“To tell you that Herbert would not suit you as a companion,” said the witness, who thought this answer rather a clever one.

“Whom did you recommend in his place?” pursued the questioner, relentlessly.

Eben hesitated, but his cleverness came again to his aid.

“I told you that I would be willing to come just to oblige you,” he said.

“Did Herbert know that you were going to make this proposal?”

“No.”

“You asked him, then, to remain in the post office while you absented yourself with a view of depriving him of the position he had just secured in my employ?”

“I would have got father to take him again in the store and post office,” said Eben, defending himself from the implied charge of treachery.

“Yes, you told me so.”

Eben nodded triumphantly. Even Melville had to admit that he was not treating Herbert meanly.