Careless reading of Ramsey has led astray a large number of people with regard to the minister referred to in 49. Speaking of the expedition of Col. Christian for the relief of the Watauga settlers in 1772, Ramsey says: “The Rev. Charles Cummings accompanied the expedition as chaplain, and was thus the first Christian minister that ever preached in Tennessee.” Granted—but while this is doubtless true, the question is not who “first preached in Tennessee,” but who first “preached regularly to a Tennessee congregation,” and that this was Tidence Lane, in 1779, is clearly demonstrated elsewhere by Ramsey. Goodspeed, indeed, using Ramsey’s facts, but changing his language, asserts in terms that Cummings had charge of a congregation “within the limits of the state”; but Goodspeed is in error in this, as he is in very many other statements. In Park’s “Historical Discourse,” a work which is the result of the most careful and painstaking original research, the statement is explicitly made that the congregation to which Goodspeed refers as having enjoyed the ministrations of Cummings “in the Holston valley as early as 1772,” was really not located in Tennessee at all. It was “in Virginia, near the site of the present town of Abingdon.” Dr. Park, himself a Presbyterian, would not be likely to fail to claim for a minister of his own denomination any credit justly due him.

In order to be absolutely frank, I desire to correct an error—the only one, I believe, in the “Dream,” and one fortunately of little moment. The man who “founded the first academy for females in Tennessee” (52) was not a classmate of Daniel Webster, as stated; although the misstatement was made on what I considered good authority.

R. L. C. White.

INDEX.

Transcriber’s note

Minor punctuation and formatting errors have been changed without notice; otherwise spelling and punctuation has been retained as published. The following Printer errors have been changed.

CHANGEDFROMTO
[Table of Contents]“136”“137”
Page [13]:“holsters and saddlebags”“holsters and saddle-bags”
Page [16]:“came from the battlefield”“came from the battle-field”
Page [35]:“which covered the same terriritory”“which covered the same territory”
Page [42]:“I am satisified”“I am satisfied”
Page [42]:“they simply put in prison”“they simply put him in prison”
Page [65:]“John McNab”“John McNabb”
Page [67:]“John McNab”“John McNabb”
Page [80]:“True philanthrophy liberates”“True philanthropy liberates”
Page [102]:“his was the ecstacy”“his was the ecstasy”
Page [107]:“and old man of sixty”“an old man of sixty”
Page [108:]“words adquate to express”“words adequate to express”
Page [146]:“foregoing names, lattitude”“foregoing names, latitude”

The Index references several entries that are footnotes. Since the footnotes have been moved to the end of the chapters in this version, the footnotes are not on the page listed. However, the link will take you to the correct footnote.

All other inconsistencies are as in the original.