1601-1607—ROBERT SINCLAIR, A.M., returned to Madderty.
1607-1617—JOHN MONTEATH, A.M., tr. to Monzie.
1617-1623—HENRY ROLLOCK, tr. to Kilconquhar. Nephew of Principal Pollock, Edinburgh.
163?-1649—JOHN GRAHAME, deposed as a Royalist.
16??-1658—JAMES DRUMMOND, A.M., tr. to Muthill.
1655-1680—ARCHD. DRUMMOND, A.M., died.
1680-1686—DAVID FREEBAIRN, A.M., tr. to Dunning.
1686-1688—JOHN RATTRAY, A.M. Ousted for not praying for William and Mary; died 1712.
1700-1705—JAMES MITCHELL, A.M., died July.
1709-1718—JOHN STEDMAN, A.M., died January. Took part in drawing up "Auchterarder Creed," and prepared Presbytery's defence before Commission.