Acknowledgments are due to Mr. Winsor for his cordial permission to make use of a number of reproductions of old maps and facsimiles already used by him in the "Narrative and Critical History of America;" they are mentioned in the lists of illustrations. I have also to thank Dr. Brinton for allowing me to reproduce a page of old Mexican music, and the Hakluyt Society for permission to use the Zeno and Catalan maps and the view of Kakortok church. Dr. Fewkes has very kindly favoured me with a sight of proof-sheets of some recent monographs by Bandelier. And for courteous assistance at various libraries I have most particularly to thank Mr. Kiernan of Harvard University, Mr. Appleton Griffin of the Boston Public Library, and Mr. Uhler of the Peabody Institute in Baltimore.
There is one thing which I feel obliged, though with extreme hesitation and reluctance, to say to my readers in this place, because the time has come when something ought to be said, and there seems to be no other place available for saying it. For many years letters—often in a high degree interesting and pleasant to receive—have been coming to me from persons with whom I am not acquainted, and I have always done my best to answer them. It is a long time since such letters came to form the larger part of a voluminous mass of correspondence. The physical fact has assumed dimensions with which it is no longer possible to cope. If I were to answer all the letters which arrive by every mail, I should never be able to do another day's work. It is becoming impossible even to read them all; and there is scarcely time for giving due attention to one in ten. Kind friends and readers will thus understand that if their queries seem to be neglected, it is by no means from any want of good will, but simply from the lamentable fact that the day contains only four-and-twenty hours.
Cambridge, October 25, 1891.
CONTENTS.
CHAPTER I.
ANCIENT AMERICA.
- page
- The American aborigines [1]
- Question as to their origin [2], [3]
- Antiquity of man in America [4]
- Shell-mounds, or middens [4], [5]
- The Glacial Period [6], [7]
- Discoveries in the Trenton gravel [8]
- Discoveries in Ohio, Indiana, and Minnesota [9]
- Mr. Cresson's discovery at Claymont, Delaware [10]
- The Calaveras skull [11]
- Pleistocene men and mammals [12], [13]
- Elevation and subsidence [13], [14]
- Waves of migration [15]
- The Cave men of Europe in the Glacial Period [16]
- The Eskimos are probably a remnant of the Cave men [17]-19
- There was probably no connection or intercourse by water between ancient America and the Old World [20]
- There is one great American red race [21]
- Different senses in which the word "race" is used [21]-23
- No necessary connection between differences in culture and differences in race [23]
- Mr. Lewis Morgan's classification of grades of culture [24]-32
- Distinction between Savagery and Barbarism [25]
- Origin of pottery [25]
- Lower, middle, and upper status of savagery [26]
- Lower status of barbarism; it ended differently in the two hemispheres; in ancient America there was no pastoral stage of development [27]
- Importance of Indian corn [28]
- Tillage with irrigation [29]
- Use of adobe-brick and stone in building [29]
- Middle status of barbarism [29], [30]
- Stone and copper tools [30]
- Working of metals; smelting of iron [30]
- Upper status of barbarism [31]
- The alphabet and the beginnings of civilization [32]
- So-called "civilizations" of Mexico and Peru [33], [34]
- Loose use of the words "savagery" and "civilization" [35]
- Value and importance of the term "barbarism" [35], [36]
- The status of barbarism is most completely exemplified in ancient America [36], [37]
- Survival of bygone epochs of culture; work of the Bureau of Ethnology [37], [38]
- Tribal society and multiplicity of languages in aboriginal America [38], [39]
- Tribes in the upper status of savagery; Athabaskans, Apaches, Shoshones, etc. [39]
- Tribes in the lower status of barbarism; the Dakota group or family [40]
- The Minnitarees and Mandans [41]
- The Pawnee and Arickaree group [42]
- The Maskoki group [42]
- The Algonquin group [43]
- The Huron-Iroquois group [44]
- The Five Nations [45]-47
- Distinction between horticulture and field agriculture [48]
- Perpetual intertribal warfare, with torture and cannibalism [49]-51
- Myths and folk-lore [51]
- Ancient law [52], [53]
- The patriarchal family not primitive [53]
- "Mother-right" [54]
- Primitive marriage [55]
- The system of reckoning kinship through females only [56]
- Original reason for the system [57]
- The primeval human horde [58], [59]
- Earliest family-group; the clan [60]
- "Exogamy" [60]
- Phratry and tribe [61]
- Effect of pastoral life upon property and upon the family [61]-63
- The exogamous clan in ancient America [64]
- Intimate connection of aboriginal architecture with social life [65]
- The long houses of the Iroquois [66], [67]
- Summary divorce [68]
- Hospitality [68]
- Structure of the clan [69], [70]
- Origin and structure of the phratry [70], [71]
- Structure of the tribe [72]
- Cross-relationships between clans and tribes; the Iroquois Confederacy [72]-74
- Structure of the confederacy [75], [76]
- The "Long House" [76]
- Symmetrical development of institutions in ancient America [77], [78]
- Circular houses of the Mandans [79]-81
- The Indians of the pueblos, in the middle status of barbarism [82], [83]
- Horticulture with irrigation, and architecture with adobe [83], [84]
- Possible origin of adobe architecture [84], [85]
- Mr. Cushing's sojourn at Zuñi [86]
- Typical structure of the pueblo [86]-88
- Pueblo society [89]
- Wonderful ancient pueblos in the Chaco valley [90]-92
- The Moqui pueblos [93]
- The cliff-dwellings [93]
- Pueblo of Zuñi [93], [94]
- Pueblo of Tlascala [94]-96
- The ancient city of Mexico was a great composite pueblo [97]
- The Spanish discoverers could not be expected to understand the state of society which they found there [97], [98]
- Contrast between feudalism and gentilism [98]
- Change from gentile society to political society in Greece and Rome [99], [100]
- First suspicions as to the erroneousness of the Spanish accounts [101]
- Detection and explanation of the errors, by Lewis Morgan [102]
- Adolf Bandelier's researches [103]
- The Aztec Confederacy [104], [105]
- Aztec clans [106]
- Clan officers [107]
- Rights and duties of the clan [108]
- Aztec phratries [108]
- The tlatocan, or tribal council [109]
- The cihuacoatl, or "snake-woman" [110]
- The tlacatecuhtli, or "chief-of-men" [111]
- Evolution of kingship in Greece and Rome [112]
- Mediæval kingship [113]
- Montezuma was a "priest-commander" [114]
- Mode of succession to the office [114], [115]
- Manner of collecting tribute [116]
- Mexican roads [117]
- Aztec and Iroquois confederacies contrasted [118]
- Aztec priesthood; human sacrifices [119], [120]
- Aztec slaves [121], [122]
- The Aztec family [122], [123]
- Aztec property [124]
- Mr. Morgan's rules of criticism [125]
- He sometimes disregarded his own rules [126]
- Amusing illustrations from his remarks on "Montezuma's Dinner" [126]-128
- The reaction against uncritical and exaggerated statements was often carried too far by Mr. Morgan [128], [129]
- Great importance of the middle period of barbarism [130]
- The Mexicans compared with the Mayas [131]-133
- Maya hieroglyphic writing [132]
- Ruined cities of Central America [134]-138
- They are probably not older than the twelfth century [136]
- Recent discovery of the Chronicle of Chicxulub [138]
- Maya culture very closely related to Mexican [139]
- The "Mound-Builders" [140]-146
- The notion that they were like the Aztecs [142]
- Or, perhaps, like the Zuñis [143]
- These notions are not well sustained [144]
- The mounds were probably built by different peoples in the lower status of barbarism, by Cherokees, Shawnees, and other tribes [144], [145]
- It is not likely that there was a "race of Mound Builders" [146]
- Society in America at the time of the Discovery had reached stages similar to stages reached by eastern Mediterranean peoples fifty or sixty centuries earlier [146], [147]
CHAPTER II.
PRE-COLUMBIAN VOYAGES.
- Stories of voyages to America before Columbus; the Chinese [148]
- The Irish. [149]
- Blowing and drifting; Cousin, of Dieppe [150]
- These stories are of small value [150]
- But the case of the Northmen is quite different [151]
- The Viking exodus from Norway [151], [152]
- Founding of a colony in Iceland, A. D. 874 [153]
- Icelandic literature [154]
- Discovery of Greenland, A. D. 876 [155], [156]
- Eric the Red, and his colony in Greenland, A. D. 986 [157]-161
- Voyage of Bjarni Herjulfsson [162]
- Conversion of the Northmen to Christianity [163]
- Leif Ericsson's voyage, A. D. 1000; Helluland and Markland [164]
- Leif's winter in Vinland [165], [166]
- Voyages of Thorvald and Thorstein [167]
- Thorfinn Karlsefni, and his unsuccessful attempt to found a colony in Vinland, A. D. 1007-10 [167]-169
- Freydis, and her evil deeds in Vinland, 1011-12 [170], [171]
- Voyage into Baffin's Bay, 1135 [172]
- Description of a Viking ship discovered at Sandefiord, in Norway [173]-175
- To what extent the climate of Greenland may have changed within the last thousand years [176], [177]
- With the Northmen once in Greenland, the discovery of the American continent was inevitable [178]
- Ear-marks of truth in the Icelandic narratives [179], [180]
- Northern limit of the vine [181]
- Length of the winter day [182]
- Indian corn [182], [183]
- Winter weather in Vinland [184]
- Vinland was probably situated somewhere between Cape Breton and Point Judith [185]
- Further ear-marks of truth; savages and barbarians of the lower status were unknown to mediæval Europeans [185], [186]
- The natives of Vinland as described in the Icelandic narratives [187]-193
- Meaning of the epithet "Skrælings" [188], [189]
- Personal appearance of the Skrælings [189]
- The Skrælings of Vinland were Indians,—very likely Algonquins [190]
- The "balista" or "demon's head" [191], [192]
- The story of the "uniped" [193]
- Character of the Icelandic records; misleading associations with the word "saga" [194]
- The comparison between Leif Ericsson and Agamemnon, made by a committee of the Massachusetts Historical Society, was peculiarly unfortunate and inappropriate [194], [197]
- The story of the Trojan War, in the shape in which we find it in Greek poetry, is pure folk-lore [195]
- The Saga of Eric the Red is not folk-lore [196]
- Mythical and historical sagas [197]
- The western or Hauks-bók version of Eric the Red's Saga [198]
- The northern or Flateyar-bók version [199]
- Presumption against sources not contemporary [200]
- Hauk Erlendsson and his manuscripts [201]
- The story is not likely to have been preserved to Hauk's time by oral tradition only [202]
- Allusions to Vinland in other Icelandic documents [202]-207
- Eyrbyggja Saga [203]
- The abbot Nikulas, etc. [204]
- Ari Fródhi and his works [204]
- His significant allusion to Vinland [205]
- Other references [206]
- Differences between Hauks-bók and Flateyar-bók versions [207]
- Adam of Bremen [208]
- Importance of his testimony [209]
- His misconception of the situation of Vinland [210]
- Summary of the argument [211]-213
- Absurd speculations of zealous antiquarians [213]-215
- The Dighton inscription was made by Algonquins, and has nothing to do with the Northmen [213], [214]
- Governor Arnold's stone windmill [215]
- There is no reason for supposing that the Northmen founded a colony in Vinland [216]
- No archæological remains of them have been found south of Davis strait [217]
- If the Northmen had founded a successful colony, they would have introduced domestic cattle into the North American fauna [218]
- And such animals could not have vanished and left no trace of their existence [219], [220]
- Further fortunes of the Greenland colony [221]
- Bishop Eric's voyage in search of Vinland, 1121 [222]
- The ship from Markland, 1347 [223]
- The Greenland colony attacked by Eskimos, 1349 [224]
- Queen Margaret's monopoly, and its baneful effects [225]
- Story of the Venetian brothers, Nicolò and Antonio Zeno [226]
- Nicolò Zeno wrecked upon one of the Færoe islands [227]
- He enters the service of Henry Sinclair, Earl of the Orkneys and Caithness [228]
- Nicolò's voyage to Greenland, cir. 1394 [229]
- Voyage of Earl Sinclair and Antonio Zeno [229], [230]
- Publication of the remains of the documents by the younger Nicolò Zeno, 1558 [231]
- The Zeno map [232], 233
- Queer transformations of names [234]-236
- The name Færoislander became Frislanda [236]
- The narrative nowhere makes a claim to the "discovery of America" [237]
- The "Zichmni" of the narrative means Henry Sinclair [238]
- Bardsen's "Description of Greenland" [239]
- The monastery of St. Olaus and its hot spring [240]
- Volcanoes of the north Atlantic ridge [241]
- Fate of Gunnbjörn's Skerries, 1456 [242]
- Volcanic phenomena in Greenland [242], [243]
- Estotiland [244]
- Drogio [245]
- Inhabitants of Drogio and the countries beyond [246]
- The Fisherman's return to Frislanda [247]
- Was the account of Drogio woven into the narrative by the younger Nicolò? [248]
- Or does it represent actual experiences in North America? [249]
- The case of David Ingram, 1568 [250]
- The case of Cabeza de Vaca, 1528-36 [251]
- There may have been unrecorded instances of visits to North America [252]
- The pre-Columbian voyages made no real contributions to geographical knowledge [253]
- And were in no true sense a discovery of America [254]
- Real contact between the eastern and western hemisphere was first established by Columbus [255]