In April, 1883, a bill in equity was filed in the United

States Circuit Court in Boston, to restrain, by decree and

order of the Court, the unlawful publishing and use of an

infringing pamphlet printed and issued by a student of [30]

Christian Science.

Answer was filed by the defendant, alleging that the

copyrighted works of Mrs. Eddy were not original with [1]

her, but had been copied by her, or by her direction,

from manuscripts originally composed by Dr. P. P.

Quimby.