Dante and the early astronomers

by M. A. Orr

Fig. 31. Venus, Mercury, and the sun.

Venus and Mercury betray their dependence upon the sun in more striking fashion, for since these planets simply oscillated from one side to the other of the sun, their epicycles must be supposed to be keeping pace with him all the way round the zodiac. [Fig. 31] shows their relation to one another. On September 25, 1911, Mercury was seen from Earth as a morning star as far west of the sun as it is possible for him to travel, while Venus, after shining as an evening star all the summer, had come into line with the sun and become invisible.[51] On December 7 following, the rotation of the epicycles (Ptolemy would say) had brought both planets to new positions, Mercury now being an evening star at his “greatest elongation east,” and Venus a morning star. But the centres of the two epicycles always remain in a line with one another and the sun, and so their periods on the deferents are the same as his, viz. one year. The epicyclic periods, or intervals between two “greatest elongations” west or east, are 116 days for Mercury, 584 days for Venus.

We still explain the complicated course of the planets by resolving it into two approximately circular motions, but we know now that only one belongs to the planet itself, the other is Earth’s own motion. The reason why the sun’s position affects the position of every planet is simply that the epicycles of Mars, Jupiter, and Saturn, and the deferents of Venus and Mercury are reflections of Earth’s yearly journey round the sun.

Ptolemy had by no means finished with the planets when he had provided each one with an epicycle to represent the “anomaly with regard to the sun.” Hipparchus had noticed that there was another lesser irregularity, which seemed to be periodical likewise, although no former system had taken it into account; and this he called the “anomaly with regard to the zodiac,” because the speed of each planet and the amplitude of its loop varies slightly according to the part of the zodiac it happens to be in. He suggested that this might be dealt with by combining the two theories of epicycles and eccentrics, and this suggestion Ptolemy adopted with success. He placed each deferent with its centre not exactly at the earth, but at a certain small distance which was different for each planet. (This is not shown on our small-scale diagrams, therefore Earth appears at the exact centre.) The true explanation of this irregularity is that each planet’s path is not strictly circular, but elliptical.

Besides this, Ptolemy had to represent the planet’s movements north and south (note how this varies in [fig. 28].). This was partly managed by the aid of small wheels, rotating in such a way that they lifted and lowered the epicycle as required.

Although Ptolemy quotes Babylonian observations of lunar eclipses dating back as far as the eighth century b.c., the oldest planetary observations that he uses were made only four hundred years before his time, and they were probably Greek. Even these were generally very rough. For instance:—

In the 496th year of Nabonassar, on the 17th day of Choeac, in the morning, Mercury was three moon-breadths north of the tail of Capricorn.

In the same year, Phamenoth the 30th, Mercury was three moon-breadths south of the horn of Taurus which is also the foot of the Charioteer.

The first year of Nabonassar (a Babylonian epoch) corresponds with b.c. 747, so the 496th year is b.c. 251. The months used by Ptolemy are usually Egyptian. The later observations, made with an astrolabe, were much more precise; Ptolemy quotes one from Theon of Smyrna, which states that Mercury was 3° 50′ in advance of the Heart of the Lion (Regulus), and for his own observations he also usually gives the sign, degree, and minute. Sometimes the planets had been observed so near stars that their positions could be very accurately determined by the aid of Hipparchus’ star catalogue. Timocharis, on a certain morning in the 13th year of Ptolemy Philadelphus (b.c. 273), saw Venus beside the last star in the wing of the Virgin (Beta Virginis); Ptolemy himself saw her so close behind a certain star in Aquarius that she seemed to touch it with her rays; and in the 83rd year after the death of Alexander, Jupiter had been observed to eclipse the Southern Ass, that is the southernmost of the pair of stars on either side of the little cluster in Cancer which the ancients called the Manger.