St. John proceeds:—

"THE WORD WAS WITH GOD."

In Justin we read:—

"This Offspring, which was truly brought forth from the Father, was with the Father before all the creatures, and the Father communed with Him." (Dial. ch. lxii.)

Again, a little before, in the same chapter:—

"From which we can indisputably learn that God conversed with some
One who was numerically distinct from Himself."

Again:—

"The Word, Who also was with Him." (Apol. ii. ch. vi.)

Again, Trypho says:—

"You maintain Him to be pre-existent God." (Ch. lxxxvii.)