[143]Jennings Bramly Bey, the Senior Inspector of Berber Province, who has kindly favoured me with some useful criticisms of this chapter, remarks: “My experience up to date is that each principal man has a different idea of his own boundaries and that those ideas differ from day to day. My impression is that the Bisharin are as yet one big family, and that the grazing is ample for all so that the boundaries are very vague between the different tribes. Disputes of course do arise as to the possession of wadis, but I find that a week after a certain wadi has been allotted to one of two tribes, both tribes are amicably grazing in it side by side without payment. The ownership of wells is more strictly defined.”
[144]Bir Shenshef and Bir Beida are in fact classed as belonging to the Hamedorab in a MS. list of wells drawn up by Bramly Bey. But he has doubtless so classed them before their true locality was known; as they lie well to the north of the Sudan administrative boundary (Shenshef is over one hundred kilometres from the nearest point of that boundary, on the Egyptian side) the Hamedorab claim can hardly be maintained.
[145]This water source is recorded in Bramly Bey’s MS. list of wells as Hamedorab property.
[146]Mr. Bramly (Anglo-Egyptian Sudan, Vol. I, p. 92), classes Bir Mashushenai as Koatil. I am, however, informed that there are two wells of this same name, and this classification probably refers to another well than the one mentioned above.
[147]The Arrêté of 1912 ascribes these two wells to the Ashab, a tribe of whom I heard nothing when in the neighbourhood; Bramly Bey informs me that they are a sub-tribe of the Hamedorab.
[148]Joint Hamedorab-Kurbeilab.
[149]Bramly Bey, in his MS. list of wells already referred to, classes Bir Odis and Bir Kadot (probably the same as my Kagog) as Hamedorab. But they were not so claimed by the Hamedorab sheikh who accompanied me, and lie well outside the Hamedorab boundary as claimed by that sheikh.
[150]Bramly Bey informs me that the ownership of Bir Um Bishtit is disputed between the Kurbeilab and Koatil, but the wadi of the same name appears to be undisputed Kurbeilab ground.
[151]I have included these two water sources (Bir Meisah and Megwel Didaut) in the Kurbeilab list, because they lie within the boundary claimed for the Kurbeilab by the sheikh who accompanied me; but according to Mr. Bramly (Anglo-Egyptian Sudan, Vol. I, p. 92) they belong to the Mohammad Omerab.