- T. Wm. Barcroft
- W. B. Bowman
- Jacob Brooks
- Carter Burton
- George B. Ives
- Job Hawxhurst
- Courtland Lukens
- Samuel Pullman
- E. W. Wakefield
- Geo. F. W. Walters
1870–1874
- Richard H. Cockerille
1874–1885
- James Sangster
1886–1899
- D. M. Chichester
1897–1903
- James M. Love