Studies on Epidemic Influenza: Comprising Clinical and Laboratory Investigations

by University of Pittsburgh. School of Medicine

Where the inflammatory œdema was accompanied by much focal hemorrhage the distribution was nodular and suggested the appearance of the hemorrhagic lung of plague pneumonia. It was this appearance which led to the suggestion that the pandemic was not one of influenza but possibly of an infection related to the eastern plague. The nodular masses of hemorrhage at times occupied areas varying from the size of a walnut to that of a golf ball and were localized amidst a relatively mildly involved lung tissue making a sharp contrast between the involved and relatively normal tissue. With the removal of the lung from the body and the partial collapse of the aerated tissues these nodules became still more prominent. The greater the amount of hemorrhage within these areas the more solid became the occupied tissue. Such sporadic distribution of hemorrhagic lesions occurred in the two most intense and rapidly fatal cases. Both of these individuals died within 48 hours of the time of onset of the lung conditions. In these two cases we do not believe that the pulmonary lesions had been prolonged over a time even as long as 36 hours but with the difficulty of estimating the onset of the lung involvement we are giving a liberal estimate of this time.

Besides meeting with the stages of congestion, œdema and hemorrhage during the earliest days of the pulmonary lesions we have found that they are to be encountered virtually through all the stages of the fatal cases either as remnants of the original reactions which had not been entirely obliterated by the succeeding purulent process or as was so commonly found, new reactions occurred in other regions of the lung so that, in the same individual, inflammatory reactions of different stages of development could be defined. I do not recollect a single autopsy of a case dying during the acute period which did not show evidence of some areas in the stages of this early acute reaction. Naturally where resolution is well advanced within the lung all trace of inflammatory exudate of various kinds is removed and where such individuals with their resolved pneumonia are brought to death through succeeding complications the above finding will not be borne out. We limit, however, our statement to the findings in the acute deaths.

We have previously intimated that the œdema present in the early stages of the reaction is to be looked upon as an inflammatory œdema or better as a true serous exudate, and must not be confused with the transudation of fluids in non-inflammatory conditions. We have on several occasions collected the fluid expressed from the soggy lungs and have made some determinations of their chemical qualities. The difficulty immediately arises in separating the materials arising from cellular degeneration from the natural constituents of the serous exudate. We were unable to obtain specimens in which laked blood was not present, so that even though the cellular constituents and fibrin were removed, decomposition products could not be separated. The analyses, however, gave a differentiation from the transudate seen in renal and cardiac conditions.

During the period of the accumulation of this inflammatory fluid the clinician could often recognize a profuse watery exudate within the lung or even observed an abundant serous discharge arising in bronchi and trachea. At times the quantity of expectoration was great. Frothy serous fluid accumulated in the air passages and would periodically be expectorated. At other times the hemorrhage was of quite serious extent and the patient would suddenly bring up several mouthfuls or more of bright blood. This pulmonary hemorrhage was without manifestations different from the acute illness with cyanosis of other individuals. The two most acute cases, which we have referred to above, were of this kind, both of them having marked hæmoptysis with the loss of upwards of a pint of blood at a time.

The early pulmonary lesion which we have described, we have called acute serous pneumonia and acute hemorrhagic pneumonia (or we might speak of it as an acute sero-hemorrhagic pneumonia) and is one which is distinctive for epidemic influenza. The cut surface of a lobe involved in this reaction is wet, glassy, meaty and oozes much blood-stained fluid. It contains no visible fibrin and presents no characters of a “cellular consolidation.” As a serous inflammation of the lung it is unique. The further remarkable character to the pulmonary lesion is that in advancing through the other stages, it never passes through a stage of “red hepatization.” Here again we have a distinctive difference from the pneumococcus-pneumonia. From what we have previously said about the nature of this early acute inflammation of the lung in this disease it is apparent that red hepatization has no place in its process. The stage of red hepatization is attained only when the inflammatory reaction is accompanied by certain constituents in the exudate, which upon coagulation (separation out of the fibrin) renders the lobe dry and solid, while there is a sufficient abundance of red blood cells and congestion to maintain a dark red color. The hepatized lung on section is dry, more or less granular, containing fibrin, red cells and leucocytes within the alveoli. Extensive œdema is unusual except in the cases of hypostatic pneumonia, which in well marked cases bears some resemblance to the gross appearance of the early influenza pneumonia. We have not encountered a single case of the red meaty lung of influenza which showed evidence of true red hepatization in the gross.

The microscopical examination of the lung tissue confirmed the observations which were made in the gross. In the early stages of congestion the reaction was much more extensive than what could be spoken of as a broncho-pneumonia. The capillary dilatation in the alveolar walls occupied diffuse areas varying from multiple lobules and areas several cm. in size to the common diffuse congestion of an entire lobe. Capillaries were distended to their full capacity and often this engorgement was associated with the leakage of blood or a serous fluid. Not uncommonly a clear serous fluid was exuded into the interstitial tissues of the alveolar wall and collected within the air sacs. The high albuminous content of this fluid was seen in the homogeneous coagulation which occurred when the tissues were placed in fixatives. The microscopical sections of such parts demonstrated the coagulum occupying the alveoli as a clear homogeneous substance containing relatively few cells and looking not unlike the colloid deposit of the thyroid. The alveolar walls, themselves, were infiltrated with fluid so that the distended tissues and vessels made these structures thick and bulky. In our own observations we were impressed by the differences of the early inflammatory reaction from those ordinarily seen in pneumonia. Amongst these differences was the quantity of fluid extruded into the lung with a relative absence of fibrin. In some instances fibrin was completely wanting, although small quantities could be demonstrated in isolated areas. This observation upon the quantity of fibrin can be made only during the early stage of the disease in as much as after secondary infection of various kinds has become implanted the presence of fibrin has become a variable quantity often exceeding that seen in the early stages. This is one of the points upon which the older authors have laid stress in differentiating influenza pneumonia from others. In this we fully concur. Whether this lack of fibrin in the inflammatory exudate is a characteristic to be associated with the infection by the B. influenzæ alone is hard to say, but in as much as it was such a prominent finding we are led to lay some stress upon it. It is, of course, to be realized, as with all other micro-organisms that under certain conditions fibrin will form an important part of the exudate even when the B. influenzæ is present. This is true in the inflammatory reactions of the meninges present in infections due to this bacillus. Under the conditions of epidemic influenza where the lung lesion is the prominent and unique reaction this micro-organism fails by itself to bring out this quality in the exudate.

Not uncommonly this stage of inflammatory œdema was accompanied by various grades of hemorrhage, varying from the presence of small aggregations of red cells to a complete flooding of the lung tissue making it look not unlike a red infarct of lung, save that the alveolar walls still showed an active circulation and living cells. It was remarkable that even though there was such an intense reaction taking place in the lung tissue there was little or no evidence of a cellular exudate during this stage of the process. Where much blood was extruded into the alveoli occasional fibrin threads were found in the coagulum. In these early cases the bronchicles and small bronchi were found to contain an exudate similar to that in the alveoli. Not uncommonly the vessels from which the red blood was escaping, could be demonstrated in sections. The appearance of the vascular wall suggested that a definite opening had occurred in the side of the capillary from which the blood escaped. We were not able to demonstrate a fatty or other type of degeneration in the cells of the capillary walls. It is probable that the process of injury was much too acute to permit of the demonstration of the products of degeneration within the surviving cells.

The hemorrhagic lesions which had existed for a longer period of time gradually showed a varying infiltration by wandering cells. The earliest cells not belonging to those of the hemorrhage or œdema appearing within the alveoli were mononuclear elements partly arising from the alveolar walls and partly coming from the circulation. Numerous mononuclear cells of epithelial type desquamating from the inner surface of the alveoli accumulated in the œdematous fluid and the hemorrhage within a short time after their occurrence. These cells either appeared in clusters or as single elements. Accompanying this were also large mononuclear cells loaded with different quantities of pigment which had apparently escaped from the lymphatic channels within the alveolar walls. These latter cells belong to the wandering endothelial type which are active in phagocytosis for foreign material and which assist so largely in inducing the deposit of carbon in the lungs and lymph glands. A third mononuclear cell appearing early in the reaction was the lymphocyte. The numbers and extent of distribution of this cell were not constant. We have seen it in some of the reactions where very few leucocytes were to be seen, and where it constituted the main infiltrating cell of the alveolar wall or the air sacs. We have previously mentioned its presence in the inflammatory reactions of the bronchi. Here we find it in the early response within the lung tissue and appearing amidst a reaction which is intensely acute. It is not long after the finding of these various cell elements that the polymorphonuclear leucocyte wanders in large droves to numerically overshadow the mononuclear cells. Nevertheless, the three types above mentioned can be recognized in the exudate through the succeeding stages of reactions in the lung. The large macrophage shows its phagocytic properties in taking up numerous red blood cells, lymphocytes and occasional leucocytes.

It is not difficult to demonstrate that the inflammatory reaction within the bronchi and bronchioles precedes the responses within the alveoli. Quite often one may find an acute bronchiolitis with desquamation of the lining epithelium and the early serous exudate lying amidst the lung parenchyma unaffected by any irritant and reaction. There is every evidence that the bacteria reach the lung tissue by extending along the walls of the respiratory tubes and eventually reaching the air sacs either in the distant extremities of the bronchioles or when they have arrived at the thin-walled structures extend through them into the neighboring air sacs.

It is during this early period that we are able to observe the characteristics of the initial inflammatory exudate as we have described it above. The serous exudate and the infiltration by mononuclear cells appear early while the absence of fibrin also attracts attention. In place of fibrin there appeared in a certain number of cases a peculiar material of a hyaline nature which becomes plastered against the borders of the air sacs forming a fairly thick laminated structure and within which thread-formation is not to be seen. Occasionally a few cells lie within this hyaline substance. Some have referred to this as a type of fibrin. We have found, however, that it does not give the staining reactions for fibrin and does not appear to be of the same composition. These masses are tightly welded to the alveolar walls and the borders are often indistinguishable. In part this material appeared to be made up of necrotic cells of the septum which previously had suffered œdema and circulatory interference. We have found in a number of cases hyaline thromboses of the fine capillaries with more or less necrosis of the alveolar septum. At times the septum was entirely destroyed so that a thick hyaline mass alone separated neighboring air sacs. This hyaline necrosis resembles in part the superficial necrosis which was observed along the borders of the denuded bronchi. There is, however, more than necrosis of cells constituting this deposit for the bulk of material eventually deposited is much greater than could arise from tissue cells alone. These hyaline masses have never been found to lie upon the alveolar wall with an intact lining, but it is always accompanied by a loss of the lining cells and more or less destruction of the wall itself. As to the nature of the hyaline deposit which is laid down in lamellae we do not know. Fibrin threads occasionally appear to arise from these hyaline deposits and extend amidst the exudate in the air sac. One cannot assume, however, that the fibrin and the hyaline material have any relation to each other as their chemical characteristics (and mode of deposition) appear to be quite different. It has been suggested by some that this hyaline material represents an imperfectly formed fibrin which has formed a jelly-like clot, not having the property of developing the usual threads.