‘Always?’

‘Well, ever since… Janie, I can’t remember again.’

‘All right.’

‘All right, all right, it isn’t all right!’ He straightened and looked at her. ‘I’m sorry, Janie. I didn’t mean to yell at you.’

She smiled at him. He said, ‘Where was that cave?’

‘Cave?’ she echoed.

He waved his arms up, around. ‘Sort of a cave. Half cave, half log house. In the woods. Where was it?’

‘Was I there with you?’

‘No,’ he said immediately. ‘That was before, I guess. I don’t remember.’

‘Don’t worry about it.’