Deposition of Eggs
Concerning T. ferox, Wright and Funkhouser (1915:122-23) wrote that deposition of eggs occurred in June and July in the Okefinokee Swamp on the sandy parts of the islands or in sandy fields in places exposed to the direct rays of the sun. The same authors recorded a gravid female taken on June 22 (op. cit.:120), and a nest with eggs on June 26. Harper (1926:415) reported egg-laying in June in the Okefinokee Swamp. Goff and Goff (1935:156) found a female in search of a nesting site crawling toward a cleared area within a hammock at 11 a. m. on May 19, about 25 yards from the western shore of Lake Griffin, Florida. Carr (1940:107) stated that eggs in Florida "are laid from March to July 10. One individual laid her eggs on a block of ice which we had buried in the sand." Hamilton (1947:209) observed deposition of eggs near Fort Myers, Florida, in "a sandy roadbed slightly above the cypress swamp and ditch levels on either side of the road." … either in … "the ruts formed by cars or the slope of the roadbed"; dates of deposition of eggs recorded are March 30 at 11 a. m. in bright sun, and March 31 (from context, the date given as March 21 is considered an error) at 5 p. m. following a heavy rain. The daily temperatures at the time of Hamilton's observations "averaged 85° F., the first really warm spell of the season."
Eigenmann (1896:262) reported egg-laying of spinifer in sand and gravel in June and July at Turkey Lake (= Lake Wawasee), Indiana. A turtle was seen digging a nest on June 26, and fresh nests of eggs were found on June 27 and July 9. Hedrick and Holmes (1956:126) wrote that a clutch of eggs of spinifer in Minnesota was found about ten inches deep in sand about one foot from the river; a steep gravel bank was also cited as a favorite nesting site. Surface (1908:123) stated that eggs of spinifer in Pennsylvania are laid in May, and the young hatch in August. Gehlbach and Collette (1959:142) found eggs of spinifer on June 19 on a sand bank 15 feet from the edge of the Platte River in Nebraska. Breckenridge (1944:187) wrote that spinifer in Minnesota nests on sandy beaches from June 14 to July 6. Cahn (1937:193) stated that deposition of eggs in Illinois occurs in "June or early July: earlier in the southern part of the state, later in the northern portion." Force (1930:38) mentioned a gravid female from Oklahoma obtained on May 20. Evermann and Clark (1920:593) were of the opinion that spinifer began laying about mid-June and continued until perhaps late July at Lake Maxinkuckee, Indiana; a female opened on June 14 had oviducal eggs, and the first nest was found on June 18. Nests were usually at the edge of an abrupt ascent in sand; one nest was found in black, mucky soil (op. cit.:595). Newman (1906:128) wrote that spinifer in the same lake nests later than the other species of turtles, as a rule not earlier than the middle of June (but as early as June 10, op. cit.:132), and rarely later than the middle of July; he observed deposition of eggs on June 22. Sites of deposition of eggs were mostly in soft sand not more than six feet from water; other sites found by Newman (op. cit.:132-33) were a sandy, abandoned road bed separated from the shore by a strip of tall grass, a rock pile (the eggs being dropped into crevices and sand packed around them), among roots of a tree (the eggs being deposited between the roots and under them in a very irregular fashion), and in clay "so hard packed that one could scarcely break it with the fingers." Natural nest sites in hard clay and a rock pile seem incongruous with nesting habits of softshells. I note that Newman's study was not begun until 1902 (op. cit.:127), and it was that year that the water level of the lake was high, flooding the surrounding lowlands (Evermann and Clark, 1920:49-53). Perhaps some of the nests found by Newman were old and not natural because of conditions resulting from the receding water level.
Newman (op. cit.:134-35) mentioned that in small sandy areas nests were frequently in contact and overlapped; he found one nest containing nine small eggs contiguous with 23 large eggs. Breckenridge (1944:187) reported a nest of 56 eggs of two slightly differing sizes, and probably from two females. Evermann and Clark (1920:594) discovered "probably 10 or 12 nests in a distance of a few yards" and mentioned one nest containing 25 eggs "that evidently belonged to two different sets … In the bottom were 10 eggs that looked old … and … separated from them by sand, were 15 other eggs."
Nesting sites of muticus were mentioned by Muller (1921:181) on one of several small islands having "gently sloping sand and mud shores, and interior areas of open sand and densely growing willows" in the Mississippi River, near Fairport, Iowa. The same author wrote that the egg-laying season is from late June to early July, and that the female selected a place 10 to 60 feet inland "with an unobstructed view of the open water." Farther north on the Mississippi River near Dubuque, Iowa, Goldsmith (1945:447) found that muticus preferred "clean, somewhat level sandbars and sandy shores free from trash, weeds … and exposed to open view." The same species, however, may "make unsatisfactory nests … in any place they can find sand, even in the weeds and bushes … when the river is high, covering the sandy plots …" Sometimes nests, which were "seldom nearer than six feet or more than twenty-five feet from water …," were submerged by a rise in water level. In Missouri, Hurter (1911:251) found that individuals of muticus came "… out on the sandbars in the Mississippi River to deposit their eggs … At the end of May up to the middle of June …" Cahn (1937:182) wrote that the nesting season of muticus is early July near Meredosia, Illinois. Anderson (1958:212, Fig. 1) found nests of muticus along the Pearl River in Louisiana on an open sandbar (not in gravel, fine sand or silt), whereas nests of Graptemys were confined to the landward margin of the sandbar.
The onset and length of the breeding season seems to be geared to the climatic conditions under which the species occurs, and, as would be expected, begins earlier and lasts longer in southern latitudes than in northern latitudes. The period of deposition of eggs in T. ferox (Florida) is from late March to mid-July, whereas that of northern populations of spinifer and muticus (southern Great Lakes region) is usually from mid-June to mid-July.
Seemingly there is little difference between species in preference of nesting sites; a sandy substrate is probably preferred. Gravid females of ferox and spinifer may wander overland some distance and select places where the view of the water is obstructed by vegetation; both species may wander little and nest in full view of the water. Concerning muticus, it is of interest that of the many nests discovered by Anderson (loc. cit.) on an open sandbar, all were those of muticus and none was a nest of spinifer. The nests of muticus mentioned by Muller (loc. cit.) and Goldsmith (loc. cit.) were on open sandbars. On June 4, 1953, six clutches of eggs were found on an open sandbar of the Escambia River, Florida; all hatchlings from those eggs that were successfully incubated were muticus. On June 1, 1954, three nests were found on an open sandbar of the same river ([Pl. 50]); the temperature within the nests at 6:30 a. m. was approximately 25° C. Two nests were dug in a sand substrate on the level portion of the bar ([Pl. 51, Fig. 1]). The third clutch of eggs was deposited in a sand-gravel substrate at the brim of the incline from the shore (approximately 30 degrees and about five feet above the water); the eggs of this clutch were arranged rather symmetrically ([Pl. 51, Fig. 2]). Unfortunately, most of the eggs from these three clutches failed to hatch. Although the data are far from conclusive, I have the impression that muticus limits its sites of egg deposition to the open regions of sand bars and does not lay inland where it must traverse vegetated areas unless preferred nesting sites are submerged or otherwise unsatisfactory. Females of spinifer may utilize open sandbars for deposition of eggs but not areas where muticus occurs. In areas where both muticus and spinifer occur, the latter probably lays farther inland or on the landward margins of sandbars.
Excavation of nests has been observed in ferox (Hamilton, 1947:209), muticus (Muller, 1921:181-82; Goldsmith, 1945:448), and spinifer (Newman, 1906:132-33; Cahn, 1937:191-92; Breckenridge, 1960:284). Turtles leaving the water are cautious, usually stopping and extending the neck to its greatest length, holding the head high, and sometimes returning to the water for a short time. Depending on the condition of the substrate and wariness of the female, nest construction may begin immediately, or several holes may be dug and then abandoned. The excavation on level ground or a slight incline is made by means of the hind feet (Muller mentions digging with the forefeet; I agree with Pope, 1949:321, and Conant, 1951:264, who consider Muller in error); the forefeet are firmly planted and not moved during the excavation, deposition of eggs or the filling of the nest cavity. The hind feet are used alternately; cloacal water may be used to facilitate digging or to provide a suitable substrate for the eggs. Cahn mentioned that some sand may be flung four or five feet, and that during the digging the head is held high. Breckenridge (loc. cit.) reported that sand was thrown a distance of ten feet. The nest may be completed in 16 minutes (Cahn, loc. cit.) or less than 40 minutes (Newman, loc. cit.). Breckenridge recorded 17 eggs laid in six minutes, Cahn recorded 12 eggs laid in eight minutes, and Hamilton recorded four eggs laid in three minutes. The hind feet are used to arrange the eggs and are used alternately to fill the nest cavity; sometimes a little sand is scraped in before all the eggs are deposited. Muller recorded the nest cavity as five inches in diameter and ten inches deep, the finished nest appearing "as a small crater … about a foot in diameter, or where the surface is covered with pebbles, as a circular area of clear sand." Goldsmith reported that the nest cavity was six to nine inches in depth, and that after deposition and filling with sand "By certain twisting movements with all four legs, she drags the plastron around over the sand, making a perfect camouflage." Newman found the nest flask-shaped having a depth of about six inches, and diameters of about three inches at the bottom and one and one-half inches in the neck. Hamilton described a flask-shaped nest, the entrance of which would "barely permit the passage of an egg … the bottom, at a depth of five inches, being about the width of a quart milk bottle." Cahn related that the "hole descended at an angle of about 60°," and the eggs thus rolled down an inclined plane.
Possibly the nests of ferox and spinifer differ from those of muticus in being flask-shaped. A nest of spinifer was reported by Gehlbach and Collette (loc. cit.) as having a neck three inches across, a depth of six inches and a width of five inches at the bottom. The nests of muticus that I discovered on the Escambia River were not flask-shaped; the eggs were five to seven inches below the surface. Evermann and Clark (1920:594) reported eggs of spinifer "generally at a depth of four to ten inches," and Breckenridge (loc. cit.) found the topmost eggs about five inches below the surface. There may be behavioral differences between ferox and spinifer and muticus. Hamilton (loc. cit.) mentioned that ferox proceeded with its reproductive duties even when he stood only a few yards away. Muller (op. cit.:181) found that muticus would run to the water if disturbed, without completing deposition of eggs; the same behavior was described by Cahn (op. cit.:191) for spinifer. Newman (1906:133) wrote that spinifer will abandon nesting activities if surprised before egg deposition begins, but will wait to cover the eggs if interrupted while laying eggs. Goldsmith (1945:448) found that an observer did not disturb females of muticus when they were laying eggs (females "could be approached and even touched"), but that, in the presence of an observer, they would scurry toward the water without covering the eggs and would not return to cover them. Turtles frightened in the process of the construction of the nests would not return to complete the original nest. Harper (1926:415) wrote that ferox, after completing nesting activities, will crawl a few feet from the nest and scuffle up the surface, presumably to decoy predators that might otherwise destroy the eggs; this observation has not been corroborated by other authors. Harper (op. cit.:416) recorded the observation of Allen Chesser, who says that females, after egg deposition, often "… bury themselves, before they go ter the water, an' stay there ten er twelve hours."
Reproductive Potential