[232] Journal, Vol. I, p. 67; Lockhart, Vol. IV, p. 401.
[233] Allan Cunningham's Life of Scott, p. 96.
[234] Lockhart, Vol. I, p. 483.
[235] See the satirical paragraph in his review of Gertrude of Wyoming, on the habits of reviewers in general. "We are perfectly aware," he says, "that, according to the modern canons of criticism, the Reviewer is expected to show his immense superiority to the author reviewed, and at the same time to relieve the tediousness of narration, by turning the epic, dramatic, moral story before him into quaint and lively burlesque." (Quarterly, May, 1809.) In his review of the Life and Works of John Home he speaks of "the hackneyed rules of criticism, which, having crushed a hundred poets, will never, it may be prophesied, create, or assist in creating, a single one." (Quarterly, June, 1827.)
[236] Lockhart, Vol. I, p. 363.
[237] Lockhart, Vol. I, p. 501. For a further comparison of Scott and Jeffrey as critics see below, pp. 134-5.
[238] Lockhart, Vol. II, p. 204.
[239] Ibid., Vol. V, p. 97.
[240] Journal, Vol. II, p. 262
[241] Ibid., Vol. I, p. 173