It is to be remarked that Tilden's vote was larger than any of the State or local candidates', and was vastly larger than had ever been cast for any other man.
| The vote for Grant in 1872 in New York State was | 440,745 |
| Tilden's vote larger than Grant's vote in 1872, when the latter carried the State by 53,466 | 81,298 |
| Tilden's vote in 1876 larger than Greeley's vote in 1872 | 134,764 |
| Grant's vote in 1868 was | 419,883 |
| Tilden's vote in 1876 larger than Grant's vote in 1868 | 102,160 |
| Seymour's vote in 1868 was | 429,883 |
| Tilden's vote in 1876 larger than Seymour's in 1868 | 92,160 |
| The total vote for Tilden in the United States in 1876 was | 4,300,316 |
| For Hayes | 4,036,015 |
| Tilden's majority | 264,301 |
| Grant's vote in 1872 was | 3,596,742 |
| Tilden's vote larger than Grant's vote, in 1872, when the latter's majority was 761,844 | 703,574 |
| Greeley's vote in 1872 was | 2,834,888 |
| Tilden's vote in 1876 larger than Greeley's in 1872 | 1,465,418 |
| Grant's vote in 1872 was | 3,013,188 |
| Tilden's vote in 1876 larger than Grant's | 1,287,128 |
| Seymour's vote in 1868 was | 2,703,600 |
| Tilden's vote in 1876 larger than Seymour's in 1868 | 1,596,716 |
JUST WHAT CHANDLER DID, AND HOW THE PLAN WAS LAID TO DEFEAT THE POPULAR CHOICE FOR PRESIDENT
[From the New York "Times" of June 15, 1887.]
"The New York Sun, after three days of hard labor, has finally produced a curious reply to the Times's comments upon Mr. William E. Chandler's connection with the election of 1876. The best answer to its series of misrepresentations will be found in the following statement of what did actually occur at the Fifth Avenue Hotel on the morning of Nov. 8 of that year.
"As stated on Saturday last in the Times, a gentleman entered the Fifth Avenue Hotel at the Twenty-third Street door about 6.30 o'clock in the morning, possibly a little before that hour. He went at once to the rooms of the national committee and found them occupied only by a number of servants in the hotel, who were engaged in cleaning and setting the rooms to rights. He was informed that everybody had gone home or to bed a couple of hours before. He left the room and started for the clerk's desk to ascertain the number of Mr. Zachariah Chandler's room. While opening the first door in the direction of the reading-room, on his way to the office of the hotel, he came in collision with a small man, wearing an immense pair of goggles, his hat drawn down over his ears, a great-coat with a heavy military coat, and carrying a grip-sack and a newspaper in his hand. The newspaper was the New York Tribune. The gentleman did not recognize the stranger, but the stranger recognized the gentleman immediately. The stranger cried out: 'Why, Mr. Blank, is that you?' The gentleman knew the voice, and said: 'Is that you, Mr. Chandler?' He answered: 'Yes, I have just arrived from New Hampshire by train. D—n the men who brought this disaster upon the Republican party.' The gentleman replied: 'The Republican party has sustained no disaster. If you will only keep your heads up here, there is no question of the election of President Hayes. He has been fairly and honestly elected.'
"Chandler replied: 'Look at this paper.' The answer was that the paper had not the news, and the gentleman began to give Mr. Chandler an idea of the situation, when Chandler interrupted him, saying: 'I have just got the key to my room; come up-stairs.' Upon entering the room, Mr. Chandler placed his grip-sack in the corner, took off his overcoat, sat down in a chair—the gentleman taking the only other one in the room—and Chandler said: 'Now go ahead.' The visitor went over the ground carefully, State by State, from Maine to Oregon, counting the electoral vote in each State, and showing the vote as it was finally counted for Hayes and Tilden. After he had finished, William E. Chandler said: 'Well, what do you think should be done?' The gentleman replied:
"'Telegraph immediately to leading Republicans, men in authority, in South Carolina, Florida, Louisiana, California, Oregon, and Nevada.' Mr. Chandler made no direct reply to this proposition, but said:
"'We must go and see Zach.'
"The gentleman said: