"'Because he was supposed to know more of the business than any of us, being as it was him that took the order for the dinner. But me and Eliza Jane, the under-chambermaid, was in the hall at the very moment when the two gentlemen came in.'
"'You saw them both, then?'
"'Yes, sir, as plain as I now see you. And you might have knocked me down with a feather when I was told afterwards that the one who was murdered was nothing more than a valet.'
"'You're not getting on very fast with your letters,' said Mr. Carter, looking over his shoulder at me.
"'I had written nothing yet, and I understood this as a hint to begin. I wrote down the waiter's last remark.
"'Why were you so surprised to find he was a valet?' Mr. Carter asked of the waiter.
"'Because, you see, sir, he had the look of a gentleman,' the man answered; 'an out-and-out gentleman. It wasn't that he held his head higher than Mr. Dunbar, or that he was better dressed—for Mr. Dunbar's clothes looked the newest and best; but he had a kind of languid don't-careish way that seems to be peculiar to first-class gentlemen.'
"'What sort of a looking man was he?'
"'Paler than Mr. Dunbar, and thinner built, and fairer.'
"I jotted down the waiter's remarks; but I could not help thinking that this talk about the murdered man's manner and appearance was about as useless as anything could be.