This ebook was transcribed by Les Bowler.

THE PROBLEM OF
‘EDWIN DROOD’

A STUDY IN THE METHODS OF DICKENS
BY
W. ROBERTSON NICOLL

HODDER AND STOUGHTON
LONDON NEW YORK TORONTO

PRINTED IN 1912

TO THE RIGHT HONOURABLE
THE EARL OF ROSEBERY
K.G.

CONTENTS

PAGE

PREFACE

[ix]

INTRODUCTION

[xvii]

PART I.—THEMATERIALS FOR A SOLUTION

CHAPTER I

THE TEXT OF ‘EDWINDROOD’

[3]

CHAPTER II

EXTERNAL TESTIMONIES

[20]

NOTES FOR THE NOVEL

[56]

CHAPTER III

THE ILLUSTRATIONS ON THEWRAPPER

[69]

CHAPTER IV

THE METHODS OF DICKENS

[82]

PARTII.—ATTEMPT AT A SOLUTION

CHAPTER V

WAS EDWIN DROODMURDERED?

[109]

CHAPTER VI

WHO WAS DATCHERY?

[141]

CHAPTER VII

OTHER THEORIES

[177]

CHAPTER VIII

HOW WAS ‘EDWIN DROOD’TO END?

[184]

BIBLIOGRAPHY

[203]

PREFACE