the herd, and disposed of, it may be to the butcher to be killed under official expert inspection, and the salvage, if any, to be deducted from the appraised value; or to be rendered and the salvage estimated; or to be buried as the case may be. In all such cases the other animals (horses, pigs) that occupy the same buildings and yards should be tested, although the risk of the infection of cattle from these animals is comparatively small. Unless in badly infected herds, steers and young cattle, which can be kept in a separate herd need not be tested. Vermin must be killed. Thorough disinfection must be applied to buildings and yards, and the dairy herd must be retested at the end of every six months until no more reactions are met with.
In this way the campaign in any State can be begun with a small staff, which may be steadily encreased as men are trained to the work, and in no great length of time the dairying and breeding herds can be purified and the investigation carried into the more purely agricultural fields, where herds are small and usually free from infection. Many minor points would require the attention of a competent superintendent of the work. My object here is to make a plea for the approved and attested method which has never failed in the case of other animal infections on enclosed farms, and which is based on the absolute destruction of every seed of the disease in the area under sanitary control. The method has the apparent drawback, that it demands a greater relative outlay at the start, than do others proposed, but in view of its certainty, and the confident hope of an early abolition of all infection, loss, and expensive expert control, it must, in my opinion, be looked upon here, as it has always proved in the past, the course of the truest economy. It may be compared to the treatment of a field of thistles by removing the offensive weeds, root and branch, before they have advanced to seed, instead of merely cutting them down with a mower, and leaving the roots, to grow anew, to leaf, to blossom and seed, in spite of the temporary partial drawback. But as the prospect of early legislation along this line is not a bright one, the expert must accommodate his aims and efforts to what can be done under the existing laws.
Breeding Healthy Stock from Parents with Latent Tuberculosis. When a State is not pledged to exterminate tuberculosis by prompt and radical measures, it is quite possible to raise healthy stock from sires and dams that have the disease in a latent form. It is very exceptional that calves are born tuberculous. If, then, they are kept in a pure environment and furnished with the milk of sound nurses, or even with the milk of their own tuberculous dams, after it has been heated for one-quarter of an hour to 180° F. or 212° F. they can be preserved in perfect health.
This is especially adapted to herds of valuable thoroughbreds, the destruction of which would be a serious loss, and the preservation of the strain of blood a most desirable object.
The whole herd should be tested with tuberculin, and the advanced and generalized cases, that can be detected by objective symptoms, should be at once destroyed and safely disposed of. The animals in good condition and that have not reacted should be placed in a new barn and yard, or where no tubercle has been, or in places that have been thoroughly disinfected, under special attendants. There will remain the animals in good condition with no objective symptom, but that have reacted, and these are placed in separate barn, yard and pasture well away from other stock, under their own attendants, for breeding purposes. They should have the best of food and air, clean, well lighted, roomy buildings with shelter from storms, clean sheltered yards, and in summer, pasturage. Any cow showing indication of active advance or generalization of the disease (cough, wheezing, dyspnœa under exertion, excessive pallor of mucosæ, unthriftiness) should be at once separated and destroyed as endangering the reinfection of others, and the stable subjected to disinfection. The calf, as soon as born, must be removed to a special building or park, where it shall get milk from a sound cow or that of its own dam after it has been carefully sterilized. After sterilization the milk cannot safely be returned to the unscalded pail into which it was drawn from the cow, and it should be fed by separate attendants who have not milked nor handled the affected animal. Any loss of condition, unthriftiness, cough or scouring on the part of any of the calves should be the signal for its separation from its fellows, subjection to the tuberculin test, and, if it reacts, for its destruction and the disinfection of the building where it was. It is well to test each calf at six weeks old and to remove the reacting ones. The success of this method is now well established.
Goodman, of Dorpat, applied it largely as early as 1891, rearing the healthy calves of reacting cows on the milk of cows that had stood the test. Bang, of Denmark, raised such calves to sound maturity on sterilized milk. Reynolds, of Minnesota, reports the raising of twenty-four healthy calves from infected cows on the milk of tested cows, while three fed on milk of reacting cows, which was supposed to be sterilized, all became tuberculous. McEachran (1899) in an extended experiment succeeded perfectly with the milk of tested cows only. I have now in hand a Jersey herd in which the progeny, fed on the milk of their reacting dams, became tuberculous without exception, and in the years following, those fed on the milk of the same reacting cows after it had been kept at 180° F. for half an hour all grew up healthy.
Under this method, inasmuch as the infection is not at once extinguished, but temporized with for the benefit of the stock owner, State indemnities are not necessarily called for. Yet the State can profitably test the cattle at public expense, mark indelibly those that react, schedule them and control them, so that they will not be allowed to change hands nor to mingle with sound animals until finally butchered, dead or recovered. The State should see to the thoroughness of the seclusion, disinfection, the safe disposal of all products from milk to manure, and the testing at intervals of three or six months of both cows and calves.