A Treatise on Fractures, Luxations, and Other Affections of the Bones

by P.-J. Desault

Case VIII. In the Journal of Surgery are recorded two cases, one by Anthaume, the other by Faucheron, which establish this doctrine.

John Seligni, a robust man, forty-four years of age, fell on the point of his shoulder, on the 19th of July 1791; the pain, which was increased by moving his arm, and the swelling which supervened almost immediately, induced him to enter the Hotel-Dieu. The efforts of assistants were at first insufficient, and it was not till after a uniform extension continued for several minutes, that the head of the humerus was drawn by the muscles against the glenoid cavity. The bone appeared to enter the cavity, although the persons present did not hear the collision or clashing of the articulating surfaces, which is almost always perceived in cases of recent luxation: but immediately the humerus was again displaced, without its being practicable to retain it. On the occurrence of this phenomenon, Desault conceived that the head of the bone had pushed before it the capsular ligament, through which it could not pass, in consequence of the narrowness of the opening which had been made at the time of the luxation. He proceeded to move the arm forcibly in every direction, in order to enlarge the opening, and immediately felt a kind of laceration, which satisfied him that his views were accomplished. He then re-commenced extension, which it was again necessary to continue, as at first, for some time, in order to overcome the resistance of the muscles. The reduction was attended with no further difficulty. The humerus continued still to have a great tendency to be displaced, and it was necessary to employ, for several days, a bandage similar to that for a fractured clavicle.

Case IX. Maria Laurencier, aged sixty, fell on her right elbow, and luxated the humerus of the same side. Eight hours afterwards she came to the Hotel-Dieu, on the eighth of March, 1789. The reduction was attempted in the usual manner; but, although the extensions were properly directed, and the head of the humerus brought against the glenoid cavity, it was still displaced again as soon as the limb was let go, a circumstance which created a suspicion, that the opening of the capsule was too narrow to allow the head of the bone to pass. The assistants ceased making extension, and Desault, taking hold of the lower extremity of the arm, impressed on it great motion, particularly in the direction of the luxation, for the purpose of enlarging the laceration of the capsule. The extensions were now renewed, and the reduction succeeded with great ease.

67. A second obstacle, more difficult to be surmounted in the process of reduction, is that arising from the long continuance of the luxation. The head of the bone, having continued for a long time in the bed into which it has been accidentally thrown, forms adhesions to it; the surrounding cellular membrane becomes thickened, and makes, so to speak, a new capsule for the head, which opposes its replacement, and, when the reduction cannot be accomplished, supplies in some measure the office of the old joint, by the movements which it allows to take place.

Most writers, and Bell in particular, advise, in such a case, never to attempt a reduction, which, being of no avail as to the luxation, might prove dangerous to the patient, in consequence of the violence it would do to the parts. This doctrine was for a time, the doctrine of Desault: but experience, in his latter years, led him to a bolder practice.

68. The complete success which he experienced in luxations of fifteen or twenty day’s standing, encouraged him to make the attempt, at the end of thirty and thirty-five days, and we have, three or four times, during the two last years of his life, seen him successful in replacing, after the expiration of two and a half, and even three months, the head of the bone which had escaped, both through the inferior, and the internal side of the capsule.

However powerful, and however long continued the extensions were, none of those terrible accidents occurred, with which we are threatened by authors. Twice only did a phenomenon occur, which it was difficult to foresee, and of which I will presently speak.

69. In cases of this kind, it is necessary, previously to making extension, to move the bone very forcibly in every direction, in order first to break the adhesions, to tear the condensed cellular membrane, which serves as an accidental capsule, and to produce, so to speak, a second luxation, with a view to make way for a perfect reduction of the first. The straps being then applied, as in ordinary cases, serve the purpose of extension, for the accomplishment of which the number of assistants must be increased.