“Once in a very great while. There was one gentleman who came occasionally that I liked very much. He was tall and dark-complexioned, with a pair of excruciating side whiskers.”

The detective smiled to himself, as he recognized in this description Mr. Barnes.

“But he was not the only one?”

“No, there was another, and a very nice man he seemed to be. He never came as much as the first one I spoke about.”

“Can you describe him?”

“Yes. A tallish man, too, rather chunkily built, with a mustache and a goatee.”

That suited Demas Lorton, all but the goatee. This, however, might very easily have been false.

Returning to the charge, the detective inquired:

“Did Miss Doane often go out in the evening?”

“Seldom or never.”