Although some of Ptolemy’s values were thus corrected by the Baghdad astronomers, no change was made in his theory of epicycles and eccentrics, which all accepted as having a concrete existence, partly because at first they did not distinguish between these and the spheres discussed by Aristotle, which he had described as formed of the same material as the planets. As Ptolemy does not explicitly state that his circles were only symbols, this is not surprising. They are formed, say the Arabs, of the fifth essence al-acir (the æther); and they conceived the epicycle as gliding over the outer surface of the deferent, like a small soap-bubble on the back of a big one. This notion, coupled with Ptolemy’s erroneous distance of the sun, misled them, as we have seen, into their imaginary discovery of planetary distances.
Tabit ben Korra 826-901.
It was also partly due to Ptolemy’s unfortunate habit of adopting the doubtful or merely provisional results of his predecessors, and representing them as well established and confirmed by himself, that they fell into another error. Tabit ben Korra, noting the discrepancy between the Greek and the Arab value of precession, investigated the question, and put forward a theory that the motion varies both in amount and direction. In his book “On the Motion of the Eighth Sphere” he describes an elaborate apparatus which he had invented to account for this variation, but he is very modest about it, and after narrating the results obtained by others, and how they had left them to be judged by posterity, he adds “And this is what we have done, with God’s blessing.” Then follow his figures and tables. This imaginary discovery was accepted by some of the Arab school, and it appears in many mediæval tables, instead of precession, under the name of the “trepidation.”
The belief in the material reality of the spheres caused the Arabs to add a ninth sphere to the eighth of Ptolemy and Alfraganus, for they thought it was enough to demand of the eighth that it should carry all the stars and give them their slow movement of precession (or trepidation). This ninth sphere, therefore, enveloped the whole universe: upon it were fixed no epicycles, no stars, no planets, but it originated the “prime motion” by turning once in a day and night, and communicating this revolution to all the inner spheres. It became known in mediæval astronomy as the Primum Mobile or first moving.
Nasir-ed-din 1201-1274.
Alfonso 1223-1284.
The Baghdad school of astronomy came to an end with Abul Wefa in 998, and the Spanish schools died out when Seville and Cordova were captured by the Christians in the thirteenth century; but the impetus given to the study of Greek astronomy and astronomical observation was carried on by other nations. In Persia a fine observatory was founded by Nasir-ed-din; in Spain the Christian king, Alfonso X, ordered tables to be drawn up to replace those of Arzachel, and the Libros de Saber to be compiled. The movement in Persia was short-lived, but in Europe the revival of astronomy had begun.