which “vanished quite slowly, beginning with the end [20]

of the tail, and ending with the grin, which remained

some time after the rest of it had gone.” Was this a witty

or a happy hit at idealism, to illustrate the author's fol-

lowing point?—

“When philosophy becomes fairy-land, in which neither [25]

laws of nature nor the laws of reason hold good, the

attempt of phenomenism to conceive the universe as a

phenomenon without a noumenon may succeed, but not

before; for it is an attempt to conceive a grin without