Fig. 61.—Mesosaurus; restoration of skeleton.
(After McGregor)
The age of the South American proganosaurs is now believed to be lower or lowermost Permian, like that of the African Mesosaurus; possibly, however, the age first described to Stereosternum (Carboniferous) may be correct.
The known skeletons are all small, none exceeding a few feet in length. The skull, as shown in the figure by Dr. McGregor, is elongate, and its teeth are extraordinarily so, and very slender. The external nostrils are situated close to the eyes; and no sclerotic bones have been discovered. There are small teeth in the bones of the palate. The neck is elongate, composed of ten or twelve vertebrae. The trunk also is long and slender, and the tail is not only long, but also much flattened or compressed. All these are very characteristic of water life. The limbs, however, show a much less complete adaptation for swimming—not much more so in fact than do those of the living Crocodilia. The upper arm and the thigh bones are relatively long, while those of the forearm and the leg are shorter than among terrestrial reptiles, the first indication of swimming habits to appear in crawling animals. The digits are not much elongated, and they have no additional finger bones, save perhaps in a lately discovered form in Africa, in which Dr. Broom reports supernumerary bones in the fifth or “little” toe.[3] The fingers and toes have only blunt terminal bones, that is, they were not distinctly clawed, and they were probably connected with each other by a membrane, as in a frog’s foot. This webbing of the feet is probable, not only because of the positions in which the bones have been found, but also because of the great length of the “little” toe, which is the longest in the foot, a character quite abnormal for a land reptile and quite characteristic of certain aquatic mammals, like the seals and sea-otters. There is a strong sacrum of two vertebrae, however, the pelvis and hind legs being connected with the spinal column firmly, clearly proving that, like the crocodiles, the proganosaurs had by no means lost their land proclivities.
Their vertebrae, as would be expected in such old reptiles, are quite primitive in structure, that is, they are deeply concave in each end, probably being perforated for the remains of the notochord. The pelvis also is of the old-fashioned type, that is, without an opening or vacuity between the bones below. The shoulder bones are old fashioned too. The shoulder-blade, especially, shows a decided adaptation to water life in its short, fan-like shape, very much like those of the mosasaurs, ichthyosaurs, whales, etc. Just why swimming animals should have short and broad shoulder-blades has not yet been explained, but doubtless they afforded better attachment for those muscles used more especially in swimming. The ribs are remarkably flat and heavy, and were not very firmly attached to the vertebrae. Heavy ribs are unusual among free swimming animals, but do occur in the modern sirenians, which live on the bottoms of shallow bays, etc., feeding upon plants. We may perhaps infer from this peculiar structure of the ribs that the proganosaurs lived more on the bottoms of shallow waters, feeding upon such fishes or invertebrates as they could capture, coming to the surface to breathe from time to time. Possibly they sought the shores for safety from their enemies, as do the Galapagos lizards, figured on [p. 142]; and doubtless they laid and hatched their eggs on land. A character which suggests that the proganosaurs lived only in the shallow waters is the elongated neck, reminding one of those two other groups of swimming reptiles, the dolichosaur lizards and the nothosaurs of the Sauropterygia, the only known reptiles besides the plesiosaurs having an abnormal number of neck bones. Still more suggestive of shallow, fresh-water habits is the absence of eye bones, as in the modern crocodiles.
The long snout, with the long and slender teeth, and the position of the external nostrils far back near the eyes, together with the flattened and long tail and the webbed feet, are sufficient proof of expert swimming habits. The legs still functioned more or less for the support and propulsion of the body on the land, and they probably were only of slight service in the water. The alligator swims sinuously with its front legs collapsed and extended by the side of the body; its hind legs are used more as propellers, with the knee flexed and the feet turned outward and expanded. The legs of the proganosaurs doubtless were used in the same way, as shown in the restoration, which has been modified from the original of Dr. McGregor in accordance with this probable use of the legs.
There seems to be an incongruity between the posterior nostrils and the heavy flat ribs, the former suggesting free swimming and diving habits, the latter shallow water and bottom habits. Possibly the position of the nostrils has been the result of the great elongation of the face in front of the nostrils; and we know that their posterior position in the phytosaurs ([Figs. 95] and [96]) has not been due to swimming habits only.
Nothing has been discovered to indicate the nature of the external covering of the body. Possibly, even probably, the skin was more or less covered by horny scales or plates, though it may have been quite bare, as in the salamanders.
To which other reptiles the proganosaurs are nearest related has long been a subject of dispute, and still is. The more probable view, however, is that they were a very early branch of the most primitive stock of reptiles, the Cotylosauria, one that soon perished, leaving no descendants, unless possibly the ichthyosaurs were their progeny. Some writers have thought that they were the early ancestral stock of the plesiosaurs, and they are often classified with the Sauropterygia. Still others have believed that they were an early side-branch of the great group of Rhynchocephalia. And this doubt has been chiefly due to our imperfect knowledge of the bones of the cranium. As has been explained, very much stress in the classification of reptiles has been laid by students on the possession of one, two, or no openings on the side of the skull back of the eyes. And this part of the skull of the Proganosauria has not yet been satisfactorily made out. Dr. McGregor thought that there are two openings in the temporal region, allying the group with the Rhynchocephalia. Dr. Huene is more positive that there is but one, like that of the ichthyosaurs. In this state of indecision, the proganosaurs may be dignified by giving them an ordinal position by themselves.