46 Med. Times and Gazette, vol. i., 1873, p. 58; also Pathol. Soc. Trans., vol. xxvii. p. 70.
47 Med. Times and Gazette, Feb. 8, 1873.
In cardiac dilatation this mode of death is not infrequently seen. It here seems to depend mainly upon stasis of blood caused by weakened power of contractility in the right heart and "by impairment of respiratory and nutritive attraction arising from feeble respiration and arrested tissue-change" (Hayden). The post-mortem revelation has afterward shown cardiac thrombosis to be the efficient cause of death. In diphtheria48 and pneumonia such examples are not infrequently encountered. As Austin Flint49 remarks, however, these coagula present almost identical physical characters with those formed after death, and consequently to fix precisely the moment of their production will at best be but a matter for conjecture. According to Walshe, it would be difficult to determine whether or not some of these almost instantaneous deaths occurred as a coincidence or as an effect. Besides, it is frequently impossible to determine the length of time they have existed before completely obstructing the circulation through the pulmonary artery into the lungs, and hence causing fatal syncopal or asphyxic phenomena. Bristowe50 goes so far even as to affirm in the great majority of cases that cardiac concretions are unaccompanied with appreciable symptoms. In this statement he includes coagula of large size entirely filling one or more of the cardiac cavities, and doubtless formed within a few hours of the final termination. To quote his own words, "We ought to require very strong testimony indeed to convince us in any case that concretions found in the heart at the time of death have caused death, still more to convince us that those clots which resemble in every point the clots which are the mere result of dying have had this effect." How different does this sound from the opinions of B. W. Richardson,51 who attributes so many well-marked symptoms to the formation of voluminous moulded clots in the heart! And, indeed, is it not at variance with the views of a host of the best medical observers? We believe Bristowe goes too far, and that cardiac concretions are not infrequently the cause of very sudden death both in acute and chronic diseases.
48 Robinson, loc. cit.
49 Diseases of the Heart, p. 276, Philada., 1870.
50 Reynolds's System of Medicine, vol. v. p. 113.
51 "Lectures" in the British Medical Journal, 1860.
There are numerous instances in which the coagulum formed in the heart is of smaller size, does not form so rapidly, and besides occupies a position in which, as it does not interfere greatly with the function of the heart, death does not of necessity immediately take place. Little by little, however, the clot is added to, and before many days have elapsed symptoms of gravest import are pronounced. So usual is it for the phenomena connected with the formation of a large cardiac concretion to be accompanied by those which properly belong to another serious affection which may likewise occasion rapid death (pneumonia, endocarditis, typhoid fever, diphtheria, etc.) that we with the greatest difficulty separate the symptoms, and can assign to the intra-cardiac condition those doubtless occasioned by it.
The cases referred to above are not the only ones. Occasionally we meet with cardiac concretions after death which have evidently existed for a number of years, and sometimes without having ever revealed their presence by notable interference with the circulation or in any way affecting the habitual good health of the individual (Laennec52). This is perhaps not to be wondered at when the coagulum is small and situated near the apex of the heart, in one of the auricular appendages, or in such a position as not to alter the play of the cardiac valves or obstruct the orifices. But when we see a whole cavity, as an auricle, forcibly distended by an old concretion which fills its entire cavity, the absence of all symptoms during life pointing to its existence occasions much surprise. Some of these large coagula have nevertheless, by a sudden change in their position, caused instantaneous death; others again, after giving rise to obscure symptoms affecting both the pulmonary and cardiac circulation, have likewise brought about a rapidly fatal termination.53 Sometimes, in consequence of the condensation or atrophy of the clot, the phenomena which took place suddenly with great intensity and indicated its presence became gradually modified, and we have known one remarkable instance in a youth during the third week of an attack of typhoid fever where the accidents thus occasioned completely disappeared, and the patient left the hospital apparently cured.54
52 Dict. Encycl. des Sci. méd., article "Concrétions sanguines."